6 ms·
> And while many factors are at play—most notably, a giant influx of new residents and a shortage of housing—Berliners tend to see greedy landlords as the probl
by epistasis 7y ago
> And while many factors are at play—most notably, a giant influx of new residents and a shortage of housing—Berliners tend to see greedy landlords as the problem.
This is a much better direction to focus their anger than other residents, at least.
There's a lot of NIMBYism in all of us, and in SF that hatred of change has found a lot of people having the newcomers, rather than the landlords that set the prices, or the politicians that set the markets so that landlords have massively growing profits.
- harryh 7y agoLandlords don't set prices. They are price takers in the market just as much as tenants.
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoLandlords set the prices by preventing new construction that would lower their prices.
- matchbok 7y agoUh, landlords don't control new construction. Government and NIMBYs do. Landlords would gladly accept new development because... it would let them make more money?
- n4r9 7y agoHere in the UK we have a chronic issue with a lack of new housing developments, alongside issues like poor rental conditions. We also have a very strong "landlord lobby", and a sizeable proportion of landlords in the ruling party, which get in the way of fixing either issue because it means less return for landlords from the assets they currently own.
- ch4s3 7y ago> Uh, landlords don't control new construction. Government and NIMBYs do Well, government and highly engaged groups of voters exercise control in municipalities in Western democracies. Landlords come in many stripes and some are local voters who hold land/property. These landlords are often NIMBYs, as any increase in supply of housing drives down the asset price of housing/land, which is to say their investments. MOst of these landlords aren't in the position to take advantage of liberalized zoning, as the are undercapitalized relative to the cost of land/construction. All of their financial eggs tend be in the basket of their existing property. Larger landlords, or developers/real estate firms may well favor liberalized zoning as they profit from development. However, at the moment many voters hate developers, sometimes for good reasons. In a sense, we're in a bit of a pickle.
- mandelbrotwurst 7y agoNot necessarily, depends on which landlords, their access to capital and interest in / ability to obtain ownership over additional properties. If you have a single rental property and no interest or ability in obtaining any additional, then you're going to make less money if new development increases supply and prices go down.
- epistasis 7y agoIn a shortage, like Berlin's, the landlords have much more ability to set prices than the tenants do. And in particular they now have the ability to set higher prices, which is the particular act that angers residents.
- TomMckenny 7y agoPrices are set by the Property Management Software SaaS that all landlords use. So it is a Cartel. That is why prices rise even in places where population drops and vacancies rise. This can't be a surprise, vast swathes of the economy have fallen into virtual monopoly over that last few decades. By the way, I think we can extrapolate candidate Bloomberg's (non)position on the housing issue here.
- toasterlovin 7y agoC'mon. Landlords are not a cartel. If a landlord can't fill a unit because renters won't pay what they ask, then they have every reason to lower the price until the unit is filled. Because some rent is better than no rent.
- TomMckenny 7y agoThis theory is simply not correct, the market is broken. Even flint Michigan has lost 1/5 of it's population since 2000 and rent has still risen. Just show me some towns where the market works. The use of that software has exactly the same outcome as a cartel but, understandably, few people want to acknowledge that even to themselves.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bmn__ 7y ago> they have every reason to lower the price until the unit is filled That's the behaviour of the completely rational homo economicus which does not exist in real life. A certain amount of landlords of walk-in business space in Manhattan have a fixed price in their mind and will not go below, no matter what.
- smegma2 7y agoWouldn't it be likely for another more rational landlord to exploit that opportunity then? Or are there some barriers?
- xvedejas 7y agoWhen will people stop looking for scapegoats and start finding solutions? Needlessly high rents are an economics problem, and there's a lot of evidence that a combination of expanding housing supply and imposing a Land Value Tax would be an actual economic solution. You could have the most evil landlords, corrupt politicians, and aloof newcomers, and an economic solution would still fix the problem. Sometimes I wonder whether nobody cares to try and solve the problem, symbolic political wars being more urgent.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoOnly allow individuals to own, not companies. If you want to let a unit, rent control with rate increases permitted annually that peg to inflation. Mandatory reporting and regulation through the local housing authority. That’s about all you can do if there’s no will to build but you don’t want corporate or private landlords gouging renters when demand outstrips supply. Life ain’t fair, everyone isn’t going to be able to live exactly where they want to. Scarcity leads to rationing. Disclaimer: Landlord who charges reasonable rents and tries to upzone where I operate.
- austhrow743 7y agoIndividuals owning is what leads to political pressure to not build. Discouraging individual ownership of housing is the way to affordable rent. Not encouraging it.
- xvedejas 7y agoYou're going to have major problems no matter what when there's demand and no political ability to build. A Land Value Tax can still in this situation put the landlord surplus back into city welfare/projects without raising rents.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThe tax is unhelpful if it isn’t used to increase supply; it’s simply government rent seeking instead of landlord rent seeking.
- matchbok 7y agoLandlords do not set prices. If you owned property or a rental you would know that.