3 ms·
It seems like no control or adjustment is made for individual vs joint returns (and therefore none for household size). I’d expect a state with greater makeup o
by sokoloff 7y ago
It seems like no control or adjustment is made for individual vs joint returns (and therefore none for household size). I’d expect a state with greater makeup of joint returns to have a lower reported percentage.
What I don’t have a good sense for is how different the splits are by state, but it seems like “per capita income inequality” is a lot more interesting than “per return income inequality”.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> It seems like no control or adjustment is made for individual vs joint returns (and therefore none for household size). Adjusting for the latter doesn't require consideration of the former at all, and consideration of the former doesn't much help with the latter, so the “and therefore” makes no sense. What you need for the latter is just consideration of the number of personal exemptions, not filing status.
- danans 7y agoPresumably the GP is referring to the "marriage penalty/bonus" phenomenon that can happen due to filing status for certain people, especially dual income joint filing households vs. single income joint filing households [1]. States with a higher proportion of dual similar-income joint filers with fewer children might hit the penalty more often (like a 2 doctor or lawyer household), and states with higher proportions of single or highly disparate income joint filing households (with a stay-at-home or marginally employed spouse) with more children would hit the bonus more often. But as you mention that effect is usually dominated by the effect of personal exemptions, and not by the fact that tax bracket thresholds between individual and joint filers don't line up perfectly while normalizing for number of filers. Correction: the marriage penalty/bonus has more to do with the disparity in spousal income than magnitude. 1. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/marriage-penalty.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/marriage-penalty.asp
- sokoloff 7y agoI'm much less interested in whether someone has 2 or 3 kids than in whether they have 1 or 2 income earners in the household. That's not arrived at from exemptions but is rather more closely approximated by filing status. Concretely, if my wife and I decide to file "married filing separately", we become two returns and income inequality is reduced in the analysis (but not at all in the real world). (I now see how “per capita income” led you to the conclusion you reached. That’s my bad.)