4 ms·
Maybe outside of China we see it as "ruled by fear", but that's really not the case in China, at least for the majority: China doesn't try to make it's citizens
by ineedasername 7y ago
Maybe outside of China we see it as "ruled by fear", but that's really not the case in China, at least for the majority: China doesn't try to make it's citizens afraid. Quite the opposite. Their modus operandi is "move along, nothing to see here, everything is fine." Indeed, that was their initial message to the public for this virus. So, the problem and partial cause of panic is when there is a problem that is very definitely not "nothing to see here", and the government is demonstrably, extremely wrong and perhaps incompetent. When so much is seen to be controlled by the government, a flaw in that armor is all the more worrying.
- daenz 7y agoChina is a place where you can be locked to a chair and interrogated by police for social media comments critical of the state. Don't try to tell me it isn't a government ruled through fear. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6uy12RpqQc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6uy12RpqQc
- throw4r563s 7y agoThat’s like saying Americans are in fear of being water boarded by the authorities. Chinese people in China are not afraid of the cops. If you see how Chinese people interact with cops, I bet you would be surprised. I regularly see people yelling and screaming at them, and the Chinese cops will still try to diffuse the situation.
- gruez 7y ago>Chinese people in China are not afraid of the cops. If you see how Chinese people interact with cops, I bet you would be surprised. Perhaps they're not afraid of the cops on a daily basis, but they are afraid of the CCP. >That’s like saying Americans are in fear of being water boarded by the authorities. Guess where you can shit talk about the head of state and not end up in a re-education camp?
- bllguo 7y agoOkay? And the US is a place where I can get brutalized, shot, and killed by the police based on.. nothing. The fact of the matter is that the vast majority of Chinese citizens are living lives thinking and worrying about the same kinds of things we do. Not cowering in fear bemoaning their lack of freedoms.
- bobbytran 7y agoI've heard this argument again and again from Chinese government sympathizers...and it's just not true. The vast majority of people aren't brutalized and shot by the police. If it does happen, it goes through a trial and the court systems. The vast majority of people talking out against the Chinese government will be jailed or re-educated in China...that's the difference.
- bllguo 7y agoYes, the vast majority of US citizens aren't getting brutalized by the police. Similarly, the vast majority of Chinese citizens are not being jailed or re-educated. You can't just compare the US population at large to the subset of Chinese people who speak out against the government. The claim was that people in China live in a state of fear, and I refuted it. Let's not conflate things.
- daenz 7y ago>The claim was that people in China live in a state of fear, and I refuted it That wasn't the claim, so you refuted a strawman. The claim was that China governs through fear, not that Chinese live in fear. When people disappear and are "re-educated" against their will for speaking out about the government, as an official policy of your government, you are governing through fear. Refute that.
- ineedasername 7y agoI refute it by pointing out that if the people are not afraid, they are not ruled by fear. The vast majority are no more afraid of their government than the average person in the U.S. is. Sure, some people have reason to fear-- there's the ever present problem of racial discrimination. And I don't mean this to say the U.S. is just as bad. I mean that people caught up in the badness in either country are outliers. So few in number as to make the issue seem too abstract, even if it is much worse in China. They just don't see their restrictions on freedoms through the same lens as folks in the Western world.
- ineedasername 7y agoThat is not common fear for the billion+ people living there. I have worked alongside many workers from China, and had a few student workers work for me. They do not view they their government as overly oppressive. They view it as working in the best interests of the people, protecting people from harmful things, like internet content through the firewall: in that case it may be they can circumvent it with some effort, but they view the initiative as coming from a place of wanting to take care of their people. You are bringing an outsider's view to this, and I'm telling you, it's not how the Chinese people feel, for the most part. I understand how that's confusing. One person was kind enough to indulge me in two hours of conversation on the topic, and it took that and shorter conversations with a number of people to realize that, Yes, the Chinese people have swallowed the blue pill offered by their government. Not that they're particularly unique in that respect, but, well, there it is. They do not live in fear in the way you think.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoStated with a western perspective here, but I wouldn't be surprised if anybody who lived under an oppressive regime would openly admit they fear it, for fear of the repercussion. Can you meaningfully distinguish those who genuinely don't feel any fear (because they're bold, or ignorant, or possibly both), and those who superficially state they don't fear their government?
- ineedasername 7y agoA U.S. citizen that migrated from China has very little reason to self-censor or dissemble on this topic. After encountering this beguiling attitude in conversations with others, I sought out such a person, an acquaintance who was a Professor of linguistics, who became a U.S. citizen decades earlier and still had close contact. He confirmed it all. This topic has also been a minor obsession for me, and the reading I've done further confirms it. Even when the people might be aware of something their government has done, they feel protected, that the government is acting in their best interests. And that awareness of incidents is rare. I showed a video of Tianmen Square to a Chinese student I knew. Not only hadn't they known about the incident, but their response was, "oh, those people (protestors) shouldn't have been doing that."
- nate_meurer 7y agoWouldn't a more accurate MO be "move along, nothing to see here, everything is fine, but if you speak out of turn we can make you disappear"?
- ineedasername 7y agoThey have a but more latitude than that. Grumble a bit and criticize, fine. Get too big and get too much attention, that's a problem. I understand they have a sort of warning system though, so it's not all "that dude said Jinping is a tyrant, get the black bags and duct tape!" I mean, it's bad, but not that bad. In part because by and large the government propoganda fulfills it's purpose.
- celticmusic 7y ago> Indeed, that was their initial message to the public for this virus. You're going to have to source that because I have a friend who lives in China and he was telling me from the start that China was surprisingly open about all of it.
- sgustard 7y agoSource: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/01/world/asia/china-coronavirus.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/01/world/asia/china-coronavi...
- ineedasername 7y agoIt appeared they were being pretty open about it, 10 days ago it was very "only a few hundred cases, and it doesn't spread easily from person to person." One first-hand account said they were telling people there hadn't been any new cases in a few days, so all was safe, go out and celebrate the new year. Now, they have the equivalent of double the population of Texas on lockdown. It's also important to realize that the Chinese government isn't quite so monolithic and in lockstep with itself as you might think. It's entirely possible that in one smaller region the local government was being open, while the wider message was the "nothing to see." That's speculation though, just mentioning it as a way they could have been both open on one level and misleading on another.
- bouncycastle 7y ago"move along, nothing to see here, everything is fine." Because, what is the alternative? To blow the whistle? Surely most would be too afraid to do that, so naturally the safest bet is to play the "everything is fine" game.