3 ms·
I think what precedes the problem you mention (and one of the main points in the article) is the problem of generating reduced uncertainty in the model. Maybe t
by bumby 7y ago
I think what precedes the problem you mention (and one of the main points in the article) is the problem of generating reduced uncertainty in the model. Maybe there’s a chance for more granular data to enhance that?
- qubex 7y agoThe problem isn’t the granularity of observations, it’s the granularity of the grid with which the simulations are run. As I understand it (by analogy with my own field of macroeconomics) the current limit is the fact that the grid is coarser than the average size of a cloud, and that therefore cloud cover needs to be approximated. That is the real source of uncertainty.
- bumby 7y agoInteresting. So is the grid limited due to computational complexity, like the mesh in finite element analysis?
- qubex 7y agoPrecisely. But don’t take my word for it. If you’re into a light introduction, consider watching Sabine Hossenfelder’s interview of Tim Palmer (a theoretical physicist’s interview of a leading climatologist is a thing of beauty in its own right).
- Angostura 7y ago> The problem isn’t the granularity of observations Perhaps you should tell the people who are running the "big observational campaign happening right now" that they can pack up and go home.
- qubex 7y agoI don’t know why you are being down-voted but IMHO you certainly don’t deserve to be.
- bumby 7y agoI don’t know since they aren’t accompanied with comments but my hunch is they may be conflating scientific consensus with model uncertainty. I.e., if I bring up model uncertainty, then I’m casting doubt on the scientific consensus (which isn’t the case). It’s more about our confidence in the models which is the point of the article. Nate Silver’s “The Signal and the Noise” gives a much better description than I could do