7 ms·
Well, politicians aren't doing anything anyway, whether the models predict catastrophe or CATASTROPHE. Already according to the 3° sensitivity predictions we wo
by adrianN 7y ago
Well, politicians aren't doing anything anyway, whether the models predict catastrophe or CATASTROPHE. Already according to the 3° sensitivity predictions we would need an effort that rivals WW2 to stay below 1.5°. Yet major countries are led by climate denialists.
- truculent 7y agowe would need an effort that rivals WW2 to stay below _2.0_
- derg 7y agoCan you even imagine how a Total War economy/society based on transitioning to greener energies, cutting emissions and pollutants, and working on improvements to housing and urban planning would end up looking? Like ignoring the whole climate change thing for a moment (though we absolutely should not do that), just the quality of life improvements to our health and well being this kind of mobilization would bring would be astonishing.
- HenryKissinger 7y agoThat would not be possible today. The wartime World War Two economy we learn about in school was only made possible because of two factors: 1) A massive surge in federal government spending, financed by borrowing from public markets (incl. war bonds), to buy the materiel needed to fight a war on two fronts (in Europe against Germany and in the Pacific against Japan). Such spending caused the public debt as a share of GDP to surge to its highest historical level ever, from about 40% at the start of the war to 100% at its peak, as you can see on this graph: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a7/US_Debt_Held_by_Public.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a7/US_Debt_... . Today, without such a total war effort, we are running trillion dollar deficits. To put it as shortly and bluntly as I could, trying the same thing today would bankrupt the government. Our debt levels are far higher than they were then, in relative terms, and increasing by over a trillion every year. We would be looking at 2 or 3 trillion dollar deficits. Deficits of that magnitude might shake investors' confidence in the U.S.'s ability to service its debt. 2) The United States was coming out of the Great Depression, and the unemployed labor pool was in the double digits, as you can see on this graph: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/68/United_States_unemployment_with_incarceration_1892-2016.png/450px-United_States_unemployment_with_incarceration_1892-2016.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/68/Un... . In other words, there were a lot of unemployed people with nothing to do who could quickly be put to work to produce stuff for the war economy. This is not the case today. The economy is running at full employment. The large spare labor pool that existed then doesn't exist today.
- QuantumGood 7y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/12/12/business/economy/fed-full-employment.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/12/12/business/econ... America has a large shadow labor force. People who do not regularly apply to work are not counted as officially “unemployed.” Have to take this into account.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Udik 7y agoTotal wars are not known to increase the quality of life. If a transition to a green economy guaranteed such massive economic gains (and no pains) don't you think that politicians of all colours would scramble to implement it? The first step to solving issues is to acknowledge all the difficulties that lie ahead: otherwise you end up in a delusional state in which solutions are obvious and easy and the only reason they're not adopted is that everyone else is evil.
- microcolonel 7y agoThe other sad conclusion to derive from this is that the "improvements to urban planning" bit is largely not happening, despite generally broad bipartisan support. It signals to me that people like complaining about things, but do not participate in politics in any productive fashion. Right now it's just team sports, and most people can not name the candidate they are voting for, outside of the presidential election, until they read it off the ballot.
- KevinEldon 7y agoIt may also be that people like the idea of 'improvements in urban planning' when they are intangible, but if those changes involved limiting their land use or bulldozing their inefficient homes and neighborhoods they balk; they may also not like moving those planning decisions from their local communities to some bureaucracy outside of their direct engagement.
- microcolonel 7y agoDon't need to bulldoze much of anything to do something though. The inefficiency of buildings is a tiny part of the problem, especially in temperate climates; more mixed use zoning, and the relaxing of single family dwelling zoning, will have a dramatic impact on excess travel. Transport accounts for basically a third of U.S. energy use, though it has been hardly growing over the last few years, which is a good start. The most efficient car, bus, or train, is the one that you didn't ride.
- rayiner 7y ago> Total War economy/society > quality of life improvements to our health and well being this kind of mobilization would bring would be astonishing. The impact on quality of life and society would be "astonishing," but they won't be improvements. The Soviets and Chinese tried similar "mobilization[s]" for food production. The idea was to direct society's efforts to producing enough food for everybody. Tens of millions of people died of starvation as a result. It turns out that governments are bad at running economies. I don't know why so many people think that the same mechanism (a command-and-control economy) will lead to a different result just because you change the goal from food or industrial production to climate change mitigation.
- nesyt 7y agoThanks for the straw man. American WW2 mobilization didn't kill ten million people - that's not an intrinsic attribute of a country focusing on something. Think also new deal / public works projects like the Hoover Dam (many died working on the Dam but not because it was a government mobilization project). Just the government spending a bunch of money on environmentally focused projects could happen and could be good.
- adrianN 7y agoAt least it didn't kill ten million people unintentionally.
- harryh 7y agoAmerican WW2 mobilization didn't kill ten million people Um, sure it did? Killing a lot of people was, in a sense, the goal.
