8 ms·
> can also sail faster than the wind at times. Really? Can you elaborate?
by simonebrunozzi 7y ago
> can also sail faster than the wind at times.
Really? Can you elaborate?
- trhway 7y agoyou can look at kiters and windsurfers - even on a mild wind they glide very fast - orthogonal to the wind you get constant ( i.e. practically independent of your speed) force driving you forward, and it accelerates you until it matches the force of the water and air resistance to your movement which grows with your speed. And of course here comes that: https://newatlas.com/wind-powered-car-world-record/11346/ https://newatlas.com/wind-powered-car-world-record/11346/ "March 29, 2009 With a wind speed of just 30mph (48kmh), British engineer Richard Jenkins has set a new land speed record for a wind-powered vehicle at blistering 126.1mph. "
- meedimusic 7y agoapparent wind
- WalterBright 7y agoTake a drafting triangle that has 30-60-90 degree corners. Place it between two objects, and squeeze the triangle between them. It'll move to the side faster than the two objects move together. Or you can just think of it like squirting toothpaste. The wind pressure on the sail and the water pressure on the keel form the two "objects" being pushed together and the sailboat "squirts" out the side. Edit: The angle between the sail and the keel is like the angle on the triangle. The keel really was a great invention.
- luckyscs 7y agoIt's like our brains aren't meant to handle resolving that not only is it pushed through, it's sucked into a thin and ever moving void. It's pushed and pulled at the same time, in otherwords, part of the continuum.
- salawat 7y agoThat's exactly how I mentally model it. You have to imagine it like a stone skimming the surface of the fluid on one side, and a bubble "sucking" the other side into it. It's two concurrent visualizations of the same force.
- taneq 7y agoSuction isn't a real thing, though. It's just our description of when lower pressure on one side of a thing allows the thing to be moved by the higher pressure on the other side. The pressure that the air above the wing applies to the top of the wing is lower than the pressure that the air below the wing applies to the bottom of the wing. The net force is upwards.
- luckyscs 7y agoI'm not sure it's that simple, and my physics knowledge isn't so strong but if it's a gradient, the force of the push can't exist without being the same thing as the force of the pull. They seem to be one in the same, the force isn't onna particular side, it's the effect of the delta between points on the gradient.
- luckyscs 7y agoIt's like our brains aren't meant to handle resolving that not only is it pushed through, it's sucked into a thin and ever moving but thin void. It's pushed and pulled at the same time.
- loco5niner 7y agoKind of like when your car splashes into a puddle and somehow some of the water drops make it onto your windshield.
- Tyr42 7y agoYeah. There are two kinds of sailboats. There's the big square sailed ones which always have to move downwind. Then there are the triangular sailed ones, which can move in any direction except for right into the wind. (Maybe a 30 degree on each side dead zone). The square sailed boats can't move faster than the wind, as they just rely on the air pushing on the sail to move with the wind. That's also how the triangular sailed boats move when moving directly downwind. They too can't outrun the wind. However, when moving sideways to the wind, the wind passes over the sail, which looks like a wing sticking out of the water. Like a wing, there's a "lift" force generated, although it's not up but sideways. The boats also have a fin sticking into the water, which prevents the boat from slipping directly along with that "lift" force, and instead move forward.
- munificent 7y ago> There's the big square sailed ones which always have to move downwind. Actually, that's not true. Square rigged "pirate-style" ships are more efficient when sailing downwind compared to fore-and-aft style sailboats, but they can still sail just fine close-hauled (into the wind) or on a reach (perpendicular). There are some efficiency pros and cons to both styles, but they all have the same aerodynamic capabilities. The main reasons square-rigged ships fell out of fashion, as far as I know, are mostly logistically. Square-rigged sails make sense when you have a really big ship. A single huge fore-and-aft sail would be too hard to handle. Square-rigged ships break that sail area down into a larger number of smaller individually manageable pieces. But larger vessels are almost all powered now. For a smaller sailing vessel, it's easier to manage the simpler Bermuda sail plan, and its more efficient. I think maybe square-rigged ships have an efficiency advantage when going straight downwind, but most sailboats simply carry a spinnaker to cover that case. (Caveat: I'm not a sailor, I've just read some textbooks.)
- tgarv 7y agoWell said, and I just want to add some detail about how square-rigged ships are able to sail close-hauled: They typically (or maybe always?) have "staysails", which run fore-and-aft between the masts, which works mostly like the main triangular sail you think of with a simple sailboat (with the exception that, as far as I know, these staysails aren't on a boom that can change its angle relative to the ship). These are able to take the wind at an angle but still generate forward thrust. The "yards", the sections that hold the square sails perpendicular to the ship, are also able to rotate between perpendicular and nearly-parallel to the ship, which lets them take advantage of a wide range of wind directions. (I'm also not much of a sailor, I've just sailed some tiny single-sail boats, but I've learned a lot while reading through the Aubrey-Maturin series and from playing the game Naval Action)
- munificent 7y agoImagine a sailboat pointed 90° relative to the wind so that the wind is coming right at its side. The sail is curved so that it takes that wind and redirects it towards the rear of the boat, giving it forward thrust. The boat starts moving forward. But, because the wind is perpendicular to the boat, even when its moving the wind is still coming in at the same velocity, so it's still producing thrust. If you can get the boat efficient enough, it can harness enough of that wind energy to reach a velocity along the sailboat's line of motion higher than the velocity of the wind relative to the ground. Note that boats can only do this when sailing at least somewhat offcenter from the wind direction. When sailing directly downwind, the faster the boat goes, the slower the wind is relative to the boat, leeching away thrust.
- bloomer 7y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackbird_(land_yacht) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackbird_(land_yacht) Was built to demonstrate that you can sail directly downwind faster than the wind as well.
- hinkley 7y agoThat is not a conventional land yacht, but I'm sure there are land yachts that can go faster than the wind, by exactly the same principle as sailboats. The motive force on that vehicle is a gear and chain between the prop and the wheels. And prop blades are set at an angle to the wind.
- mannykannot 7y agoThere is one complication here: as the boat accelerates, the relative wind moves forward. Consider a boat on a beam reach, where the wind over the water is at 90 degrees to its track. If the boat is travelling at wind speed, the apparent wind over the deck is at 45 degrees to the bow. The useful angle of attack for airfoils goes up to about 15 degrees, so let us assume that the sails are set to this. Therefore, the chord of the sail is at 30 degrees to the boat's track, its lift is at 60 degrees to its track, and so half the total lift is in the direction of motion [1]. So long as this exceeds the total drag of the boat, from the water and the air, then it will continue to accelerate. [1] To simplify (and to go faster!) assume a multihull sailboat, hydrofoil, or a dinghy with its crew hiked out so that is not heeling appreciably, as when a boat is heeled, a component of its sails' lift is directed downwards.
- AceyMan 7y agomy analogy: if you have ever launched a pumpkin or watermelon seed by squeezing it between your fingertips just so then you can understand how the craft can move faster than whatever provides the impulse. \\ wing is to wind as seed is to fingers \\
- QuantumGood 7y agoThat's how we were taught in sailboat racing school.