5 ms·
The speed a witch folks will imply there is a conspiracy at every turn on HN seems to be increasing with time.
by duxup 7y ago
The speed a witch folks will imply there is a conspiracy at every turn on HN seems to be increasing with time.
- shadowgovt 7y agoHN is passing the Eternal September threshold; this is a standard pattern with any open-subscription message board as T approaches infinity. I'm old enough to remember transitioning my interaction from /. to HN to get more professional discussion of industry topics. That was a long time ago, and there's no reason to assume most of /. hasn't followed me here by now. Edit: for those downvoting me, I'd appreciate a clarification on whether I was "off-topic," "troll," "flamebait," or something else; this is not the granularity of feedback to which I am accustom. ;)
- duxup 7y agoI fear you are correct. I'm a bit bummed as HN was pretty unique / not likely to find a new one.
- alasdair_ 7y ago>I'm a bit bummed as HN was pretty unique / not likely to find a new one. Slashdot, Digg and Reddit all had the same "unique" feeling for a long time. Something will replace HN eventually.
- duxup 7y agoI never felt like Slashdot, Dig, or Reddit expected the same amount of depth / thoughtfulness. Like when I ask a question here I'm not inundated by "I just read wikipedia and i'm here to splain it to you!" folks (I did too man .. that's not my question) and the expected depth on HN was / sometimes is fairly comprehensive. Also a lot less meme level type blogsmap nad links to folks who have blogs that actually know something. For me that was fairly unique to HN, at least as far as programming type stuff goes. Slasdhot, dig, reddit, always kinda spammy / shallow.
- bdamm 7y agoInterestingly, now that most of the chaff has abandoned /. it has somewhat returned to its original flavor, albeit a bit tainted. I'll not likely return simply because the conversation is a bit more grown-up here and I prefer the uncluttered presentation. But it's better now than it was at its worst.
- duxup 7y agoWay back in the day I always felt the /. community was a bit shrill... to the point of absurdity when it came to the topic of Open Source and such. Hopefully they've mellowed a bit.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dang 7y ago"HN is passing the Eternal September threshold" is something people say perennially. It goes back a decade already: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1524164 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1524164 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1613021 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1613021 See also "HN is turning into Reddit", which even goes back to before HN was HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=66057 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=66057 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21755721 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21755721
- rbanffy 7y agoWe are always surprised by unbelievably convenient coincidences favoring whoever has the ability to cause them. It's astonishing that, during the vetting process and over the course of his employment, his alleged sexual preferences were never a cause for concern. These people can't keep secrets from their employers because any secret they keep is a possible liability.
- duxup 7y ago>convenient coincidences favoring whoever has the ability to cause them. I feel like that by default would just mean everything involving anyone with any power (or even little) would be thought to be a conspiracy.
- simion314 7y agoThe thing that makes me believe that the evidence was planted is because is such an easy thing to do and it does a lot more damage, if there were some financial transcation then there would be some more evidence to corroborate it, if it was some objects or property again there would be a lot more things to corroborate, with porn you just plant a file or a stick and then the you show the jury some disturbing image and you are done, you destroyed the person, lazy and efficient. The article does not mention it and I would like to know if it is know if this was some files on his laptop, or was in his browser cache or browser history or an USB stick
- zionic 7y ago>I would like to know if it is know if this was some files on his laptop, or was in his browser cache or browser history or an USB stick That kind of stuff will never be released though.
- livueta 7y agoGiven the national security aspect of this case you might be right, but in general a lot of dirty details about the hows and wheres of CP cases comes out eventually in court filings. Exhibit A: "Mad Thad" McMichael / https://imgur.com/a/xr2IH https://imgur.com/a/xr2IH - of "\things\dont click\cp\cp" fame.
- mindslight 7y agoIt would obviously be better if the original article had itself examined the glaring motives. But since we can not rely on mass media to actually do critical reporting, it's good for someone else to say it. When convenient narratives are repeated without questioning, it warps people's perspectives.
- duxup 7y ago>it's good for someone else to say it I'm not sure I agree. You could say that about ... anything. Spam, racism... etc.
- zionic 7y agoSee my child comment for a more in depth response, but to your point I believe it is naive to assume intelligence agencies would not weaponize something as powerful as a CP accusation.
- duxup 7y agoI think it is illogical to assume that it happened in any / every given case with no evidence. I would think that just given time someone has falsified such a thing before, I don't by into the idea that it makes sense to make that assumption for any or every given case.
- homonculus1 7y agoNot every case. Nobody assumes a conspiracy when your neighbor down the road gets brought up on possession of such material. Despite easily having the power to, there's no motive for the federal government to go around framing random individuals of sex crimes. But a whistleblower? A thorn in the intelligence agencies' side who has exposed them and attracted their ire? You'd be a credulous fool to take that story at face value. The IC has a long and documented history of flouting norms like honesty and integrity. These are institutions whose entire purpose is to use deceptive, extra-legal methods to focus the power of government against anybody who poses a threat to it.
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoThe only rational, non-conspiracy nut commenting is getting downvoted.
- compuguy 7y agoWhy would they need to do such a thing. The defendant broke his agreement with the CIA and the Federal Government by leaking classified information. It honestly seems incredibly stupid to falsify evidence that could torpedo an entire case....
- zionic 7y ago>Why would they need to do such a thing. In general or this case? In general: Because it's incredibly powerful. In this case? See below. >The defendant broke his agreement with the CIA and the Federal Government by leaking classified information. This has yet to be proven, and the defendant claims he is innocent. An alleged leaker claiming his innocence possessing unencrypted CP is incredibly convenient for the CIA. Almost too convenient. >falsify evidence that could torpedo an entire case Why when the risk to the gov is basically 0%. You run a kit to plant the files and metadata. The files are then "extracted" by a forensic tool, the "evidence" is now bulletproof. The only person who could conceivably challenge such a move would be a very wealthy person who knew they were innocent and chose to hire expert witnesses to analyze the planted data to prove it was faked. Even then... good luck.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoIt's pretty well established that people federal law enforcement wants gone are allegedly pedophiles or otherwise abusing children at an exceptionally high rate compared to the general population. In the absence of other information some skepticism is warranted.
- shadowgovt 7y agoIs it? I've never seen a statistic suggesting that. Feels like it'd be pretty easy to observe if it were happening.
- Kuinox 7y agoWhy do you think this is conspiracy ?
- duxup 7y agoI don't / don't know that it is a conspiracy .
- nyolfen 7y agoit’s a symptom of elite and institutional deligitimatization and it’s everywhere
- spyridonas 7y agoSo you believe that an agent working for CIA on Vault 7 didn't know how to encrypt his hard drive ?