4 ms·
> US and Five Eyes countries following US are banning Huawei for strategic reasons, not for technical reasons. Telecom infrastructure is strategic industry and
by kube-system 7y ago
> US and Five Eyes countries following US are banning Huawei for strategic reasons, not for technical reasons. Telecom infrastructure is strategic industry and US want's to prevent Chinese getting ahead.
Despite the current president's personal crusades, this is not about US protectionism. Companies in the US wouldn't benefit from a ban on Huawei equipment anyway, it would be Finland and Sweden who do.
Supply chain trust has always been a primary concern of any kind of critical resource/infrastructure defensive strategy. Every time a country relies on another for a critical ongoing need, it introduces an inherent power imbalance that the supplying country can use as a leverage. This kind of stuff is centuries-old geopolitical strategy, and it's still in the news every day when we're talking about energy, food, minerals, etc. (e.g. Russian pipelines) Why is communications infrastructure any different? It's not.
- anticensor 7y agoDo you mean NOKIA and Ericsson?
- freyir 7y agoYes, those are the only cellular infrastructure companies besides Huawei. There was Alcatel-Lucent, but Nokia bought them a while back.
- abainbridge 7y agoThere's an emerging trend of service providers trying to virtualize their core network. Rakuten in Japan is a leading example. "They have assembled a small army of suppliers to build a virtualized network built on x86 hardware. ... Rakuten has no dedicated hardware except in its antennas, ensuring the upgrade to 5G will be straightforward. ... Chief Architecture Officer Tareq Amin said the network has "virtualized everything," including radio access, core, transport, IP, billing and operational support systems." I'm not sure who this army of suppliers is though.
- sangnoir 7y ago> Despite the current president's personal crusades, this is not about US protectionism. Companies in the US wouldn't benefit from a ban on Huawei equipment anyway Why are you limiting US strategic interests to protectionism of private companies? It is in the American Interest (both private and public spheres) if "Made in China 2025" were to fail: Huawei is a just one front in that war. In this light, minimizing Huawei's market access with (even in the absence of domestic competitors) makes strategic sense: less experience in the market, less revenue, less R&D). Technological expertise tends to bleed into military applications
- empath75 7y agoAll the “American” products are made in China, too, so I don’t see what the difference is.
- kube-system 7y agoThe supply chain for one of these products consists of more than hardware manufacturing. You’ve got software, support, maintenance, governance, etc. The hardware is the easier part to account for, it’s both physical and a constant.
- freyir 7y agoOP said it’s strategic, not that it’s protectionist for US companies (in fact, they pointed out that no US companies are competing in the next sentence that you didn’t quote). I think you’re both saying essentially the same thing.