3 ms·
I worry that adblocking ultimately hurts only the little sites. Google and Facebook have first party ads which could be made significantly more tricky to block.
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
I worry that adblocking ultimately hurts only the little sites. Google and Facebook have first party ads which could be made significantly more tricky to block. Or Google could use Chrome’s dominance to slowly switch over to a variation of Encrypted Media Extensions, which is impossible to interfere with.
- Larrikin 7y agoGoogle already does the latter on mobile. Every single one of their apps defaults to forcing a Chrome tab open instead of your preferred browser. Chrome on mobile doesn't offer extensions like Firefox does. I only recently discovered there is an option to turn off this behavior but its only a matter of time until they remove that option.
- nsomaru 7y agoIs this documented anywhere? Was trying to help a friend on android but I couldn’t find the setting
- nelblu 7y agoI am not sure whether that is true. I don't have Chrome on my android and firefox is my default browser. So all apps load firefox in app Page when they are navigating to an outside url.
- Larrikin 7y agoMost apps respect your preferences. The tab action to keep you in the app will typically give you a tab of your default web browser if your preferred browser has implemented it. Gmail and Google search specifically open a powered by chrome tab when you click on links unless you look around deep in the settings to turn off this user hostile feature.
- eitland 7y agoSmall sites can put in the effort to make deals with individual advertisers and bake it right into the page. Usually when I or others bring this up someone says: but then you are leaving behind the value of serving customized ads for each user. To to which I counter: - ads baked into the page would probably slip by my ad blocker, and more importantly, as long as they are relevant and not annoying I'd probably not even care to try to get rid of them. There exist a subset of ads that are absolutely ok with me and I'd be happy to leave them visible to support smaller sites, and another subset of ads that I just don't care strongly about. - I strongly believe that the value of customized ads has been overhyped. And with that I mean to the ad buyer, not to Google: I've only seen relevant ads from Google once or twice a year for the last 10 years or so. - there should be a value in knowing that your ads don't end up next to a "hit the monkey scam" or next to another dubious ad. A good seller or sales organization can make this obvious to ad buyers. - for a number of sites I would not only be OK with but also happy to pay for individual news items (think smaller newspapers from Nowhere that gets linked in social media etc), as long as they don't insist on selling me a subscription instead of access to this single page.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> Small sites can put in the effort to make deals with individual advertisers and bake it right into the page. Say I run a blog, by myself or maybe with one other person. Even putting aside questions of my own limited time, are big companies going to deal with me? Is it practical for them to deal with me and a thousand other, individual small blogs?
- wpietri 7y agoIf you run a blog now, how much money do you realistically expect to make? I have a site that gets about 30k pageviews per month; I threw ads on it just to see what would happen. It makes something like $12/month. Even at minimum wage here, after hosting costs I could afford to spend approximately zero time on it. So I think for small sites, the answer is effectively the same with algorithmic ads or directly sold ads: you won't make enough to matter either way.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> I have a site that gets about 30k pageviews per month; I threw ads on it just to see what would happen. It makes something like $12/month This seemed surprisingly low to me, so I did a little Googling. https://blog.adstage.io/google-display-ads-cpm-cpc-ctr-benchmarks-in-q1-2018 https://blog.adstage.io/google-display-ads-cpm-cpc-ctr-bench... > In Q1 2018, [AdWords] advertisers paid $2.8 dollars per thousand impressions So for a site with 30K monthly page-views, I'd expect something closer to $84 per month with one ad per page. Place an ad on both the top and bottom of each page, and now it's $168 per month. Still not a ton by any stretch, but an extra 2K in income each year is nothing to sneeze at.
- shadowgovt 7y ago... and it makes a world of difference for some people. Ad clearinghouses are a flattening and democratizing force on the Internet that I don't think people recognize as such. They let people who otherwise couldn't really afford to pay for server space put up their content.