6 ms·
I found it shocking to realize that thousand years old realizations are still worth more than the vast majority of ideas invented since (regarding human existen
by agumonkey 7y ago
I found it shocking to realize that thousand years old realizations are still worth more than the vast majority of ideas invented since (regarding human existence that is).
Gives a slight taint to the meaning of the word 'progress'.
- dwrodri 7y agoThe progress we have made towards changing the conditions humans live in has evolved immensely, but the progress we have made towards a different human condition from our ancestors is almost nonexistent.
- agumonkey 7y agoyes agreed, materially we're off the pit I'd argue though, that a good life is a balance between human condition and material needs. A kind of optimized frugality.
- taberiand 7y agoThat's the thing about philosophy - it doesn't take any special tools or rely on modern technology to study, just intellect. People today aren't any more or less sophisticated than the people of thousands of years ago, and them no more than the people thousands of years before them. Philosophy transcends time and space, and the golden age of Greek and Roman philosophy is full of extremely insightful and applicable knowledge to our modern lives.
- stallmanite 7y agoSo philosophy is similar to software as a field in that you don’t need a bunch of equipment to get going? Maybe it’s trivial but I had never considered that fact or it’s implications before.
- refset 7y agoMy favourite computer-related quote: "programming is applied philosophy" (origin unknown, sorry!)
- therein 7y agoI always thought, and probably not for the most solid reasons: Math is applied philosophy and theory of knowledge. Physics is Math applied on reality. Chemistry is applied Physics. Biology is applied Chemistry.
- thunderbong 7y agoAgree. I had also thought of the sciences in that manner.
- bigbonch 7y agoI would ammend the last two points and say Chemistry is Physics applied to physical primitives and Biology is Chemistry applied to organic phenomena or something like that.
- drworm 7y agoWhich brings to mind this classic XKCD: https://xkcd.com/435/ https://xkcd.com/435/
- rxhernandez 7y agoIt could be argued that physics has nothing at all to do with math; merely, that it is a convenient and powerful tool for humans to make sense of it. I've seen Susskind convincingly (albeit shallowly) argue that more "primitive" animals understand physics and I would be surprised if it was easy to argue that animals understand mathematics without circular logic or quick and loose definitions of what math is.
- thunderbong 7y agoI'm not so sure. Of course, I have asked many philosophical questions of myself, when understanding software. This, I've noticed, especially happens when you're crossing layers. For example, between hardware / assembly, assembly / C, C / OOP. However, considering that we have not really come up with a language with which we can communicate with computers seamlessly, I have my doubts. Because, unless we have a language, we can't really philosophize. This could be a problem due to the interfaces we have though. Or probably, because our interfaces with computers seem to be getting broader and richer with each generation of hardware, we haven't really been able to freeze on the language through which we communicate.
- FabHK 7y ago> People today aren't any more or less sophisticated than the people of thousands of years ago, and them no more than the people thousands of years before them. Well, yes and no. We certainly know a lot more than people knew back then. We know vastly more about the cosmos, we know about atoms, we know about evolution, we know much about the brain. We also face very different challenges than people millennia ago - we have weapons of mass destruction, more obesity than famine (in developed countries), social media, and so on. Thus, I'd say only a small part of philosophy is still applicable and valuable today. (For example, Seneca was a Stoic, and Stoicism had much to say about physics and logic, which is pretty obsolete now, I'd say.) There's a potential fallacy there, like thinking that old music was better, when what we still hear today is just the very best of old music.
- sifar 7y agoHow does knowing more about the physical world help me understand myself better ? People more than two millennia later still find what he said relevant. What is it that we have produced in the last century would meet that test ? How much of that will be due to our increased knowledge and technology ?
