4 ms·
The difference is that soft-left progressive purity spirals tend to end with online bullying, while authoritarian purity spirals tend to end with people getting
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
The difference is that soft-left progressive purity spirals tend to end with online bullying, while authoritarian purity spirals tend to end with people getting killed.
Admittedly there is some overlap where people lose their jobs.
Of course there has to a collective standard for morality. The problem with purity spirals and witch hunts is that they stop looking at specific criminal acts - slavery, theft, murder, and rape aren't morally justifiable, however you slice it - and become more about group conformity and public professions of ideology.
Dissent, debate, and non-conformity become immoral acts in themselves - and that is not a valid moral position.
- Tomte 7y ago> The difference is that soft-left progressive purity spirals tend to end with online bullying, while authoritarian purity spirals tend to end with people getting killed. That's the classic left—right apology. I find both wrong. Just as I don't think you get to burn down cars, just because other people are bashing other peoples' skulls in. For some reason, a large part of the extreme left pays lip-service to non-violence, but is always quick to deflect criticism about left violence by pointing to (more extreme) right violence. I don't find that convincing and believe both sides need to be locked up. Sure, the murderers longer than the car burners.
- jeegsy 7y ago> For some reason, a large part of the extreme left pays lip-service to non-violence, but is always quick to deflect criticism about left violence by pointing to (more extreme) right violence. THIS! I'm not on the right but I've always felt that one of the right's biggest tactical errors was to allow their movement to be be seen as the violent side. Nothing in history that I've seen would suggest that the right, even the extreme right, is inherently prone to violence and yet this point is made frequently, casually by even fair minded people.