10 ms·
Chip industry had worst sales year since dot-com bubble burst
- crmrc114 7y agoThis article sounds alarmist. "Revenue fell 12% to $412 billion in 2019, the Semiconductor Industry Association said Monday in a statement. That’s the biggest drop since 2001, when industry sales slumped 32% as the dot-com bubble burst." I don't see how 12% is a skyfall number. Especially when compared to 32%. It was pay-walled so I did not read any further.
- JTon 7y ago> It was pay-walled... For others who hit the wall. https://outline.com/VYJEa5 https://outline.com/VYJEa5
- baybal2 7y agoTurn off the javascript on the page.
- kube-system 7y agousing "reader view" in my browser and then refreshing works for me.
- crmrc114 7y agoI did not think that would work- why even bother with the darn paywall! I just guessed that if you disabled js the page would fail to load like other news sites. Anyhow, thank you!
- pjc50 7y agoRevenue falling at all in any tech industry is usually cause for extreme concern, as all the investor numbers assume infinite growth.
- t-writescode 7y agoPerhaps that’s the real problem there. If companies like Intel and AMD are still turning a respectable profit, there’s no cause for actual panic, yet. Investors should learn that intractable P/Es on established companies are, at best, unwise in all but the edge cases.
- totalZero 7y agoP/Es aren't the best way to trade companies like AMD where past earnings are not indicative of future earnings.
- throwaway5752 7y agoLet's stop discussing a hypothetical. Analysts in this space are well aware of the cyclical nature of it, and have better data than some of the companies in question. The premise is false. Cyclical trough/peak earnings normalization is decades old from industrial and resource sectors.
- throwaway5752 7y ago"as all the investor numbers assume infinite growth" This is absolutely not the case in semis.
- cma 7y agoSome of these companies had near monopolies for long stretches of time. If some of that is busted up through competition it could drop revenue while still being healthy. If you're invested broadly in the whole sector you might lose, but if you're invested in the successful challengers you win. If actual demand was lowered rather than just supply changing due to effective competition, then it would be a bigger concern.
- _jal 7y agoWe can argue about adjective choice, but a 12% revenue drop in any industry is going to get people's attention. The environment in which that 32% drop happened involved thousands of companies failing within a short time span. I personally ended up leaving the Bay Area after being out of work for over a year. (I came back.) Just to offer some context to hang those numbers on.
- pascalxus 7y agoI don't see that happening at all currently. The housing market is insane in the bay area, as usual, even out here in the tri-valley area. as far as livermore, houses are selling like hot-cakes, not even on the market for a week.
- _jal 7y agoDidn't intend to imply we're on the edge of a tech-recession or anything close to that. But I'm pretty sure property prices are not a leading indicator of tech crashes. In the first dot.com crash they didn't drop until after the job market carnage was well over. https://www.bayareamarketreports.com/trend/3-recessions-2-bubbles-and-a-baby https://www.bayareamarketreports.com/trend/3-recessions-2-bu...
- wyxuan 7y agoCould be that Intel chip supply shortages, and decreased average sale prices (due to AMD offerings) could be the reason for this. Not as many people upgrading as inter generational gains start to level off.
- zozbot234 7y agoI think embedded systems account for the vast majority of chip production, so any dynamics involving Intel/AMD would be very minor.
- Retric 7y agoEmbedded chips are generally cheap. CPU’s sell for ~1,000x the price of most embedded chips. X00$ CPU vs X0c 32 bit microprocessors / microcontroller etc.
- siracusa23 7y ago10c 32-bit microcontroller from Intel/AMD? Have I been buying the wrong chips? Care to share some links? EDIT: commenter above edited their post, mentioned $.10 MCUs from Intel/AMD
- Retric 7y agoI edited the comment for clarity, but never mentioned Intel or AMD.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoAll right, X0 c 32-bit microcontrollers from whom?
- mooibos 7y agoCypress, Microchip, STM... Really, take your pick.
- jackhack 7y agoAgreed, this news doesn't square with market performance. For instance, FSELX (Fidelity Select Semiconductors portfolio) mutual fund is up 43% over one year, doubling the performance of the S&P500. Top-10 holdings (68%) include Intel, Qualcomm, Broadcom, Nvidia, Micron, Marvell, ON, NXP, FLex, Commscope, so it's a fairly broad measure. For this cross-section to be performing so strongly, others must be circling the drain if indeed the industry is turning down steeply. I'm not seeing that.
