6 ms·
How long will it take our society to realize that democracy is threatened when machines are involved in voting or vote counting? Going back to voting exclusive
by pmoriarty 7y ago
How long will it take our society to realize that democracy is threatened when machines are involved in voting or vote counting?
Going back to voting exclusively by ink on paper and hand counting is imperative.
- pricees 7y agoI don't know. I feel this may be a great application of blockchain and public ledger tech. Of course it would need to be open source... And... You know.. Obviously written in Rust.
- mycall 7y agohttps://votecoin.site https://votecoin.site
- boring_twenties 7y agohttps://xkcd.com/2030/ https://xkcd.com/2030/
- skrowl 7y agoWith strong voter ID. Paper ballots do you no good if you can't verify that they were cast by a real person that was eligible to vote in that area, and that they only voted once.
- LargeWu 7y agoThis is, in reality, a virtually nonexistent problem. It's often used as a rationale for voter suppression, though.
- tathougies 7y agoFalse: not having voter ID is used as a rationale for voter ressurection though: https://chicago.cbslocal.com/2016/10/27/2-investigators-chicago-voters-cast-ballots-from-beyond-the-grave/ https://chicago.cbslocal.com/2016/10/27/2-investigators-chic...
- cyphar 7y agoCourts found that the North Carolina voter ID laws were designed to be discriminatory[1]. Same in Texas[2]. So it's definitely true in at least two cases that voter ID laws were provably designed for voter suppression. [1]: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/05/north-carolinas-voter-id-law-supreme-court-cert/526713/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/05/north-c... [2]: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/jul/20/texas-voter-id-law-voting-rights-act-federal-court-decision https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/jul/20/texas-voter-...
- LargeWu 7y agoNot only provably, but explicitly. Voter suppression was the primary intent.
- cyphar 7y agoSomething being provably true is a higher bar than it being explicitly stated (because an explicit statement isn't enough to prove something to be true). I agree that voter suppression was the primary intent, but the legislation wasn't called "The Illegal Voter Suppression Act 2013".
- skrowl 7y ago> a virtually nonexistent problem Watch Broward County FL this November. Whole boxes of filled out ballots will be "found" mysteriously. Just like every election.
- LargeWu 7y agoThat is election fraud, perpetrated by the people running the elections themselves, not voter fraud. If you can't trust the people running the elections, then no amount of voter ID is going to matter.
- jedberg 7y agoIn 2016 there were only four confirmed cases where people voted who should not have and would have been stoped with voter ID. All four voted for Trump, but that's not super relevant. What's relevant is that it was four out of 127,000,000 votes. Even if the problem were 1,000 times worse then we know it still would have had no effect on the election, even if they were all in Wisconsin.
- bjourne 7y agoLast election cycle, the Bernie Sanders campaign insisted that the Iowa caucus should be changed so that more data was reported. Back then only the final number of delegates were reported. So it is entirely possible that the caucus always was a mess but that it only got discovered this year.
- astronautjones 7y agoand that's being spun into "he got what he asked for" now. yes, the general public now understands how bobo this operation is!
- oblib 7y agoWhere I live we use paper ballots that are both scanned and tallied on sight by a machine when submitted, then hand counted by volunteers at a central location that anyone can observe. I'm pretty comfortable with that.
- basch 7y agoI admittedly dont know the specifics of this process, but to break it down very abstractly, there seems to be a challenge and a misconception. The challenge is: is the person submitting the results who they say they are, and are they authorized to submit results for said precinct, did their data submission transform on transit. The misconception seems to be that any of the data is private. Issuing 1700 instagram accounts and having each precinct post and tag a photograph would have been both more secure, and instantly verifiable. Anybody could go back later and go "yep thats the photo I posted." "Yep that is the account that we expected the photo to come from." "Yep, the account wasn't improperly accessed." Everyone in the public can see the live results real time, and hand verify the summarization. A worst case scenario would be someone doctoring one of the Math Sheets, printing out a near perfect duplicate, and creating confusion over which document is the "real" one. Breaking into a physically secure area with a fake piece of paper may cause a situation with an unverifiable truth. Having a public, timestamped photograph minimizes counterfeiting and forgery. Providing a csv/xlsx file, and having a whitelisted list of senders would have worked, along with a bot ingesting the files as they came. A onedrive with 1700 shared spreadsheets would have worked, each precinct manager would have just needed a copy of mobile excel. The technology that generates my fantasy football cheat sheets seems more advanced. The goal here should be to get a definitive answer posted into the public record, timestamped and proven to be the appropriate sender. The "pin" nonsense is the scary part of all this. Did anybody who shouldnt have download the app, and submit the wrong results? >he had to sign in with an email and password, provide a two-factor authentication, and enter a one-time password generated by the Google Authenticator app. What is the point of 2fa/authenticator, if the person is registering for the first time the night of the primary? Wouldnt 2fa be for preventing access to the account youve already made, not to prevent someone from creating your account? Unless somehow the phone numbers were already on file, and a sanity check took place before the 2fa step, which I doubt. Is 2fa anything more than security theater in this application?
