5 ms·
Ask HN: How to take your privacy back?
As we saw in the recent discussions https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22236106 or https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20794937, all browsers do kinky stuff in the background that the user has not initiated nor is aware of. It is one thing to ping home to see if there is an update available but that is not even close to what is happening. And it does not matter if you are using firefox or brave. They all do it.
Then there is the Windows, the big daddy of spyware, that sends everything about you directly to Microsoft. They just rebranded spying on its users as "telemetry" to brainwash people into thinking it is not as bad as they think it is.
Anyhow, it looks like it is impossible to simply sit in front of Wireshark and try to manually blacklist everything you see. There are millions of domains and sub-domains these companies use to spy on you one way or the other so it is a fools errand.
Hence the question arises - is it even possible to get your privacy back? Are there tools would that allow you to do that or should we just forfeit our privacy altogether and forget it even existed in the first place?
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoPihole is still a really nice fire and forget solution for your network. It costs nearly nothing and you outsource the question about what to block to the lists they source. A network-based blocker will also block your OS’ bad behavior, such as calls to telemetry domains. And then, you know, don’t use Chrome. A browser from an ad company will always be compromised by design.
- thretgreegre 7y agothat IS a solution, but it requires another piece of hardware. I believe there must be a solution that could provide the same via virtual network driver(like VirtualBox).
- hprotagonist 7y agoLittleSnitch?
- cipherboy 7y agoIf you wanted to go that route (and don't care about the small performance hit or are willing to dual boot to play games)... Try QubesOS and pihole together: - https://www.qubes-os.org/ https://www.qubes-os.org/ - https://blog.tufarolo.eu/how-to-configure-pihole-in-qubesos-proxyvm/ https://blog.tufarolo.eu/how-to-configure-pihole-in-qubesos-... It should let you do exactly that: local pihole to monitor and block traffic from all VMs. (I haven't tried it. I went the route of a separate pihole enabled network behind my cable modem as I have other devices I'd like to block traffic on too.)
- iwalton3 7y agoYou can install a hosts file on your computer blacklisting many of the domains in the PI hole system, although if you use the largest blacklists you'll probably have performance issues. You can also install a local DNS server like dnsmasq and set that up to block websites. There are also external DNS providers that provide blacklisting similar to PI Hole. (Although then you are trusting the DNS provider not to track you.)
- SamPatt 7y agoTrue, but the hardware is cheap and extremely simple to setup. The entire process took me maybe one hour and cost probably $40 if you include the SD card and Ethernet cable too.
- beatgammit 7y agoYou can install Pihole on whatever device you want. The difficulty is having it be up 24/7 since it going down will break your access to the internet, so a separate device is usually simpler.
- drKarl 7y agoYou can use some of those crowdsourced lists of hosts files to ban trackers, ad networks, and the like, i.e. https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts or https://github.com/notracking/hosts-blocklists https://github.com/notracking/hosts-blocklists, you can use pi-hole even as a docker container https://github.com/pi-hole/docker-pi-hole https://github.com/pi-hole/docker-pi-hole or install it in your router. You can use privacy plugins and extensions for browsers, like umatrix, etc. You can use Tails, which uses 2 VMs. You can use a VPN service (that's controversial since you then put your trust on the VPN provider), or roll your own with something like algo from trailofbits, or streisand. You can combine multiple VPNs an/or Tor, with VMs. Mirimir wrote some articles on that setup. If you want to go full in you can use QubesOS, although now Joanna Rutkowska left the team. I'm sure there are other options...
- drKarl 7y agoAlso use a linux phone like Librem 5 or Pinephone (still early days for both), or root an android phone and flash it with a custom ROM. Best option for security and privacy is GrapheneOS but only supports Pixel phones. LineageOS supports lots of devices. There are others.
- nostrapollo 7y agoIf the assumption is that browsers track because it benefits the company commercially, it would be really cool if a company produced a browser at a premium that didn't do all of the above - this model must exist already? Privacy for a price sounds like a bad precedent to set though.
- darau1 7y agoUnless the software is open source and only community supported, it's the only precedent that makes financial sense.
