4 ms·
I'm citing to article's describing Sweden's economic regulations, corporate taxation regime, history of privatization, and educational system. These aren't "che
by rayiner 7y ago
I'm citing to article's describing Sweden's economic regulations, corporate taxation regime, history of privatization, and educational system. These aren't "cherry-picked examples"--they're basic pillars of a country's policy that you look to in deciding whether to characterize a country as "socialist" or "capitalist."
Sweden has never been socialist. It got rich through lassaiz-faire capitalism: https://elgar.blog/2014/09/09/embracing-capitalism-the-real-success-of-swedens-universal-welfare-state/ https://elgar.blog/2014/09/09/embracing-capitalism-the-real-...
In the 1970s and 1980s, Sweden experimented with a mixed economy, with a large public sector and extensive price controls. That experiment was a failure:
> In the 1970s, policy became more anti-capitalist. In 1983, Sweden even decided to implement a partial socialization of company profits, the so-called wage earner funds. Economic problems grew more and more severe, and when the boom of the 1980s turned into recession in the early 1990s, Sweden was hit much harder than other countries.’
In the 1990s, Sweden changed course. It deregulated industries, cut corporate taxes, and privatized large sectors of the economy. When people point to the "Nordic model" today, they are pointing to the ability of countries like Sweden to have strong economic growth combined with a robust welfare state. But the "Nordic model" is starts with a capitalist foundation not a socailist one:
> The history of Sweden, however, also shows that the financing of a generous welfare state requires a highly competitive business sector. The best way to promote a combination of prosperity and equality is not to fight capitalism with high capital taxes, but rather to use capitalism as an engine of growth and combine it with a well-designed welfare state that provides a social safety net while preserving the incentives to work and provide for oneself.
To give you a concrete example that illustrates the larger approach: if you take the subway in Stockholm, you're riding in train cars owned and operated by private companies. If you take the subway in New York, you're riding in a government owned-and-operated system. The Swedish approach is to rely on market forces when possible, not government command-and-control. It isn't to demonize the private sector, but to unleash it.
To put it differently, the term "democratic socialism" means you start with a socialist economy and make it more democratic. The Nordic model does the opposite. It starts with a capitalist economy, and makes it more democratic, by taxing the wealth generated by the market to provide welfare services. That's the "Nordic model" today. Of course maybe there are unrepentant socialists who pine for the 1970s, but the Swedes have doubled down on capitalism and deregulation and have been perusing that strategy for almost 30 years now, after having tried alternatives.
- jahaja 7y agoThis is such dogmatic bullshit that I can't be arsed. The "source" you're referring to is linked directly to the neoliberal thinktank Timbro. All your examples are a recent development that's exactly my point.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't stoop to this level even if someone else is completely wrong, or you feel they are. Maybe you don't owe them better personally (though why not?), but you definitely owe this community better if you're posting here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jahaja 7y agoYou're right. Apologies. But surely I would get rightfully warned if I'd suggest that the US Army is a great example of successful Stalinism and link to my favourite commissar confirming my articulate trolling?
- dang 7y agoI'm not sure I understand the question, but for sure we don't care whether the comments that break the site guidelines are for or against any particular side. I'd never claim we do a perfect job of being unbiased, because most bias is unconscious, but what I can say is (a) we have many years of conscious practice at it, which must count for something, and (b) most of the time when people interpret moderation as picking on their side, it's a mechanical response (similar to how sports fans feel the refs pick on their favorites) that's not grounded in what we actually do, and doesn't see the cases where the 'other side' got moderated the same way. Does that make sense?