- totalZero 7y agoIn saying that there cannot be a turndown because stocks are rallying, you are not comparing apples to apples. Companies can circle the drain while their stock rallies. Companies can do good business while their stock gets crushed. First, people are buying equities in general because interest rates are being held low artificially by the Fed, which has been pressured by the President to do this. Second, few traders and investors understand how to differentiate semiconductor companies, so when it blows, it will all blow. People get out of crowded trades chaotically. Investors and traders, who are largely unsophisticated about the specific technologies that each company develops and markets, will punish the sector rather than choosing individual names to sell. I will say it again: most people who trade tech professionally have no fucking clue what these companies actually build. They look at numbers, watch earnings reports, and listen to buzzword-laden commentary from research analysts. Look at Apple. Their supply chain is threatened by factory shutdowns and a huge market of theirs has basically been put on ice, but their stock is near all-time highs. They haven't made a game-changing product since the days of Steve Jobs, and people usually say their value now comes from their execution. But how can you execute if your suppliers are shut down and one of your major markets is closed for business? INTC is facing tons of pressure in enterprise and PC from AMD, their 10nm has been a disaster for them, and yet their stock popped 9% on earnings due to cloud demand. It's trading near dot-com bubble levels. They are getting hurt in their competition vs TSMC on fab, and losing market share to AMD, yet their stock is like a rocket ship. Doesn't this seem weird? QCOM has been hit hard by several regulators and in a number of lawsuits for its IP bullying, it has come out and said that coronavirus is going to hurt smartphone manufacturing and sales, and yet its stock is trading near all-time highs. Don't ever confuse stock performance with company performance. Boeing stock is trading at more than double where it was when the 737 Max 8 took its first flight four years ago.
- baybal2 7y agoI wrote before that semiconductor industry economists were awaiting a crash for a very long time. At least since 2016, I saw notion of a coming crash coming from very esteemed industry publications that cost few thousand bucks to access. Everybody in semi knows of the cyclical nature of the industry, and the non-stop long bull run since 2008 looked very unusual to many. Why is this so important? The reason is that few years ago, the industry committed itself to the biggest capital infusion in history with EUV. Those fabs costs tenths of billions, and take years to build. They are never ever constructed without an extremely thorough research done with top tier economists.
- totalZero 7y ago> They are never ever constructed without an extremely thorough research done with top tier economists. EUV is necessary to keep up with Moore's Law expectations.
- baybal2 7y agoYes, as I understood, the industry people thought that it's now or never. From one side, there was a long held reservation to poor money waiting for the cycle to restart, but the end of the cycle was not seemed coming despite everybody showing that the conditions for it were there.
- rossdavidh 7y agoWell, some parts of the industry did. Some just opted out. Every generation of lithography sees a few companies say "forget it" and step off the treadmill, either moving to a fabless model (pay others to make your stuff), or consigning themselves to legacy parts only. This has resulted in a long term concentration of semi manufacturing among fewer and fewer companies. Even Global Foundries (the company) decided to hold off on EUV.
- lwb 7y ago> tenths of billions Do you mean tens of billions? The difference is two orders of magnitude :)
- tjpaudio 7y agoThanks for the post, tipped me off to the current rock-bottom ram prices to max out the ram of my desktop I built 5 years ago.
- pkaye 7y agoI used to work in the semiconductor equipment industry in the 90s and it was quite cyclical. One year the demand was great and they were hiring like crazy and the next year things were looking dismal and they had to do layoffs. This repeated many times though the overall trend was of growth. I managed to stick around for some time since I was in R&D and with a bit of luck. Things smoothed out considerably over the decades.
- dylan604 7y agoDoes this follow companies not buying new equipment annually, but wait a couple of years inbetween before the next upgrade?
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoI'm not sure why all companies would be on the same cycle of upgrading. You would assume they would all be offset and it wouldn't make a difference in sales.
- ksec 7y ago>Revenue fell 12% to $412 billion in 2019, ....That’s the biggest drop since 2001, when industry sales slumped 32% as the dot-com bubble burst. In 2001 post Dot Com Bubble, that 32% drop was real. The 12% drop in 2019 was only due to NAND and RAM went from Record High and back to "normal". Samsung was the most profitable company in 2018 simply because NAND and DRAM. Almost everyone in Semiconductor industry is making fairly decent amount of profits and increase unit shipment in 2019. Look at look at the leading Foundry ( TSMC ) and Intel all making record profits and shipment. Bloomberg is quickly becoming BuzzFeed for financial news.
- mrspeaker 7y agoI know we're being trained to hate journalists these days, but that quoted sentence is just stating a fact: the biggest drop since dotcom bubble... and the article reads very reasonable. I don't see anything controversial in there - seems to balance the negatives with things like "the rate of decline abated" and "the decline in industry sales didn’t stop investors betting on a future rebound." - how is that sensationalist? Maybe they could have reported it as "19th best year since dot com bubble"?
- thrustmaster 7y agoBy "being trained" do you really mean that we are thinking more critically about the information fed to us?
- mrspeaker 7y agoWe've always been trained to think critically about media (I even had classes on it in high school - one called "critical thinking"!). Seems like now it's just "hate journalists" not "think critically". If something doesn't fit your world view, just ad hominem it. I'm hoping I'm just imagining it though (confirmation bias!), and it's really always been like this.
- stevenjohns 7y agoIt might have something to do with social media making it more obvious that journalists and news agencies are usually partisan and agenda-focused rather than neutral and content-focused. Political journalism (domestic US and international) has completely gone to shit. Tech journalism has slowly fizzled away into just clickbait and financial news has slowly drifted towards interpreting Ouija boards and magic 8-balls.
- fokinsean 7y agohmmm every time I'm at the store I see like 3 new brands of chips I've never seen before.