- beatgammit 7y agoWhich is precisely why I use Firefox. Once you disable Pocket, I think you can be reasonably sure the browser isn't tracking you, but websites surely do. If you want to limit websites tracking you, your best option IMO is Tor Browser, which is also based on Firefox. If you want the "paid" option, Brave apparently tries to reward content creators for good advertising behavior, while blocking bad ads.
- nostrapollo 7y agoHere's a guide: https://restoreprivacy.com/firefox-privacy/ https://restoreprivacy.com/firefox-privacy/
- tiborsaas 7y ago> Privacy for a price sounds like a bad precedent to set though. If you think about it, it's not. The lack of privacy is because people expect things for free.
- vearwhershuh 7y agoIn increasing level of commitment/difficulty: - Use brave as your browser - Use a VPN w/ tracker blocking DNS - Move to protonmail or fastmail - Start using Signal for your instant messsaging - Start using Tor (but that might get you on the list) - Stop buying everything through Amazon - Install and use piHole (and marvel at how much traffic your wifi router sends to home base) - Suck it up and move to linux You are still going to be tracked, but these are the things I can think of that might help.
- SamPatt 7y ago>stop buying everything through Amazon Indeed. I'll plug OpenBazaar here, a p2p marketplace built on IPFS, as well as Haven, the mobile app version focusing on privacy.
- PatentlyDC123 7y agoI'm still reticent to go with Brave because of their Basic Attention Token system. Do you think Firefox could be a viable alternative with uBlock and other privacy protecting plugins?
- vearwhershuh 7y agoYes, I think that's a reasonable alternative. Certainly much better than nothing.
- beatgammit 7y agoEh, I think moving to Linux is easier than many of those things, especially "start using Signal" since it has issues with the network effect. In fact, I'd put Signal at the end of the list. Sure, you can use it as an SMS frontend, but that doesn't really give you any privacy benefits.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rglullis 7y agoOne project I started but stopped due to some (in my view) limitation of IPFS is https://bitbucket.org/lullis/nofollow https://bitbucket.org/lullis/nofollow. It started as a "read-it-later" service that would extract the content and bookmark any page you wanted but afterwards the idea that it could be used as a distributed, curated, web of "clean" and tracker-free html documents. Basically, every web page you saved on your instance would be saved on your IPFS server as well and it wouldn't be hard to write an extension to check if any url you want to open has already a cleaned version on IPFS. So, with more people installing/using this system, the more the different instances would collect pages and more people with the extension could go on without needing to visit any site that could actually track you. What pulled me off this (besides "regular" work and family) was the fact that IPFS does not have yet any sort of ACL for your pinned content. As it is now, your node will serve anyone that asks for content that you have. If you are pinning content from different websites it would be quick to make you a target for copyright lawsuits. I still use my own instance, but at the moment it is just something that does more or less the same as Wallabag. I do wish I get some time to make it more useful for more people though.
- throwaway9d0291 7y agoIt's relatively straightforward: where possible, stop using products and services that don't respect your privacy and instead use ones that do. Where you can, reduce their ability to compromise your privacy with ad-blockers, custom DNS or by disabling JavaScript. Windows has telemetry? Use Linux. Firefox has tracking? Use IceWeasel. Every website wants to track you? Disable Javascript. Google tracks your every move? Stop using Google products. Yes, in many cases this will lead to some degree of inconvenience or perhaps a service that meets a particular need doesn't exist. That's the price you have to pay in modern times but it is a price you're able to pay, if you value privacy sufficiently.
- silicon2401 7y agoWhat are the privacy costs to using FF? Also, what's a good alternative to Google docs/etc? Should I VPN into a home machine using open/libre office?
- throwaway9d0291 7y agoI don't know, I was just taking the poster's claims at face value. There are self-hosted alternatives to Google Docs, like OwnCloud with Etherpad.
- mus1cfl0w 7y agoI can highly recommend the Privacy, Security & OSINT Show but it really depends on how far you want to go: https://www.inteltechniques.com/podcast.html https://www.inteltechniques.com/podcast.html