3 ms·
To be fair, a political solution would also fix the problem. So would a religious solution. Any solution would fix the problem - because the word "solution" imp
by eesmith 7y ago
To be fair, a political solution would also fix the problem. So would a religious solution. Any solution would fix the problem - because the word "solution" implies that the problem has been fixed.
One problem is that people don't agree on what an economics-based solution should be. There have been any number of proposed economics-based solutions to other problems which have exacerbated the problem.
Let's take "expanding housing supply". What kind of housing? From https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/housing-crisis-london-high-rise-luxury-developments-property-local-councils-austerity-a8618171.html https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/housing-crisis-london-h... :
> More than 500 high-rise developments are in progress across the city of London. For a nation in the grip of a housing crisis, this should be good news. But in reality, this will bring hardly any benefit for many of those seeking a decent home. Almost none of the new homes are reserved for people with no or low incomes and, although house prices in London are falling – particularly at the upper end of the market – construction for wealthy people and international buyers continues.
> Much of this building is actually intensifying the stress on the affordable housing market, as developers grab cheap land and resources that can be converted into expensive, for-profit housing construction.
And for land-value tax, well, see the criticism at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax#Practical_issues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax#Practical_issue... :
Several practical issues are involved in the implementation of a land value tax.
> Most notably, it must be: - Calculated fairly and accurately; - High enough to raise sufficient revenue without causing land abandonment; - Billed to the correct person or business entity
How is it calculated fairly in the face of "evil landlords [and] corrupt politicians"?
- xvedejas 7y agoAs far as I can tell, it is a myth that building high-income-targeting housing does not help, in aggregate, low-income earners. See the concept of filtering, which is well-studied and sees two effects: 1. middle-high-income households moving into more expensive units, middle-low-income into the space left over from that move, etc. 2. the slower effect of declining values from aging housing stock. Okay, but you're still skeptical. I do honestly understand, you probably should be; I definitely don't regard myself as the best person to argue about these things. Knowing that, I should make a less ambitious case on this one and point out that "grabbing cheap land" for expensive construction is far better than letting it go empty and not contribute via taxes to the local government's coffers. And yes, I'm aware of the criticism of LVT. But isn't it obvious? If we have politicians who are virtuous enough to enact an LVT, I think we've tunneled into an alternate reality operated by saints, so that just about resolves itself.
- eesmith 7y agoThere are other downstream consequences. Consider in a simple model two cities, A and Z, which are next to each other. In A, the city focuses on high-end housing. It's successful. Rich people move to A. Rents go up on older housing, to meet the market demand, including the temptation to sell the plot, raze the structure, and build new high-end housing. As a result, poorer people move to the more affordable Z. This is exactly what's predicted in your #1. Since the expensive housing is in A, that city gets more tax money, which goes to schools, libraries, parks, etc. Z doesn't have that revenue source, so ends up with worse quality schools, libraries, parks, etc. The citizens of city A all have cars, and don't like all the non-residents coming through and using "their" libraries, parks, etc. so convert most streets to cul-de-sac versions and don't provide mass transit. The citizens of Z, many with service worker jobs in A, must therefore buy cars in order to keep their jobs. Which lowers their overall income, and makes it harder to save up money. Z responds by building more low-cost housing, but this is further away from A (where the jobs are), and doesn't address the unequal tax base. > But isn't it obvious? Well, yes. That is my point. I pointed out that if you assume you have a solution, then of course there's a solution. Remember, you argued "You could have the most evil landlords, corrupt politicians, and aloof newcomers, and an economic solution would still fix the problem." What economic solution is there if you have normal people? Not saints, and not demons.
- eesmith 7y agoHere's another downstream consequence, for London. When a lot is converted to high-end apartments, the population density may go down. For example, what may have been an apartment house for 20 families (5 floors, 4 per floor) may be 10 or even 5. Or, as is the case in London, the apartment may be occupied only occasionally. Neighborhood business often depend on local traffic. If there are fewer people, then there is less need for barbershops, and corner shops, and the like. Owners may need to quit, sell their property, and move elsewhere. These are stressful. Grocery stores may switch to high-end/expensive foods. As a result, the non-rich who live there have fewer options, and a lower quality of life. Now, this may not be a problem for those who use economics to maximize "gross domestic product" or other easily measured value. But it may worsen, say, "Gross National Happiness." Economics doesn't guide us on what to maximize. That's what politics does.
- hcknwscommenter 7y ago>How is it calculated fairly in the face of "evil landlords [and] corrupt politicians"? Really? That part is trivial. In the US, your local municipality and/or county has very detailed data on each parcel of land. Occasionally, there is a data error, but if you have ever looked up your assessors records, they are pretty darn accurate. PLus, we all have readily accessible satellite data now.
- eesmith 7y agoQuoting the Wikipedia article I linked to, Assessment/appraisal is "still easily distorted by corrupt politicians through the excuse of the complex coding."