4 ms·
There could be strategic military advantages to having people on Mars. Nuclear mutual assured destruction doesn't work if one side has a base on mars, where it
by londons_explore 7y ago
There could be strategic military advantages to having people on Mars.
Nuclear mutual assured destruction doesn't work if one side has a base on mars, where it would take 6+ months for any fired nuke to arrive.
Having people in spacecraft could be a good place for high-importance leaders - nearly no bunker is nuke-proof, but a spacecraft far away is far harder to hit.
- emiliobumachar 7y agoCould you please spell out how would nuclear MAD stop working? The way I see it, the Mars base could be ignored for MAD purposes unless it's self sufficient and large enough to be considered civilizational survival. By the point it can no longer be ignored, the other side will just aim a couple nukes at it - what will the colonists do, move the base in months? (Also, tangentially, I don't think the whole transit time would apply to something expected to blow up on arrival. It doesn't need to slow down enough to land, just enough to survive plowing trough Mars' thin atmosphere before slamming extra hard on the ground. Heh, for a small enough base the attacker might skip the actual nuclear warhead altogether.)
- londons_explore 7y ago> what will the colonists do, move the base in months? Yes. If you knew that your city would be destroyed in 6 months, you'd build a new one elsewhere. People on earth don't have that privilege due to not having 6 months notice.
- jcranmer 7y agoHow long do you think it takes to build a city?
- est31 7y agoThe 6 months travel time are with current technology, and in a few decades we might be able to have better propulsion systems. It's like saying that keeping the MAD threat alive is expensive because you have to refuel those bombers that circle over the arctic... eventually you find better tech. Also, once the nuke rocket is near mars, it takes only a signal at light speed to re-direct it at whatever settlement you want to target.
- levesque 7y agoNot sure why you got down voted (feels like some people treat this as reddit), but I think hitting a spacecraft with a missile would probably be easier than reach people in a very deep bunker.
- njb311 7y agoThe disadvantage of that would be that high-importance leaders who are in a spacecraft far away won't be high-importance leaders for very long.
- jacquesm 7y agoThis is a completely surreal comment. "One side"? When we're on Mars you'd hope that there would be two sides: Earth and Mars, from the perspective of someone on Mars their buddies next door are a lot more important than any kind of allegiance to Earth based bits such as nations.
- kamaal 7y agoI wonder why this argument doesn't work on earth itself already. Like when some one is sent from one country to another very far country to fight people. You'd wonder why don't use this logic, we are here, why fight for people thousands of miles away. That's because throughout human existence, things like Identity, and an expectation of something in return eventually from the home country/society always exists. The fact that Mars is far doesn't mean anything here, what matters relative time and periods of time people are willing to wait.