4 ms·
>I'm unconvinced that a college education is actually even that useful. How is this a question? How many high school grads have you interviewed and thought yo
by jayd16 7y ago
>I'm unconvinced that a college education is actually even that useful.
How is this a question? How many high school grads have you interviewed and thought you could spin them up to the usefulness of a graduate from nothing in a reasonable amount of time/effort?
Education is expensive, sure. We can talk about that... but useful? It seems obviously useful to me.
- recuter 7y agoWow.
- slowdog 7y agoNot sure if you're missing the point of the poster above. Poster is more likely asking whether the education gained in college is actually useful vs the doors opened by having that diploma. If one dropped out of college right before graduation with 99% of the education, likely that person would end up with worse off job prospects compared to the person who completed their program
- InitialLastName 7y agoOne of the most important signals sent by finishing a college degree is "I can finish the things I start". That also happens to be one with great transferability into a workplace driven increasingly by independent work.
- jayd16 7y agoThe diploma is useful in certain fields I'm sure. Although I doubt most CS employers would really hold you to it if you explained you never completed your final quarter but aced the interview. However, they said college education not college diploma. They're clearly talking about the skills learned.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- overgard 7y agoTo answer your question: plenty. I've had the pleasure of working with a lot of people without college educations who are great.
- jayd16 7y agoSure. A degree isn't a requirement to be good. That's not whats in question here. I'm trying to illustrate the absurd notion that the skills you gain in college are not useful by pointing out the obvious skill gap between a fresh high school and fresh college grad.
- kamarg 7y agoWhat about a fresh college grad vs a high school grad with four more years of problem solving, socialization, and maturity? They comparison you make isn't fair because you aren't giving the high school grad the benefit of added learning they would accumulate in the same time period the college grad was taking courses.
- jayd16 7y agoWhat do you mean, isn't fair? That dev with 4 years experience had to start with zero once. The scenario is exactly what the high school grad will face. That said, the argument still stands with a candidate with a degree and a similarly aged candidate with no relevant work experience but similar maturity, odds are you'll still be able to pass the Pepsi challenge and see the difference. Remember, I'm only arguing against the notion that college is useless. If you're lucky enough to get a mentorship that will teach you everything you need right out of high school, great. Go for it. That's not exactly a common occurrence. College is a high cost, low risk way to get some experience and land a job but its certainly not useless.
- eli_gottlieb 7y agoMy undergrad didn't teach actual courses in C, Ruby on Rails, Scala or in fact any other "style" of programming I've ever used in industry besides Java and Python. And I went to a top-20 undergrad for CS. That doesn't mean it wasn't useful. It was. I use stuff I learned in my past education a reasonable portion of the time, now, as a researcher. That doesn't mean that it was a more direct way to "get a job", had I the courage to try that path at the time, than just doing an apprenticeship would have been.
- ur-whale 7y ago> Education is expensive, sure. We can talk about that... but useful? It seems obviously useful to me. It all depends what your definition of "Education" is. If you mean a college degree, then I'd agree that in most cases (depending on your major), it's indeed not particularly useful.