5 ms·
Man, this is gold. I for long tried to write something along those lines, but I think the author did summarise my thoughts better than I could've done myself.
by baybal2 7y ago
Man, this is gold.
I for long tried to write something along those lines, but I think the author did summarise my thoughts better than I could've done myself.
The class conflict — something that western literati class keep denying acknowledgement, is really the driver of much of social progress. And this holds more even more true in the West than in the East.
The class warfare is there, it exists, and it is what has been responsible for the prime majority of political developments in the West for the last 30 years.
- petermcneeley 7y ago30 years eh. I think one might argue that "The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles."
- dluan 7y agoShhh we're busy reinventing Marx as a new idea for the pundit brained technocrats. We need people like Elon and Andrew Yang to tweet it to us before it can be considered cool again.
- jdc 7y agoeh.. not _all_ analysis of class conflict is Marxist
- contingencies 7y agoHow about generating a synthetic group of such personalities using ML with retweet and emotional conflict generation as feedback parameters? Then letting them loose on the public? Wait, that's already happening...
- jml7c5 7y ago>The class conflict [...] is really the driver of much of social progress. How so?
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI'm thinking: because it gives people a strong, active, positive goal to pursue. Members of each class want to migrate to the higher one, or at the very least, have their children break into the higher one. If you're discriminated or treated unfairly by a group of people, the natural reaction would be to separate yourself from that group of people, not fight it. But if for some reason you really want to join that group - perhaps because they're of higher socioeconomical class - then you have a motivation to fight and reform things.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoExcept that the article says that the working class in the US - and the UK - don't want to migrate. They just want to complain and break everything. They don't want to improve anything for anyone in a strategic sense. They want textbook authoritarianism with a daddy figure lying that he loves them, and telling them who to hate so they can feel better. It's an utter infantilisation, and the right are happy to sponsor it and farm it for their convenience. But attacking the left for pointing out that it's not really a solution seems to be part of the rhetorical package it's wrapped in. The right are always happy to demonise the left for the working classes, because duh - of course they are. The problem on the left - and I wouldn't consider most of the US Democratic Party as the left, incidentally - isn't so much "be like us" as a failure to understand just how murderous, dishonest, and literally criminal the elites on the other side are, and how limitlessly violent, self-serving and treacherous they can be in pursuit of their aims. This wasn't a problem for the old turn-of-the-19th-century left, which had direct experience of being beaten up and shot at. But by the time you've been through college and acquired a fairly comfortable job it's hard to remember what your comfort is built on. These facets of political history are conveniently erased from official nation-building stories of "progress" in the UK and the US, and people have to make a real effort to find out about them - which hardly anyone does now.
- shadowprofile77 7y agoOh of course. We can summarize the conflicts, complaints and angry points of the working class as nothing more than an urge to "complain and break things". I'm sorry but that's a load of dismissive nonsense. So is the notion that only the "far right" seeks to build text-book authoritarianism with a daddy figure who tells the working class how to feel and who to hate. Either you've completely failed to pay attention to modern history or are deliberately ignoring a huge part of it but the left is just as guilty of the right of that very thing. They just (and even this only lightly) couch their authoritarianism and drive to spread hatred in different terms. In some countries (such as where I live), the left is just as nationalistic as any rightist. To also claim that the elites with murderous, dishonest and literally criminal intentions are mostly unique to the self described right of politics is absurd.
- roenxi 7y agoOne of the things the article hits quite well that is otherwise hard to put a finger on - the effective media personalities, etc, etc, are basically all either from or in the process of migrating into the upper class quite quickly by virtue of making lots of money. So any class struggles, much as I dislike the term, are very effectively silenced by the media because none of the talking heads have an interest in putting it up in lights. It adds an interesting perspective to Trump and the incoming Twitter/Facebook/Youtube revolution that seems to be hitting the political sphere. It is harder to drown out lower class opinions because the broadcasting channels have become so accessible.
- hef19898 7y agoYep, I think the biggest difference between last centuries 20s and now is that the nationalistic notion is today more of a sugar coating. Today it seems to be more about the rich against the poor, regardless of country, region or continent. A divide that can, and currently is, easily abused by certain parties and groups. Add uncertainty about the future, climate change prime among a lot of different reasons, and societies are much more volatile than they should be. The general egoism doesn't help neither.