- Rafuino 7y agoThis must be mostly attributable to the massive NAND and DRAM prices falls in 2019.
- swiley 7y agoNo one can innovate when they can’t understand. No one can understand when they can’t read the data sheets for chips they don’t use. Want people to build things with your crap? Don’t fight them when they try.
- adammunich 7y agoThis absolutely. The chip people always make custom protocols for /everything/.
- swiley 7y agoCustom protocols are not really the end of the world, it’s when they make a custom protocol and then use copyright to force you to do certain things in order to use it.
- adammunich 7y agoThey really do slow down development though, and flrxe you to hire specialists who can make sense of the often terse datasheets.
- selectodude 7y agoWouldn't a lot of the complexity be due to the fact that these are likely the most complex pieces of engineering on earth?
- makapuf 7y agoComplexity and nicely written datasheets /doc are tractable. Obfuscated docs and average complexity is cryptic.
- lowdose 7y agoAre you talking about NVIDIA and their Cuda stack or some another manufacturer?
- riku_iki 7y agoI run this site, where we track public companies revenues, and Q3 2019 shows -8% drop in revenue for semiconductors segment, but it can be because Q3 2018 had +15% Y/Y: https://finintelligence.com/app/segment/2873229239 https://finintelligence.com/app/segment/2873229239
- cgh 7y agoCoincidentally, I've been wondering about dumping some cash into a semiconductor ETF like eg the VanEck offering (SMH). I noticed that there are leveraged ETFs like SOXL that magnify returns and I typically associate these riskier offering with precious metals and so forth. I hadn't realised that semiconductors seem to fall into that same "cyclical commodity" category.
- Vysero 7y agoIf only the US had the infrastructure to do everything from mining the materials all the way up the chain to building custom PC’s, wouldn’t that be cool? If we could do everything “in house” so to speak?
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoSeems like it should be a priority for homeland security really...
- Vysero 7y agoNot sure about you guys but I would be willing to pay a premium if I knew that every part in my computer was created right here in my own country.
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoPretty nasty pressure move to strangle your rival's access to chips. New foundries can't be built over night.
- neonate 7y agohttps://archive.md/3Ms5l https://archive.md/3Ms5l
- kpmcc 7y ago"hurt by a trade war between the largest chip producer, the U.S., and the largest consumer, China" This sentence confuses me. Seems like they have it backwards. Can someone clear this up?
- trynumber9 7y agoIt depends. Do you include Taiwan in China or not? If not, then yes. In fact, U.S. is the largest manufacturer of semiconductors. In 2018, nearly half of the total semiconductor market was occupied by firms based in the U.S., according to the Factbook2019 of SIA.
- anonsivalley652 7y agoQuestion: why then are there recent media reports that DDR4 and SSD prices going to be increased? Is this Samsung's unilateral oligopolic move, another price fixing event, a ploy to stimulate panic buying and/or some other structural move related to real ability to supply? (Yes, I remember the hyper-commodification DRAM price wars and price fixing of years gone by.)
- baybal2 7y agoRepost from: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20630279 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20630279 Semiconductor industry is a very reliable canary for the long term economic situation. Semi industry employs top economists. It is critically important for them to have extremely thorough economics research when they decide on their financials. Fabs cost billions, and whole fab complexes close to $10B. They take many years to construct and make running. Financing plans for them have to be done impeccably, and account for way more than capital forecasts. The financial outlook for a fab changes dramatically depending on how the world changes during its construction. The few fragments of such report done for TSMC I saw included everything down to political, cultural, and technological black swan events. One of the most bizarre one that they actually managed to predict was the current regulatory and sociocultural "dotcom backlash". For example, they see big server chip buyers like Facebook, Amazon, Google greatly scaling down their ambitions, and therefore they did not include the option for big reticle sizes in their lithography equipment buy list.
- Animats 7y agoHere's the historical total graph, not the year to year change graph.[1] Unclear if this is constant dollars. That's from the World Semiconductor Trade Association, which collects statistics and resells them, expensively. The Bloomberg article is what you get from the free tier, press releases. [1] https://www.wsts.org/ https://www.wsts.org/
- jhallenworld 7y agoThere is interesting news about Xilinx specifically: they are no longer allowed to sell the Huawei, so their stock declined recently. The consequence is that Huawei needs to switch to home-grown ASICs, and I'm sure the pressure is on for a high-end home-grown FPGA vendor. So this is just one company, but I'm wondering if tariffs in general are a part of this decline. https://epsnews.com/2019/10/28/xilinx-cuts-huawei-from-future-forecasts/ https://epsnews.com/2019/10/28/xilinx-cuts-huawei-from-futur... https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/20/business/economy/trump-us-china-deal-micron-trade-war.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/20/business/economy/trump-us...
- Bombthecat 7y agoUhhhh I think it is because everyone is waiting for the next gen consoles of Xbox and PlayStation. There are even rumors for a Nintendo switch "x" And they all need chips.. And electric vehicles are also slowly catching up. They need chips too. Its not a bubble burst, just a generation change (and wait)