3 ms·
Silicon Valley is simply maturing from a new emerging market into a more traditional, but no less innovative one. As Schumpeter pointed out many decades ago the
by Barrin92 7y ago
Silicon Valley is simply maturing from a new emerging market into a more traditional, but no less innovative one. As Schumpeter pointed out many decades ago the idea that 'small is beautiful' is not really true.
The equilibrium for innovative ecosystems is not small-scale but rather monopolistic competition, because complex production processes require scale and knowledge that can only be managed by sufficiently large institutions. In mature industries, the competition happens between monopolistic players who for a while earn surplus profit through the collection of economic rent and are then replaced through creative destruction by another player (think Myspace and Facebook), rather than the bazaar economy that this article seems to advocate in which profits are constantly burned away by competition, it is surplus capital of monopolistic firms that enables innovation.
This also shows in productivity statistics, wages and so on, where large firms simply win out. And as one data point, Apple is worth about as much as all unicorns on the planet combined. People tend to overrate the importance and size of startups for what I think are ideological reasons.
And also, in addition, it should be pointed out that the American government played a significant role in enabling the 'old' silicon valley in the first place. This role (also one which Schumpeter introduced) of the entrepreneurial state seems to be forgotten on occasion. It wasn't just smart kids in garages but also the defence department which contributed to the development of the SV ecosystem.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 7y agoCompletely agree with your take. People forget that Bell Labs and Xerox Parc which were at the forefront of innovation were the result of cash rich monopolies.
- WalterBright 7y agoXerox evolved out of Haloid, which struggled near bankruptcy for years to build an impossible machine - the photocopier - one of the great disruptive innovations.
- zzzcpan 7y ago> it is surplus capital of monopolistic firms that enables innovation This is purely ideological assertion that just excuses predatory behavior. Surplus capital does not enable innovation whatsoever. Innovation is more like quality, it is habitual and cultural. Give all the right people an opportunity to apply themselves and you get innovation and, of course, give everyone a chance to become the right people, to raise their children that way, educate them the right way, not indoctrinate, etc. The role of capital and startups here is not creating such people, but that of wealth and power: to take ownership of future innovations that could be created by such people and remain wealthy and powerful.
- notduncansmith 7y ago> complex production processes require scale and knowledge that can only be managed by sufficiently large institutions I think this makes an assumption that industry equilibrium relies on complex production processes. There is a lot of interest in simple production processes and I think that one trend that will continue in the next few years is the (both open and closed source) productization of production processes for consumption by progressively-less-technical individuals over time. This drastically reduces the amount infrastructure (and corresponding capital) required to bring innovative new products to market, unseating incumbents and breeding healthy competition.
- QuantumGood 7y agoThe "skunk works" approach to difficult problems has been well proven, often as a "small is beautiful" approach within a bigger company. Beyond a certain size, it's hard for the effort of a single individual to have the kind of large effect that is a key driver of motivation—it's hard for enough of the individuals to each feel they have a large effect on process and outcomes.