5 ms·
Totally agreed. We ended up funding the web with an attention/gullibility tax not because of an careful planning, but because the technology wasn't there for an
by wpietri 7y ago
Totally agreed. We ended up funding the web with an attention/gullibility tax not because of an careful planning, but because the technology wasn't there for anything else.
For quite a while I've been very conscious about paying for things I like, things I think are good in the world. Subscriptions for sure. Patreon to support individuals. And I just signed up for Scroll, which sends money every month to the sites I browse: https://scroll.com/ https://scroll.com/
If ads die (which I'm 100% in favor of), then people will figure out how to support the things they really like and care about. And the rest will die off.
- tadzik_ 7y agoScroll is looking interesting – reminds me a bit of Brave, but with a more specialized “websites renderer”, so to say. Is there a list of sites they support available somewhere, so that I can see if it's useful to me?
- mav3rick 7y agoVast majority of the world can't afford paying for every website
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoWebsites existed before online ads were a thing.
- kmlx 7y agoyes, but the current penetration didn't. if you think the future is asking people from Rwanda to pay 5 bucks a month to read a single online newspaper, or get access to Reddit then I guess you're in for a rude awakening.
- shadowgovt 7y agoThis is what concerns me most about ad blocking. "In a world without ads, people will just pay their own way" is elitist thinking. Most people online have nothing of value to exchange except their attention.
- ChuckNorris89 7y ago1) How will it cost to read the newspaper 5$ in Rwanda? That's the price of a monthly subscription in Germany. 2) If said people can't afford 5$/month how will they afford the stuff ads are targeting them to buy?
- bawolff 7y ago90% of everything is crap, and websites are a thing so 90% of them are crap. So its ok if they die. Then again, neither wikipedia nor <s>youtubr</s>hacker news have ads and that's like half of what i read on the internet right there. Edit: this is what happens when i try to post while falling asleep. Meant to say hn not youtube. Youtube definitely has ads
- genghizkhan 7y ago> Then again, neither wikipedia nor youtubr have ads and that's like half of what i read on the internet right there. Don't know which YouTube you use, but the one I do does have ads.
- glenneroo 7y agoI also don't ever have to deal with ads - perhaps because I also have a (seldom used or visited) channel?
- nomadluap 7y agouBlock Origin seems to block all advertising on Youtube for me, including pre-roll and intermission ads in the videos. The only advertising I see on youtube these days is the sponsored sections inserted by the video creators.
- pwm 7y agoI don't really watch that much youtube but now that my son watches some cartoons on it I've subscribed to premium so he doesn't see any ads. I think it's ok to pay for youtube as it arguably provides a useful service. I also know that I'm in a privileged position to be able to pay for youtube premium, so my comment is not about whether ads are inherently bad or not, just that you can watch youtube without ads if you pay for it.
- jefftk 7y agoHN has ads: they're the job posts that appear on the front page without voting buttons
- wpietri 7y agoSure. Which means we'll end up with some sort of system where that's not necessary. Remember, the marginal cost of production for a web site visit is zero. It's also important to remember that the vast majority of journalists and would-be journalists currently can't afford to do journalism. We need to solve both the consumer and producer problems.
- shadowgovt 7y agoWhat should the people who have nothing of value to exchange but their attention use for currency?
- wpietri 7y agoThe marginal cost of rendering another web page is zero, so economically there's no reason for them to pay anything. Further, the attention of a perfectly broke version has a value of zero. Since advertisers are still paying for it, you could argue those hypothetical people are harming a website by viewing it: they bring the yield of ads down, encouraging advertisers to only support things for rich people.
- shadowgovt 7y ago> The marginal cost of rendering another web page is zero, so economically there's no reason for them to pay anything. Tragedy of the commons. The marginal cost to render another page is zero, but if 100% of pages pay nothing, the server is run at a loss. As a result, only pages that can get "stuck in" alongside revenue-positive content (or pages on a whole server operating at a loss with revenue generated via some other source) can survive (i.e. a patronage model). > Further, the attention of a perfectly broke [person] has a value of zero In addition to direct encouragement for consumers to buy something (what is called "conversion"), advertising is also used to shape public perception and garner general interest. Coke doesn't consider an ad vended to a broke person to have zero value, because their product becomes the thing that person will ask for if someone offers them a free beverage of their choice, and it becomes the thing they'll generally recognize as "a soda" over alternatives when the topic comes up at all. The Ad Council's products are generally not about getting a broke person to spend money, but to shape their behavior ("this is your brain on drugs," "#DanceLikeaDad," etc.).
- wpietri 7y ago> Tragedy of the commons. Possibly, but not necessarily. The tragedy of the commons applies when there's a non-zero marginal cost. But with zero marginal cost, you have have to find some way to cover your expenses, and then you can give away the rest as a public good. E.g., the NYT can happily give away a ton of pageviews to non-subscribers as long as they keep their subscriber base up. Public radio, another medium with zero marginal cost, has been giving away their content for decades. > Coke doesn't consider an ad vended to a broke person to have zero value [citation needed] I highly doubt Coke thinks that way. There is approximately nobody who sees their ads that is so permanently destitute that they will never have the opportunity to buy a soda. Indeed, at least in the US, the poor are better customers than the well off. About 2/3rds of people below $30k in income drink soda, while only about half of people over $75k do. https://news.gallup.com/poll/163997/regular-soda-popular-young-nonwhite-low-income.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/163997/regular-soda-popular-you...
- tripzilch 7y ago> Totally agreed. We ended up funding the web with an attention/gullibility tax not because of an careful planning, but because the technology wasn't there for anything else. That implies it was even needed. It wasn't the same people either, the online ad industry is a bunch of greedy fucks with dollars in their eyes, they came to the web like a swarm of locusts.