4 ms·
Even a 5C (9F) warming is not "CATASTROPHE." See: https://www.forbes.com/sites/ucenergy/2018/12/05/will-global-warming-shrink-u-s-gdp-10-its-complicated-says-th
by rayiner 7y ago
Even a 5C (9F) warming is not "CATASTROPHE." See: https://www.forbes.com/sites/ucenergy/2018/12/05/will-global-warming-shrink-u-s-gdp-10-its-complicated-says-the-person-who-made-the-estimate/#1ddb805d3f2e https://www.forbes.com/sites/ucenergy/2018/12/05/will-global...
> While it is true that we estimated damages as high as 10% of GDP annually at the end of the century for warming of 15°F above pre-industrial levels, the odds of a temperature change that would drive damages of this magnitude are slim. In fact, they are less than 1-in-100 by our original calculation. Under a scenario of continued growth in global emissions, 9-out-of-10 global change temperature projections fall approximately in the range of 4°F to 11°F by 2100. The median change is closer to 6°F. We deliberately incorporate tail risks in our research, not just “most likely” outcomes, because consideration of tail risks is crucial to sound risk management.
- claudeganon 7y agoNot a catastrophe for whom is the obvious question here.
- rayiner 7y agoPretty much everybody: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/08/20/climate-change-to-slow-global-economic-growth-new-study-finds.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/08/20/climate-change-to-slow-globa... > In other words, if global GDP doubles or halves by 2100, the results suggest real GDP per capita would still be 7.22% below where it would be otherwise. For most of the world, an RCP8.5 scenario is equivalent to knocking out 3-4 years of GDP growth. Bad, but not catastrophic, and probably less bad than the impact of "WWII-style mobilization" and shifting the economy into command-and-control mode.
- claudeganon 7y agoPointing at GDP over and over again is at a best a fuzzy indicator of overall well-being, especially in the developed world where inequality has unmoored it from improvement in material standards for many people. Amazon stock prices skyrocketing tells you little about the health or well-being of their workforce.
- rayiner 7y agoGDP is the number we have. It's not perfect, but it's better than trying to assess the costs without reference to numbers. More significantly, GDP per capita gives a strong measure of the country's capacity to provide for well being, including through redistribution. The specific redistributive policies we adopt or not are mostly orthogonal to climate change.
- tzs 7y agoAlso from that link: > Our localized approach to studying the relationship between climate and society reveals that the burden is spread unevenly. In many counties, GDP decline could total more than 10% by 2100, and in the worst-hit county, Florida's Union County, losses could near 28% for a likely warming scenario under continued emissions growth (the 7°F median change, not the extreme 15°F change highlighted in press coverage). The combined tally almost certainly understates the extent of the damages, because the worst effects are concentrated in places where incomes are lowest. Tumbling incomes in poor counties have a correspondingly small impact on nationwide GDP, meaning the economic burden of climate change is reduced because it falls on those with low incomes. > If the burden is spread evenly, 1% or 2% of national GDP might seem manageable, but we will not all be equal in the face of climate change. Across the United States, there will be winners and losers. What is lost in all of this noise is the sad fact that even those smaller numbers are too high a cost. They come from a subset of outcomes that are well-measured. As ever in this debate, it is important that we look beyond the headlines, beyond the averages, and examine the people at the heart of the issue. Look at the mass of evidence that points to people who will actually be negatively affected by climate change. They are not abstract people not-yet-born and in some far-off land. They are your neighbors. They are your friends. They are you. Combining local climate projections with historical observations yields a personalized, evidence-based outlook of future risk. Our ongoing research is mapping out these local impacts across the globe. That sounds pretty catastrophic.
- rayiner 7y agoIt's only catastrophic if we don't respond appropriately to mitigating the impact in hard-hit areas, and even then only to a relatively small number of people. Retooling our system to perform that mitigation is a much more limited task than the "total war economy" people are talking about to address climate change.