7 ms·
The American date notation is simply a direct reflection of the spoken language. We say "February second, 2020" and we write "2/2/2020". (Contra the root commen
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
The American date notation is simply a direct reflection of the spoken language. We say "February second, 2020" and we write "2/2/2020". (Contra the root comment, I can't agree that 2/2/2020 is a palindrome.) I don't see this as being crazy or even unusual.
When order matters, you invariably want big-endian notation, which is why that notation is acceptable everywhere regardless of the usual native notation. But by the same token, it means that all other styles are equally "nuts". European day-month-year notation doesn't have any technical advantages over month-day-year.
- justinclift 7y ago> We say "February second, 2020" ... Interesting. We (Australian) say "Second of Feb, 2020". ;)
- rags2riches 7y agoWhat about the Fourth of July then?
- thaumasiotes 7y agoWhat about it? It's the name of a holiday. 12/25 is often called Christmas, and yet 9/29 is never called Michaelmas. Same thing.
- stevekemp 7y agoThe parent was making the point that generally Americans refer to dates such as "May 2nd", "April 14th". But one of their biggest holidays is explicitly called "4th of July", changing the ordering.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoAnd a proper name is not good evidence of normal usage. "Christmas" is normal use in an older, Catholic method of identifying calendar dates. Americans don't use that method; most couldn't if they wanted to. But Christmas itself is still identified that way for historical reasons -- the word has gone from being an example of talking about the calendar to being an example of a proper name. "4th of July" is not a method that Americans couldn't use if they wanted to, but it is an ossified usage that doesn't reflect how Americans generally refer to dates. Like Christmas, it is a proper name of limited evidentiary value.
- Kaiyou 7y agoHuh, where I'm from the 24th of December is Christmas. The 25th is the day after Christmas.
- loco5niner 7y agoReally? Where are you from? This might help explain how Santa delivers all those presents in "one night".
- Kaiyou 7y agoPossibly it's the difference between being an atheist and a catholic, since I faintly remember my catholic friends receiving presents on the morning of the 25th, while I would receive them on the evening of the 24th.
- loco5niner 7y agoInteresting. Are you from Canada?
- Kaiyou 7y agoI'm from Europe, but not from an English speaking country.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoOpening presents on Christmas Eve is a pretty common tradition. Calling Christmas Eve "Christmas" is not common at all.
- Lio 7y agoI don’t know, I always imagined that you said “4th of July” because up to that point you were Brits and that’s how we say it. ...and then the very next day, without adult supervision, you started saying your dates weirdly and dropping the “u”s out of words, stuff like that.* * DISCLAIMER: May not be an accurate representation of history. :P
- thaumasiotes 7y agoIt's more accurate than it might sound. If I recall correctly, the American spelling reforms were largely a one-man top-down effort driven by the ideological goal of being more separate from Britain.
- justinclift 7y agoIt's commonly referred to as "Simplified English" for good reason. ;)
- dcuthbertson 7y ago> I always imagined that you said “4th of July” because up to that point you were Brits True, but nowadays we say "Independence Day" :-)
- iso947 7y agoMacy’s call it 4th of July https://www.macys.com/shop/4th-of-july-sale https://www.macys.com/shop/4th-of-july-sale
- umanwizard 7y agoYou can say any date like that in American English, it’s just less common. “Today is the second of February” sounds perfectly natural, but I’d be more likely to say “Today is February second”.
- loco5niner 7y agoAs in everything else in American English, there are exceptions.
- hibbelig 7y agoThat middle-endianness is spoken doesn’t make it better. It’s still crazy. Starting with the most general and ending with the most specific is a logical order. Doing it the other way round is also logical. But starting with the middle makes no sense. It doesn’t seem unusual to you because you use it often. That said I’m German and I realize that German postal addresses are crazy for the same reason. I wish we‘d adopt the Chinese format: country first then province (state), then County then town then neighborhood then street and house. German addresses are middle endian: street then house number then zip code then city then country. The right order seems to be: city, zip, street, house number. Most general to most specific.
- cortesoft 7y agoFor something like addresses, usage pattern is going to matter... if most mail is sent within the city, then putting street first makes sense, because the city is almost always the same; it shouldn't take up valuable real estate at the front of the address. The broadest unit that is likely to change going first makes sense.
- gsich 7y agoOr from botton to top: country, city, zip, housenumber, street, name.
- mopsi 7y agoWhat's so crazy about the German notation? Seems to make perfect sense, as it goes line-by-line from the smallest to the largest sorting unit: 1. Exact street location (street + house) 2. District (postal code) 3. City 4. Country Also I prefer this order over the Chinese, because I assume most people handling mail will need to smallest details and it would just be very annoying if local mailmen had to skip over country and city names every time before reaching the bit they actually need.
- lucideer 7y agoYou listed two details on one line to make the German notation seem non-crazy. A more "logical" notation, as per the gp's comment would start: 1. Exact street location (house + street)
- gmac 7y agoChicken and egg. I (in British English) say the second of February.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoI would agree that there's influence in both directions between the written pattern and the usual manner of speech. All I'm saying here is that there's nothing surprising about the written pattern matching the usual manner of speech. That is the primary purpose of writing; it's weirder for the writing not to match the speech. (Although certainly not unheard of; it is the norm in e.g. Chinese.)
- elif 7y agoUnfortunately, you're using an idiosyncratic American "usual manner of speech" to justify an idiosyncratic American format.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoAnd the problem with that is... what? Are you saying we should all speak Chinese because spoken Chinese dates go in correct sorting order?
- umanwizard 7y agoIdiosyncratic? Of course. People in different countries speak differently. Every natural language is totally arbitrary and “idiosyncratic”. What is your point?
- iso947 7y agoThe assertion that most people and most countries in spoken language say “day [of] month”, which I find anecdotally accurate, although that’s mainly in European countries and languages This matches why almost every country in the world uses “d/m/y” in normal usage.
- 7y ago