- JohnClark1337 7y agoI think this boils down to the premise that the more complex you make a system the easier it is to break that system
- yongjik 7y agoSorry for tooting the horn again, but this is really a solved problem. You go with paper ballots and vote-counting machines. The result is available pretty fast, and when there's concern you can always re-count everything by hand. This is how it's supposed to work: https://youtu.be/ViK9pe9Pv_s?t=27 https://youtu.be/ViK9pe9Pv_s?t=27
- ikeyany 7y agoThat's never been how caucuses work, so it's not quite a solution to this problem.
- astronautjones 7y agothe solution is to modernize and stop having ridiculously archaic caucuses
- rayiner 7y agoCaucuses are great. High information voters who have to publicly stand by their candidate, and persuade other members of their community to support their candidate. More on the “democracy” side of the equation than the “republic” side.
- chillwaves 7y agoThat is not what happened.
- chipotle_coyote 7y agoThe OP wasn't being metaphorical in any sense, they were literally describing how caucuses work. If your first choice doesn't meet a qualifying threshold in your precinct, then you can switch your vote in the second round, and supporters of other candidates can literally try to convince you before that round. It all happens in the open with people literally crossing to different parts of the room to caucus for different candidates. The app -- and its failure -- didn't change any part of this process.
- walshemj 7y agoUm hand counting in primary elections - you think the Blackadder episode where they try to get Baldric elected to a rotten borough is a good idea.
- bluGill 7y agoThis isn't a primary. There are no ballots. The Republicans do ballots - on paper, but the democrats don't have a ballot at all.
- jariel 7y agoPaper ballots with scanned results in the booth. No scan means redo your vote. That way you have a track record + instant results. Folks can take home the stub to ensure non-repudiation etc.. They can look up the serial number on the stub they take home to see for sure it was recorded. FYI we should also have basic ID requirements for voting. The arguments against it are kind of ridiculous, and federal or state ID should be free. There should be no 'voter registration' required either: the state knows your address and that's that. For lighter elections like city alderman, you can use your ID + passcode to SMS or email your vote. Maybe make a law requiring that any tech used for legal voting has to get the thumbs up from the NSA or some super amazing agency that is also secular in nature. None of this 'quickie app for voting' rubbish. At this point, I hate politics so much, I think every nation needs a 'caretaker' Pres/PM from the bureaucracy - someone who can clean out the cobwebs, get rid of a bunch of old laws, clean up the tax code, take on the public unions (I mean reform not destroy, I mean teachers probably need higher salaries) and basically do a big, operational house cleaning that has nothing to do with politics.
- bluGill 7y agoThis is a caucus not a primary. From what I understand there are no ballots at all - you physically walk around the room until you find the group you want to support, if your group is large enough to choose delegates (generally there are more slots than people to fill them) to the next convention. The delegates are in theory (in practice it is different) not required to vote for you, so when your group chooses people you need to make sure they are like minded.
- coredog64 7y agoOnce everything has been decided, an iron clad paper trail IS produced. There’s nothing anonymous about the results document and it is signed in front of witnesses. AIUI, the paper doc isn’t discarded until after the party convention.
- bluGill 7y agoI didn't say there was no paper trail. I said there no ballots. That is a subtle difference that if you don't go to democrat caucus in Iowa you probably don't understand. Theoretically a group can win delegates in a caucus with just an issue not a candidate - for example you can all agree that the most important issue is Oranges (a fruit that doesn't grow in Iowa...) and get a delegate without committing to a president. Of course in practice most people show up only for the president poll and leave as soon as that is over.
- briandear 7y agoAnd elections had more integrity before electronics? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Box_13_scandal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Box_13_scandal
- bluGill 7y agoThis is a caucus not an election. The democrats have never used paper ballots (as far as I know - my history is short though). The republicans still use hand counted ballots. Either way in a caucus you are NOT electing a president, you are just choosing a delegate who goes on to the national convention where the president is chosen. There are rules so that the caucus results feed who is supported at the national convention, but there are ways around those rules if you want to go to the national convention and then support someone who wasn't even running in the first place - though you pretty well better be assured of a win before you think about trying those tricks as the media will go nuts. (the same rules exist in primary states, technically there is a caucus somewhere that chooses the delegate to the national convention who can then vote for someone else)
- boring_twenties 7y agoDon't worry, we've solved it with blockchain.