8 ms·
>So yes, unless you arbitrarily limit the entire globe to some level of prosperity like a novel about a disutopian world ruled by an evil anti-science theocracy
by coldtea 7y ago
>So yes, unless you arbitrarily limit the entire globe to some level of prosperity like a novel about a disutopian world ruled by an evil anti-science theocracy,
I don't see much evil to that (limiting the "the entire globe to some level of prosperity"). Nor it has anything to do with being anti-science. You could be pro-science (pro understanding the world, physics, math, etc), and against continuous growth.
Better that models that treat the environment as externalities, or which convolute and stress the daily life for ever more trinkets to fuel the growth machine...
- shaftoe 7y agoYou don't see much evil to handicapping the entire human race?
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoYou don't see much evil in the absence of strategic intelligence required to avoid terraforming your own planet to make it less habitable?
- Kaiyou 7y agoEvil needs agency, so no, I don't see evil in the absence of something.
- rbrtl 7y ago"Bad men need nothing more to compass their ends, than that good men should look on and do nothing."
- Kaiyou 7y agoEmphasize on "good men". They're not evil for doing nothing.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoA convenient abdication of responsibility, isnt it? We we not responsible for plane crash/ financial crysis / climate change, it just happened!
- Kaiyou 7y agoI was talking about evil, not responsibility.
- jhrmnn 7y agoWhat about the absence of resistance to evil? Perhaps not evil per se, but one could call it absence of good.
- Kaiyou 7y agoThat depends on your definition of 'good', I guess. I wouldn't say that you have to fight evil to be good.
- coldtea 7y agoFor one, societies do have agency. People decide every day, with who they elect, where they spend their money, how they live. You don't need a conscious goal of X to act in a way that brings X. And if you know that your actions are part of the problem and you still doing them, that's even worse. Second, evil needs agency only when we talk of evil deeds. An outcome can be evil in itself though - not evil-doing, evil, in the sense of bad, ominous, deleterious, etc.
- homonculus1 7y agoI do, and that's what cancerous infinite growth on every dimension will eventually do to us (or is already doing?) We need to constrain growth to science and efficiency, and pull back on population and land use.
- coldtea 7y agoNo, I don't see "moar stuff, moar tech" as the ultimate reason of the human race. I'd rather the human race is happier, more self-fulfilled, friendlier, with more solidarity, and better allocation of its resources, than it expanding forever... If anything, I see much evil in "not handicapping" the human race, and ruining the planet, the animal life, and the human race in the process.
- andersonvieira 7y agoYou probably live a comfortable life and is mostly satisfied with what you have so you see no need for more growth. Now imagine someone had the means to implement this same idea 200 years ago. We probably wouldn't have water and sewage treatment, fast transportation, modern medicine, electric light and all the appliances that come with it, internet, etc. I find it disingenuous to dismiss all these as trinkets. This would be basically limiting the possibilities of all future humans in the name of some "greater good". That is textbook evil for me. I think the main problem with this kind of thinking is that it is always based on what you know now, and not on what is possible. The world we live today, our technology, and the way we use resources would be unimaginable 200 years ago. The same is true about our knowledge of what will be possible 200 years from now.
- virgilp 7y agoI largely agree with you, with some amendment: > The same is true about our knowledge of what will be possible 200 years from now. The same _might_ be true. I think it's really a race in the current moment of time - will our knowledge of the physical world evolve fast enough to allow us to undo/transform the damage our growth does to the ecosystem? Or will the damage our growth does ultimately limit & maybe even revert our ability to grow? The truth is... we don't know, I think both scenarios are plausible. For all we know, civilization might end in 50 years due to either one of multiple potential causes (war, global warming, etc) - or on the contrary, we may discover something truly transformative (like the ability to convert energy to matter and vice-versa) and all today's problems will seem silly. Or anything in between, I guess :)
- raducu 7y agoI think you are being disingenuousby saying 200 years. Except medical advances and science, I'd be all willing to trade ALL the economic "growth" in the first world of the last 20 years if we could also revert wars, climate change and destruction of habbitat for the last 20 years. Oh, and by "growth" I mean the insane asset price inflation and concentration wealth, strengthening of the military-industrial complex, monopolisation by corporations, too big to fail banks and financial institutions.
- anonymou2 7y agoIn fact I would say that the belief in perpetual growth is pretty much anti-science. It contradicts the evidence that the earth is a sphere to begin with.
- Aunche 7y agoIt doesn't matter if you're ok with it. The problem is that everyone has to agree with you for it to work, which can't happen outside of force.
- merpnderp 7y agoAll these plans for utopia always rely on bending other people to their will at the end of a gun, exactly like every other utopian nightmare.