4 ms·
Has there actually been any rigorous study of the 10,000 hour figure? I really don't believe it or the Gladwell's book because it discounts actual talent. It
by protomyth 16y ago
Has there actually been any rigorous study of the 10,000 hour figure? I really don't believe it or the Gladwell's book because it discounts actual talent. It seems like the great a way to keep someone from finding their actual talent, much like giving awards for participation and having no "winners".
- PaulHoule 16y agoI don't know about rigorous studies, but it seems like common sense to me (though you might get that 10k down to 5k or 3k in some situations) Most people take at least 5 years to get a PhD, pro athletes take at least that long to get established, even Justin Bieber worked really hard at making music when he was a little kid. 10k hours is also roughly the timescale involved with children learning language. You can certainly see people who seem come out of the blue, like Sylvester Stallone's success with Rocky, you usually find that there was a lot of hard work in the background. Stallone was playing bit parts, writing scripts, and lifting weights for a few years before he got his break. Certainly his acting, writing, directing, and bodybuilding progressed considerably after he got big.
- protomyth 16y agoI really not sure it is common sense. I believe you have to have some talent or any amount of practice isn't going to help. I could spend 10,000 hours trying to sing, but it is not going to help, I just don't have that type of voice. I don't discount people's hard work at improving a talent, but I don't think the hours get you there. The all-it-takes-is-10,000-hours vibe of the book seems to be incorrect.
- PaulHoule 16y agoSure, natural talent helps, but you need natural talent + 10k hours to get world class performance. There's no shortcut, unless you count being in the right place at the right time and having no competition.
- protomyth 16y agoI don't think natural talent "helps", I truly believe it is a prerequisite.