4 ms·
> has completed ... PhD dissertations How can that possibly work? You don't just go away and write a PhD dissertation in isolation, it grows slowly over three
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> has completed ... PhD dissertations
How can that possibly work?
You don't just go away and write a PhD dissertation in isolation, it grows slowly over three or more years with intimate private discussion with your advisor, and intermediate peer-reviewed publications that you have to present and defend in-person.
I can't understand how you could conceivably out-source that to someone else?
- trevyn 7y agoSame as how middle managers can explain work product to their superiors -- they didn't personally create it, but they have grown familiar over time as an intermediary.
- bawolff 7y agoI've never done an oral defense, but surely there is a difference between someone expected to be an intermediary to higher ups who know nothing, and an oral defense where subject matter experts attempt to stump you with tricky questions
- rjsw 7y agoThe client could be perfectly capable of doing an oral defence, and to have done all the research that is described in the thesis, just not that great at putting it down in a formal way.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI still don't get how that would work. When your advisor asks you in person how you think some technique that they've only just explained to you applies to your work, what do you do? Text your Kenyan ghost-writer under the table?
- Double_a_92 7y ago"Hmm... Yes.. Sounds interesting, I'll see if I can apply that to my work. Thank your for your valuable input." Also you probably still have some idea of what is going on. You still had to pass all your in-person exams in your academic career so far.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThere's plenty of people who can understand specialized subject matter in great detail, well enough to edit a dissertation, but can't write very well in the first place. Ethical or not these people probably benefit greatly from outsourcing the initial draft of most of their writing.
- gryson 7y agoI imagine for something like a diploma mill (or not too far removed), where a dissertation may be required to get the degree but there is little genuine advising or research taking place. I heard a story from an outraged faculty member at a legitimate university concerning the PhD process in the school of education at said university (not EdD, but PhD). Apparently, none or almost none of the education faculty had themselves received a PhD (most had M.S.Ed), yet they were awarding large numbers of PhDs to students each year. Furthermore, the students were apparently doing "group dissertations", which I'm still not sure of how to interpret (I trust the person who told me of this, and I don't think it was hearsay). The point of this anecdote is to suggest that even at good universities, there may be situations where students are able to get away with doing less than would typically be expected of a good PhD program.
- badpun 7y agoThere are advisers at universities here in Poland who are basically happy for you to write your PhD on your own (with zero supervision), as long as it meets the required quality standard (which can be rather low). This way, he fills his quota of mentees without devoting work to it.
- ChainOfFools 7y agoI can say from firsthand experience (albeit a data set of 1) that is happens in the US at the Ph.D level program in a rather well known school with a sculpture of the founder whose shoe is as frequently rubbed for good luck as it is defiled by drunken frat boys.
- Maken 7y agoThere are some really bad PhD programs out there. It could be they were outsourcing only the writing of the dissertation itself, dumping a bunch of papers and expecting the ghost writer to turn it into a coherent story.