- nate_meurer 7y agoIt's not a straw man, and your examples are no more apt than Rayiner's. America's WWII mobilization is really nothing like the Green New Deal. The total cost of the U.S. war effort is estimated at around $300 B (adjusted for 2009 dollars) [1]. The lowest realistic estimates for the cost of an effective Green New Deal are around double that amount every year, and lasting for decades [2]. It's true that WWII cost far more relative to GDP (over a third, versus 2% for the New Green Deal estimate above), but expressing the cost relative to GDP is not very useful in this context; in 1945 the U.S. was poised to enter a period of ten percent annual GDP growth at a time that military spending was plunging. The situation now is completely opposite; the U.S. will possibly never sustain greater than 2% GDP growth, and the Green New Deal proposes to pull money out of that for decades to come. The character of WWII spending was also completely different. That money was largely spent on things that were pretty much guaranteed to help the war effort; materiel, industrial infrastructure, and troops. There was little risk of misallocation. In contrast, the Green New Deal is fraught with misallocation risk. In that way, I suppose that a comparison to modern military spending is actually quite appropriate. 1 - https://eh.net/encyclopedia/the-american-economy-during-world-war-ii/ https://eh.net/encyclopedia/the-american-economy-during-worl... 2 - https://newleftreview.org/issues/II112/articles/robert-pollin-de-growth-vs-a-green-new-deal https://newleftreview.org/issues/II112/articles/robert-polli...
- KevinEldon 7y agoGermany had a Total War economy in WW2. North Korea has one today. The Russian Revolution might not be considered 'Total War', but was single-minded in its focus similar to what you're suggesting. None of these economies worked out well for their citizens. Even the US economy/society during WW2 was more than victory gardens and war bonds; personal freedoms were limited, there were interment camps, forced enlistment, war profiteering, and propaganda (along with the hundreds of thousands of deaths).
- adrianN 7y agoMy point is that Americans were willing to pay that price even though the actual threat of Nazi Germany was not even in the same ballpark as the threat posed by climate change. I'm also reasonably sure that the switch away from fossil fuels can be done without hundreds of thousands dead.
- lacker 7y agoThat's not how I imagine a total war. The point of "Total War" is that you start making every decision necessary to achieve your goal, that you weren't willing to make under a democratic process. If we go to total war to prevent climate change, that means things like: * Shutting down power and fuel supplies to poor countries that can't afford current solar or wind power * Military conquest of uncooperative countries * Bombing coal mines to shut them down * Bombing oil fields so nobody can get the oil * Slaughtering foreign civilians to reduce their carbon emissions When I think of a "total war" caused by an emergency response to global warming, those are the sort of consequences I imagine. Let's hope we don't get to "total war".
- sambull 7y agoIt's because the predominate feeling of those in power is this issue is overpopulation. And yes a population reduction the type WWII provided would be in the 'right direction'. That this is all 'carrying capacity' and they know how to deal with that. Just need more room to live. Steve Bannon and Trump are fans, "The authors envision a return to a more traditional, conservative social order as one outcome of a crisis. They also see the possibility of retribution and punishment for those who resist or refuse to comply with the new expectations for conformity. Mr. Trump’s “with us or against us” attitude raises questions about what kind of leader he would be in such a crisis — and what kind of loyalty his administration might demand." https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/08/us/politics/bannon-fourth-turning.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/08/us/politics/bannon-fourth... "If they do not yield — kill all males", says the terrorist christians: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matt_Shea#%22Biblical_Basis_for_War%22_manifesto https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matt_Shea#%22Biblical_Basis_fo...
- pacala 7y agoMajor countries are led by popular demands. Minor countries as well. Vast overuse of energy resources is a pattern intertwined with modern life, from housing to transportation to food to recreation. The people demand having a vehicle with more than 100hp at their whim. Now picture a herd of 100 horses for every person on Earth. It is political suicide to propose cutting down to ecological sustainable levels of 1 horse per person. That's before we take in account the population explosion of 5-10-20x compared to pre-industrial levels. Not sure where you even begin implementing policies to reduce the population levels to ecological sustainable levels. As a species, we are simply incapable to comprehend that the way out of poverty is intelligent frugality. Instead, we attempt to brute force our way. The effort needed to fall back into an ecological sustainable band far surpasses WW2, and no one wants to hear about the actual costs. Nothing will change until mother Nature will do the change for us. The hard way.
- lostapathy 7y agoWe already know how to reduce population - education for women and access to contraception. Birth rates have slowed so much in some parts of the world that it is, apparently, worrying for their economic stability.
- Frost1x 7y agoWe humans have developed one fairly good approach to problem solving by focusing on localized concerns and self-interest. For many problems, this seems to work fairly well with a few negative yet manageable side-effects. In my opinion, these approaches completely fail at solving large issues that require large orchestrated efforts that require things at state, nation, and even world scale and longer timescales than an individual or their kids. We haven't really developed a 'hammer' for those sort of problems and that hammer keeps competing with our 'saw' we use on the other problems whose proponents want to only use their 'saw' for every problem they see, ignoring its shortcomings.
