5 ms·
What does 'upper class' mean to the authors? To me, 'upper class' means something like an international billionaire, or a member of a European aristocracy, som
by chrisseaton 7y ago
What does 'upper class' mean to the authors?
To me, 'upper class' means something like an international billionaire, or a member of a European aristocracy, someone with considerable social influence, something like that.
Here it seems to mean someone driving a new car?!
- JamesBarney 7y agoIn one study upper class is defined as being in close physical proximity to a large number of $1 bills.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> responded to an advertisement on Craigslist, an online community forum, and received an invitation to complete an on-line study for a chance to win a $50 gift certificate I don't think upper class people regularly respond to competitions for $50 gift certificates on Craigslist, either.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoBored stay at home partner might?
- jshevek 7y agoThe issue is the degree of selection bias, not whether outliers exist.
- doubletgl 7y agoFor the study with cars at an intersection, they simply used the model and make of the cars, so an old toyota vs. a new mercedes for example would be on opposite ends of the spectrum.
- badpun 7y agoThe problem with that is, plenty of wealthy people drive mundane or even frugal cars. I'm guessing that the need to drive a flashy car can correlate with being an asshole much more strongly than wealth.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 7y agoThe Queen of the United Kingdom's state Bentleys were made back in 2002 so she's presumably working class in the eyes of this study.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoThe only time I have seen the Queen she was in a 1950's or earlier Rolls Royce. I used to work near St Pauls so you occasionally had official events. Also Prince Charles famously has a 40 year old Barbour he wears
- leoedin 7y agoMy biggest complaint with that study is that it doesn't seem to control at all for the "asshole who buys a shiny car they can't afford" effect. I bet there's a correlation between people who buy expensive cars purely to give the perception of wealth who are also much more likely to cut people off.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- luckylion 7y ago> To me, 'upper class' means something like an international billionaire, or a member of a European aristocracy, someone with considerable social influence, something like that. That's a weird concept of "upper class". There are very few billionaires, they don't really make up a "class". They are part of the upper class, but pretty much anybody with a personal wealth that is far above the mean would qualify for upper class in my book. If you stopped working now and, living an average lifestyle, wouldn't have to ever work again, surely you're not middle class, but you also don't have to be a billionaire for that to be possible.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> If you stopped working now and, living an average lifestyle, wouldn't have to ever work again, surely you're not middle class I think you'd be middle class. Upper class is people with international influence, staff, significant land, titles, honours, membership of elite social organisations. It's not just people with a bit of money.
- luckylion 7y agoBut that would make them quite literally the 1% (or 0.1%), i.e. you'd have large middle and lower classes and barely visible upper class. I wouldn't put "net wealth of 5m" into a group with "net wealth of 50k", I think the 5m person is more similar to somebody with 500m insofar that he doesn't do manual labor, has a significant income from capital gains, and has ensured that even his kids won't ever have to actually work. Something like 50% lower, 40% middle, 10% upper class, with a tiny part of that upper class making up the super rich sounds more reasonable to me. Maybe the super rich are their own class?
- chrisseaton 7y ago> you'd have large middle and lower classes and barely visible upper class Yes, isn't that the world we live in?
- 7y ago