3 ms·
So, since the title is a bit baity: On a mathematical level we understand and have consensus; but the "dirtiness" of practical applications of mathematics makes
by falcolas 7y ago
So, since the title is a bit baity: On a mathematical level we understand and have consensus; but the "dirtiness" of practical applications of mathematics makes it a bit more complicated to explain fully.
- loeg 7y agoIt's extremely baity.
- falcolas 7y agoI'm not sure if it's because they're trying to break it down for laymen, but there's a lot missing from these explanations and their supposed problems. There's no discussion of boundary layers, turbulent vs laminar flow, the effect of wing textures, nothing. There's also no discussion about what happens when you try and tilt a wing too far upwards - a stall - or why the simple buildup of ice on a wing can cause an otherwise fine wing to lose its ability to produce lift.
- pmoriarty 7y agoWell, the quibble here is whether having equations that are solvable and useful for making predictions is equivalent to having an understanding. If you answer "yes", then the problem with that view is most evident in physics where equations and successfully tested predictions result in counter-intuitive "quantum weirdness" which is hard to reconcile with claims of understanding. As Feynman was supposed to have said, "If you think you understand quantum physics, you don't." Another problem with such a view is it results in descriptions which sound absurd on their face, such as claims that when people look they see photons. But people look they see objects, fields of color, or have other experiences which are irreconcilable with the abstractions or equations created by physicists. This is related to what is known in analytic philosophy circles and cognitive science as "the hard problem of consciousness", which is how one reconciles "scientific" explanations of how the mind works with people's actual experiences.
- falcolas 7y agoIt can be explained, though. I took aerodynamics courses over a decade ago, and they had a decent explanation which covered all of the points brought up in the article, incorporating both Bernoulli's principle and Newton's third principle. The big challenge seems to be making it explainable to someone with no domain knowledge.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]