- bdamm 7y agoYes, I think it is pretty clear that this social structure is the cause and at this point the only solution. Why the only solution? Generally I view the prevention of a strong global government to be a conservative issue and for better or for worse that isn't likely to happen (peacefully). The construction of such a government would speed up solving this issue but then we'd be left with another power hungry government to reign in.
- usaar333 7y agoWe've solved plenty of problems at scale; think ozone layer depletion being reduced. The problem with climate change is that it is really expensive to fix with highly uncertain costs to do so.
- jellicle 7y agoClimate action has a net negative cost; spending $10 will get you more than $10 of benefit for almost any intervention you'd care to name. So it's not expensive in any long-run calculation, only the short-run.
- usaar333 7y agoCertainly high ROI ones (say not building new coal power plants), but definitely not the lower ROI interventions. Nor is cost net negative if you use high discount rates and try lower co2 targets (e.g. 3 degrees warming by 2100 is much more likely to have positive ROI than say holding 2 degrees). Huge controversy around protecting against lower probability, highly destructive scenarios. Point is there's lots of controversy here. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_climate_change_mitigation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_climate_change_...
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Already according to the 3° sensitivity predictions we would need an effort that rivals WW2 to stay below 1.5°. Comparisons to a war are overly dramatic because it puts the destruction on the opposite side of the effort. If you're in a war and two countries spend a trillion dollars fighting the war, those resources go to causing trillions of dollars of damage to the other country -- most of the cost of the war is getting bombed, not making bombs. With climate change it's the opposite -- the more we do against it, the less damage there is overall. On top of that, most of the "costs" are just replacing other costs -- you have to spend money building solar panels, but then you don't have to spend money doing oil exploration or mining coal, which offsets most to all of the cost. On top of that, wars are characteristically fought by governments with all the bureaucratic inefficiency that implies, whereas the single biggest thing we could do against climate change is to accurately price carbon and then let the market find the most efficient way to optimize it out. Obviously that doesn't get us out of actually doing it, but the biggest problem isn't that it's actually that hard from an economic perspective, it's that it's hard from a political perspective because the oil industry has a trillion dollar interest in not ceasing to exist.
- rayiner 7y agoEven a 5C (9F) warming is not "CATASTROPHE." See: https://www.forbes.com/sites/ucenergy/2018/12/05/will-global-warming-shrink-u-s-gdp-10-its-complicated-says-the-person-who-made-the-estimate/#1ddb805d3f2e https://www.forbes.com/sites/ucenergy/2018/12/05/will-global... > While it is true that we estimated damages as high as 10% of GDP annually at the end of the century for warming of 15°F above pre-industrial levels, the odds of a temperature change that would drive damages of this magnitude are slim. In fact, they are less than 1-in-100 by our original calculation. Under a scenario of continued growth in global emissions, 9-out-of-10 global change temperature projections fall approximately in the range of 4°F to 11°F by 2100. The median change is closer to 6°F. We deliberately incorporate tail risks in our research, not just “most likely” outcomes, because consideration of tail risks is crucial to sound risk management.
- claudeganon 7y agoNot a catastrophe for whom is the obvious question here.
- rayiner 7y agoPretty much everybody: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/08/20/climate-change-to-slow-global-economic-growth-new-study-finds.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/08/20/climate-change-to-slow-globa... > In other words, if global GDP doubles or halves by 2100, the results suggest real GDP per capita would still be 7.22% below where it would be otherwise. For most of the world, an RCP8.5 scenario is equivalent to knocking out 3-4 years of GDP growth. Bad, but not catastrophic, and probably less bad than the impact of "WWII-style mobilization" and shifting the economy into command-and-control mode.
- claudeganon 7y agoPointing at GDP over and over again is at a best a fuzzy indicator of overall well-being, especially in the developed world where inequality has unmoored it from improvement in material standards for many people. Amazon stock prices skyrocketing tells you little about the health or well-being of their workforce.
- protanopia 7y agoWhy is a 1.5° maximum a target that should be aimed for? William Nordhaus says a 3.5° maximum is the optimal target. His models show that a 3.5° maximum would result in a net benefit of 30 trillion whereas a 2.5° maximum would be a detriment of 50 trillion[1]. That is to say the reduction in damage would be far less than the cost of implementing such a policy. The cost for a 1.5° maximum target would be even more severe. [1]W. Nordhaus, “Projections and Uncertainties about Climate Change in an Era of Minimal Climate Policies,” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, vol. 10, no. 3, pp. 333–360, Aug. 2018, doi: 10.1257/pol.20170046. edit: This comment is currently sitting at -2. If you think a 1.5° target is optimal, you should explain why you think so rather than just down voting this post. The paper I linked to is by William Nordhaus who won the Nobel Prize for economics in 2018 for his work related to the economics of climate change.
- adrianN 7y agoThis is what the IPCC has to say about this: https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/chapter/chapter-3/ https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/chapter/chapter-3/
- Vysero 7y ago"we would need an effort that rivals WW2" Exactly and from what I remember WW2 had around 75 million casualties. Which is an unfortunate and grim prediction on what it's going to take to get any real action from politicians.