- Vaskivo 7y agoKnowing genetics makes you understand why and how you are similar to your parents. Knowing that physical and psychological state are linked, and that they affect each other. We have ways of introspecting one's mind and body and understand the the "whys" of being an individual and also Human.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoExcept genetics is too low level to describe anything but the most basic features. On that matter - my dad and my grandpa were alcoholics; and thus I have the same vice if I don’t pay attention to my motivations in life. However knowing genetics didn’t help me understand that :)
- dsego 7y ago
- leftyted 7y agoProgress lies in the fact that everyone has access to these ideas. It isn't surprising that the best ideas are old. Any idea that has survived for thousands of years has to be good.
- agumonkey 7y agobruh, I'm not even sure that's remotely true. I'd bet my left pinky that people knew this earlier in life than us because our society shields us from our true selves. Too many distractions to the point it's harmful.
- IggleSniggle 7y agoOr at least it has survivability, which is often but not always a proxy for a "good idea." Ideas that are very good but also unpleasant or exceedingly complex are unlikely to survive. Perhaps for some definitions of good, these ideas are not good.
- jvanderbot 7y agoMy favorite book on this exact sentiment (with healthy doses of neuroscience) is Happiness Hypothesis. Recommended!
- ellius 7y agoTaleb makes the argument this should actually be obvious. Old ideas have survived over time, which suggests they are good enough to be passed down from generation to generation. New ideas are a complete crapshoot, and you have to do a lot more work to figure out if they're worth a damn.
- jborichevskiy 7y agoThe Lindy effect Wikipedia article has further reading on this as well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect
- lubonay 7y agoI guess that's why they call it "surviving the test of time".
- apatters 7y agoI disagree, if someone draws motivation and satisfaction from Epictetus' quote then that's great and I don't want to cast any shade on it. But I think it's very dated and we have better ideas today. Just to put forward a few recent criticisms: #1. This quote is a very literal example of a sort of "man up" style of prescriptive thinking which tells you to solve your behavioral problems by Being More Manly. For the vast majority of people, being told to Be A Man doesn't work to alter behavior in the long run, it discourages self esteem and offers no practical guidance. If studying mammalian behavior is any guide, this sort of advice is likely a product of a man's instinctual dominance drive. Males love to give advice because when it sounds good it helps them accrue status and cement their position in the dominance hierarchy, which increases their mating options. We have numerous moderns alternative to Be A Man if you want to change your behaviors, the best ones are based on the past 50 years of research into how the brain works. They typically focus on understanding emotional, unconscious, or instinctual behavior and working out how to process these things more productively. Examples include cognitive behavioral therapy (and a host of similar emerging therapies), or BJ Foggs' Tiny Habits framework (which was recently shared on HN). #2. For a criticism of a totally different tack, Epictetus and Seneca are both operating within a rigid framework that privileges values such as efficiency, self-improvement, and accomplishment. Presumably, they see these things as the best path to happiness. Why are these values privileged? What authority has established that any of them, including personal happiness, are important and meaningful to pursue? In the past century we've been exposed to multiple strains of existentialist, postmodernist, and nihilist thought which all emerge from the same revelation--existence fundamentally has no meaning, all value systems are human constructs, and the universe is much larger than our day to day struggles. All our traditional values are now beset by refutations. We believed in God, but centuries of scientific progress have dispelled the evidence supporting His existence. We believed in civilization, but our largest societies went on to slaughter millions. We thought the universe revolved around us, but learned that we're ants crawling on the face of a pale blue dot, of no consequence in the cosmos to any but our own self-centered perspective. This might all sound pretty dark, but the good news is that nothing you do is really important. The universe will remain unperturbed no matter what actions you take (or don't)! So if you're stressing about how well you live, remember that you're merely chasing fictions in a framework that someone else cooked up. This is a modern day revelation that would never have been achieved without modern science and rationalism, and is still developing. There are as many views on how to process existence's meaninglessness as there are philosophers. To name a few: Nietschze's will to power, Camus' absurdism, Sartre's pursuit of personal freedom. Alternatively it's fine to spend your afternoon playing Xbox, no matter what your parents say. #3,4,5++ I'm sure there are more!