5 ms·
Bruce Schneier thinks that the best compromise is to to have paper ballots that can be counted by a machine or by hand. If all observers agree the vote was righ
by nabla9 7y ago
Bruce Schneier thinks that the best compromise is to to have paper ballots that can be counted by a machine or by hand. If all observers agree the vote was right, machine count stands. If someone challenges the vote, you count by hand.
- Operyl 7y agoExactly. I think that machines can be used just fine in a very specific configuration. I.e. you go to a machine, select the choices you want, that machine prints out a ballot with your choices. You review that ballot. If the ballot is correct, you go over to a tabulation machine, feed it in, and call it a day. That machine retains the paper ballots if verification is needed. EDIT: And if someone wants to fill out a paper ballot manually, let them. Just have a few spares around, most people won't.
- badwolf 7y agoThis is how the new voting machines we use here in Austin work. Big friendly, easy to use touch screen, it then prints your ballot on paper, in big friendly easy to read lettering. You then feed that into another machine. There's the e-voting, as well as paper ballot paper trail.
- hoseja 7y agoWHY does anyone need electronic voting in the first place? How much of an inconvenience is it to make a mark next to your choice on a piece of paper? I feel like there is some insane American reason to make voting machines but I can't comprehend it.
- Operyl 7y agoIn Florida, our ballets are very long legal pieces of paper and can sometimes be 7-8 pages worth... So I definitely see the appeal here. The font is tiny for the population, as well. A lot of our population has problems filling the bubbles too (because of varying physical conditions).
- the_snooze 7y agoBallot marking devices are riskier than hand-marked ballots. A forthcoming study found that few people check what the machines print out, and even fewer actually report discrepancies to poll workers. https://jhalderm.com/pub/papers/bmd-verifiability-sp20.pdf https://jhalderm.com/pub/papers/bmd-verifiability-sp20.pdf
- wycy 7y agoI'd say a combination of this idea plus a mandatory hand count of a random sample of, say, 2% of the ballots from each machine to make sure the results are similar.
- vlovich123 7y agoThat is what exactly what is suggested. OP presented a small subset of the entire article outlining how this should work. Highly recommended read.
- vsareto 7y agoAt this point in US politics, if someone can challenge it, they will. Might as well count by machine and by hand by default.
- scott_s 7y agoThe caucuses are not normal elections: there are no ballots. The results are literally counting where people in a room are standing and recording that on a spreadsheet. The problem has been relaying that spreadsheet to the party.
- Loughla 7y agoIt feels like a caucus exists to arbitrarily filter out participants based on how long they take. Not everyone has the 2-3 hours to spend on a caucus vote. Why don't they just vote via paper ballot?
- dont__panic 7y agoIn this specific case? Because Iowa wanted to be the first contest in the nomination process, but NH legally gets to run the first primary. Caucusing is an older alternative to voting that served as a loophole to allow Iowa to go first.
- finnthehuman 7y ago>Why don't they just vote via paper ballot? Because Iowa chose to have a caucus, not a primary. If you’re not an Iowa voter, there are a million political bikesheds that would have more relevance to your life. You’re basically just complaining about the pace of a television program.
- couchand 7y agoIt's worth noting that the caucus is supposed to be much more than just registering your presidential preference. The idea is that you have a regular gathering with your neighbors to discuss political concerns. That most people view it as an elaborate and slow version of a primary is an indictment of how sad the state of political participation in our country is. That being said, it is an excellent way to exclude people who have other responsibilities or difficulty making it out for several hours on a week night.
- 333c 7y ago
- MichaelApproved 7y agoPaper and hand counting only. Election results are too important to risk compromising them by trying to save money or rush results. The money saved is always marginal anyway and the extra time is usually only a few hours.
- Yetanfou 7y agoRemember "hanging chads" and "pregnant chads" [1]? Those were machine-countable paper ballots which could be hand-counted in case of a challenge. Replace the punch-card ballot machine by pencil marks and the discussion will go over whether a specific field is just smeared or marked, whether a mark just outside the designated field still counts as a mark, etc. In short, paper voting ballots are better than this digital nightmare but they come with their own set of problems. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chad_(paper) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chad_(paper)
- the_snooze 7y ago>the discussion will go over whether a specific field is just smeared or marked, whether a mark just outside the designated field still counts as a mark, This is a solved problem. In my precinct in Virginia, any mark inside the bubble counts as valid. If you accidentally put a stray mark in one selection and intentionally fill in another for a single-choice contest, the scanner machine will reject your ballot and notify the poll worker about your overvote. If you marked outside the bubble, the machine will reject your ballot as an undervote.
- TYPE_FASTER 7y agoI like the system in Massachusetts: you fill out a paper ballot and feed it into a slot where it's scanned optically and deposited in a locked container. The ballot has circles you fill in with a provided marker (like standardized tests).