4 ms·
How is the stability of the system? I always afraid of AMD because of their low investments into software that AMD systems won't be rock stable. Especially with
by vbezhenar 7y ago
How is the stability of the system? I always afraid of AMD because of their low investments into software that AMD systems won't be rock stable. Especially with Linux, where Intel commits a lot of code into kernel.
But AMD value is tremendeous, especially comparing with Intel CPU supporting ECC. I'm thinking about buying Xeon W-2265 workstation and it's just 12 cores for $1200, AMD is much cheaper and for that price I can get Threadripper monster.
- simion314 7y ago>I always afraid of AMD because of their low investments into software that AMD systems won't be rock stable. Especially with Linux, where Intel commits a lot of code into kernel AMD CPUs are used on servers so there is no reason they won't make all it's possible to have a stable system, are you referring to AMD GPUs? I read it takes up to 1 year after release until the graphics driver gets stable on Linux.
- numpad0 7y agoRyzen 1st-gen had the segfault issue, RNG issue, voltage/clock related ones and few more. RX480 and 580 were exact same chips, only the latter was mature manufacturing wise and had completely different firmware resulting in a superior performance. It’s true that AMD products has yield(as anyone else) as well as parameter tuning/compatibility issues especially early on. I don’t think their issues are of reliability kinds(like early failure in industrial Intel Atom) though.
- missosoup 7y agoSwitched from intel to amd with the same concerns at the back of my mind. Never had a single issue.
- bennyelv 7y agoI used to work at a global financial services firm that was AMD only back in the late 2000's when they were on top in the CPU wars. We never had any negative consequences from making that decision.
- llampx 7y agoI switched to AMD in 2018 and haven't had any issues. If you aren't running ECC memory the CPU drivers are the least of your concerns.
- dijit 7y agoWhy would ECC affect anything? FWIW I used a 1st Gen Ryzen at home and it would constantly BSOD under Windows but ran completely stable with linux (this was when Ryzen was brand new)
- llampx 7y agoWhat I mean is that switching to ECC memory will do more for your stability than the choice of Intel or AMD.
- numpad0 7y ago1st gen Ryzen had some suboptimal values in some very internal parameter that caused incorrect DRAM reads affecting all OS. They accepted warranty claims and later released BIOS updates. I doubt ECC would help prevent it(other than maybe by being slower?)
- ksec 7y agoI thought it was some valid concern for those who lived though the K5 /K6 / Athlon era. I never had, or even heard of stability problem with AMD's CPU Core, but during the early days AMD surely had worse chipset especially in I/Os. Where it had compatibility or performance issues. But these days most of them are third party IPs, from USB Controller to PCI-E Express, and they are the same IPs used by millions if not billions on Smartphone, Tablet and many other use cases. So you can be sure they are pretty damn well tested.