4 ms·
I've heard a proposal, which I generally tend to think is a good idea: eliminate the insanity defense, but give judges the option to send criminals to the insan
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
I've heard a proposal, which I generally tend to think is a good idea: eliminate the insanity defense, but give judges the option to send criminals to the insane asylum rather than prison.
Does anyone with greater knowledge see flaws with this idea?
- ceejayoz 16y agoIsn't that what the insanity defense already generally does?
- protomyth 16y agoIt is supposed to work like that, yet it seems to let the person back on the street at some point. The only real way I can see that as safe is if they removed a tumor or something that was causing the problem.
- rms 16y agoYes, psychological treatment is almost ridiculously obviously a better thing to do with criminals than lock them in boxes for an extremely long time. The problem is not with the idea, but with changing a system as entrenched as the prison-industrial complex.
- jhancock 16y agoPerhaps its better to simply enable prison systems to treat people with mental illness properly without regard to whether the mental illness was diagnosed or related of the original reason they ended up in prison. Of course, treating mental illness is expensive and requires more staff per inmate, etc... Its my understanding there are quite a few schizophrenics in general population as its simply too expensive to deal with them in a more human fashion. But of course if we are talking about more humane treatment and possibly rehabilitative treatment then we need to extend the discussion to all prisoners.
- btilly 16y agoDoes anyone with greater knowledge see flaws with this idea? Yes. There are cases where the insanity defense is clearly correct, and extended incarceration makes no sense. One example is a man who had become very abusive to his wife and newborn. Medical tests demonstrated the existence of a brain tumor. Removal of the tumor removed his uncontrollable rages and restored his normal state of being. (Along with great remorse over what he had done.) After that, what purpose would incarceration have served other than to derive his wife and young child of much needed income? In practice, though, I've heard that those who are found to be insane will, on average, wind up incarcerated longer than those who are not. True, it is a mental hospital rather than a jail. But the effect is similar to what you indicate. With the twist that discharge happens only after medical professionals judge that the person has improved, rather than having the discharge happen according to a guess by the judge.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI hate to add noise to the conversation, but I would like to thank you for changing my opinion on this matter. I was wrong and now I understand why.