3 ms·
Would the Bard Have Survived the Web?
- tokenadult 16y ago"Copyright, now powerfully linking authors, the printing press (and later technologies) and the market, would prove to be one of history’s great public policy successes. Books would attract investment of authors’ labor and publishers’ capital on a colossal scale, and our libraries and bookstores would fill with works that educated and entertained a thriving nation. . . . "Yet today, these markets are unraveling. Piracy is a lucrative, innovative, global enterprise. Clusters of overseas servers can undermine much of the commercial basis for creative work around the world, offering users the speedy, secret transmission of stolen goods."
- kiba 16y agoHow is it "unraveling"?
- tokenadult 16y agoIf I correctly understand the submitted article, the claim is that most writings that have been written in earlier decades in the expectation that the author would make money from copyright royalties are now readily available in pirated versions that can be downloaded around the world without any payment to the author. So the paying market is unraveling, because the main distribution of new content now is pirate distribution. Do you read what the submitted article says differently?
- kiba 16y agoWhere is the evidence that piracy cause the paying market to unravel?
- Tycho 16y agoCD/music sales have been declining for a decade. The latest Call of Duty game will shift more units in a single day than the top selling album will sell annually. Book sales, overall, I'm not sure, but I don't think they've been in major decline. Yet. The worry is that Kindles and iPads will do for novels what the iPod did for songs: drastically change the preferred method of consumption to something more vulnerable to piracy. The article is predicting a future trend.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- wccrawford 16y agoIsn't the argument usually the opposite? That due to the copyright laws today, Shakespeare couldn't have even written his stories? The sword cuts both ways. He can't base his works on other peoples' works, or he can't put a lock an key on his own. Also, his plays weren't meant to be read, they were meant to be seen being performed. Unsurprisingly, that's how the popular music artists of today make the most money as well. It's not even piracy that causes that, either.
- anamax 16y ago> That due to the copyright laws today, Shakespeare couldn't have even written his stories? > He can't base his works on other peoples' works, or he can't put a lock an key on his own. Did Shakespeare reuse many non-public characters? I ask because that's where copyright is an impediment to story writing. That is, Disney can go after me for doing a story with Woody the Cowboy, but not Carl the Cowboy, even if Carl is secretly alive. However, I heard that Pixar patented putting eyes on the windshield for vehicles that are alive.
- tokenadult 16y agoI heard that Pixar patented putting eyes on the windshield for vehicles that are alive. Where did you hear that? I don't think "patent" is the likely legal concept if such a thing was done.
- elwin 16y ago> Did Shakespeare reuse many non-public characters? I ask because that's where copyright is an impediment to story writing. Shakespeare reused large portions of the plotlines from contemporary plays. Hamlet and As You Like It are two I can think of. But I think he changed most of the names.
- Tycho 16y agoI'm sure Shakespeare could have found a way to write his plays if the source material he used had been unavailable/protected. I think the point is that Shakespeare had an effective pay wall which guaranteed he'd be rewarded for his work (there was still piracy, human recorders in the audience, but it was manageable). Later copyright protected markets created 'virtual paywalls' and much more creativity ensued. The web has greatly reduced the effectiveness of all these paywalls, thus someone like Shakespeare might not even bother to create in the first place. Also, having exclusive performance rights is very important too. Otherwise the only hope of commission is for the chance to debut/premier a work (after which, it's anyone's game).
- hessenwolf 16y agoI struggled to take it seriously at all after the following sentence. "They are abetted by a handful of law professors and other experts who have made careers of fashioning counterintuitive arguments holding that copyright impedes creativity and progress."
- kiba 16y agoThis opinion article is poorly written. It's a bunch of assertion with no empirical evidence to back it up. So the market for books and inventions is unraveling, how? Who are these law professors and experts that says these things? What are their arguments? Ignoring evidence? Put the data into numbers we can understand. Is there any case study of a country with no IP laws? What does history tell us?
- Boosh 16y agoHow can you not all see the main point of the article? Namely, human beings act/create/innovate when they are properly incentivized, i.e. financial compensation. It's the same argument with socializing our health care system. There is a reason the U.S. has the most advanced health care system and best trained medical community in the world. Take away those incentives (socialize the health care system) for the medical community and you can bet the U.S. will not be as innovative. Say what you will but people are motivated by financial incentives. "Money changed everything. Almost overnight, a wave of brilliant dramatists emerged, including Christopher Marlowe, Thomas Kyd, Ben Jonson and Shakespeare. These talents and many comparable and lesser lights had found the opportunity, the conditions and the money to pursue their craft. The stark findings of this experiment? As with much else, literary talent often remains undeveloped unless markets reward it."