3 ms·
My line of work requires a lot of time presenting. We typically tag team our presentations so experts are presenting their own slides. It definitely adds to the
by tootie 7y ago
My line of work requires a lot of time presenting. We typically tag team our presentations so experts are presenting their own slides. It definitely adds to the authenticity. Typically I'll write up slides relevant to the audience, but it's usually on topics that I already know inside and out and don't need to follow a script and can easily respond to questions and tangents. Then pass to another expert who can talk about their stuff with equal vigor. Speaking about something that's actually interesting is also hugely important.
I think the exact inverse example is probably Donald Trump. He has little relevant expertise to his job and hasn't really bothered to learn much along the way. Instead, he speaks at length without a script and without breaking tempo unburdened by facts, experience or even coherence. Just a lot of confidence and a lot of emotion. And it evidently works really well for a lot of people.
- dkersten 7y agoI personally don't really like tag-team presentations. I'm sure it can be done really well, but in almost all talks I've ever watched (GDC, strangeloop, various language conferences) the switch between speakers always came across as distracting, hectic or jarring. Yes, I imagine they were rarely (or ever) as well practiced as you sound and I imagine that makes a huge difference and it sounds like you're doing it for the right reasons (so that the person talking is always talking about something they know about, certainly helps talks sound less artificial, as you say), my main point is that I don't think its good advice to tell people who aren't as well practiced because I find it often makes otherwise decent presentations not so great. Everything else you say sounds great, though :)
- joshuaheard 7y agoScott Adams (Dilbert creator) has written several books on persuasion and persuasive techniques. He analyzes Trump's communication style very positively.
- dragonwriter 7y agoScott Adams isn't an expert on either persuasion generally or the domain in which Trump operates (writing a book doesn't make you an expert; ideally, being an expert would be related to having a book taken seriously, but being a celebrity can do that without any expertise.) Trump did a decent enough job at leveraging decades of Republican propaganda designed to create permanent unmet needs and resentments to support politicians permanently promising incremental steps in the direction of those needs, and cutting the legal out of the people making that offer by not nakedly offering the whole hog rather than incremental steps. But that's not a triumph of persuasion: the persuasion was done by decades of work by professional political propagandists; Trump was just meeting the already-radicalized Republican base where they'd been set up to be exploited.
- lifeisstillgood 7y agocould you expand a bit? what are the unmet permanent needs
- arrrg 7y agoI mean, it obviously works. That doesn’t tell you anything about its ethical or moral content, though.
- TwoBit 7y agoDoes he recommend lying so much? I'm not sure how to categorize Trump's lying. He just says whatever he wants, completely made up.
- nordsieck 7y ago> I'm not sure how to categorize Trump's lying. He just says whatever he wants, completely made up. My charitable view of Trump's lying is this: He is one of the first high level public officials to take Scalia's opinion in Republican Party of Minnesota v White seriously > Campaign promises are, by long democratic tradition, the least binding form of human commitment. His speech is in essence poetry rather than prose; he focuses almost exclusively on evocative imagery and emotional impact and disregards facts as largely irrelevant to his audience. To my dismay, this is much more effective than I would like it to be.