4 ms·
I imagine the UK weighs Huawei equipment with potential Chinese introduced backdoors vs Cisco equipment with potential US introduced backdoors. Probably cases e
by tyingq 7y ago
I imagine the UK weighs Huawei equipment with potential Chinese introduced backdoors vs Cisco equipment with potential US introduced backdoors. Probably cases exist where Huawei is the safer choice. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/photos-of-an-nsa-upgrade-factory-show-cisco-router-getting-implant/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/photos-of-an-nsa...
Feels like there's a niche market for a UK, French, German, Australian, etc, line of equipment.
- aldoushuxley001 7y agoBut the UK is part of the 5 eyes, it makes more sense to use US backdoors than Chinese backdoors, despite both being undesirable to say the least.
- tyingq 7y agoThat's weird and funny to me. Doesn't the UK have its own foreign policy that's distinctly different from the US view? Isn't there room for some selective divergence? Consider, for example, Ukraine, Syria, or Iraq. I wouldn't trust US sanctioned intelligence at all in those areas. Chinese influenced info might (sometimes/often) be more neutral.
- ethanbond 7y agoThis is only true if you naively believe that being compromised by the US carries even remotely similar risk to being compromised by the CCP. One key difference: China is an adversary to the US and UK. The US is not an adversary to the UK. This strategic relativism is tired and indefensible in any version of reality.
- tyingq 7y ago"The US is not an adversary to the ...UK." Not generally, but there are cases where they are. Ask Assange, for example. Surely the UK has information they would rather not share with the US in some cases.
- ethanbond 7y agoNot tactically aligned 100% of the time != an adversary. To act otherwise - or to act like China ought to enjoy a similar relationship - is downright dangerous in the face of escalating geopolitical tensions.
- tyingq 7y agoThat just sounds very black and white to me. Why would the UK blindly follow the US in all cases? Surely there's room for their own interests.
- ethanbond 7y agoI don’t believe I proposed that the UK “blindly follow” the US, nor did I even say it’s a-okay that the US might engage in espionage against allies. I said that the US-UK relationship is absolutely nothing like the UK-CCP relationship, and therefore US efforts to project power are in no way comparable to Chinese efforts (as far as the UK is concerned). However, if you really want an answer, there are two reasons that the UK ought to align itself with the US (and vice versa). Those two reasons are Russia and China. We are fortunate to be living in an era of widespread peace, but that is not guaranteed indefinitely. Should, god forbid, widespread warfare break out once again (as it has since tribal days up until the last 80 years or so), any westerner with a modicum of understanding of Putin’s or Xi’s ideal world ought to be on the side of the US/UK.
- tyingq 7y agoSure, you didn't explicitly say either. Apologies for that. But from my point of view, you implied it. I recognize it's a fuzzy area. But using 100% US gear does imply some acceptance of blindness. We (US govt) are pretty up front about our manipulation.
- ethanbond 7y agoNo apologies necessary, just trying to clarify - that was an unintentional implication. I do not even want the UK to use 100% US gear, never mind think they strategically should use 100% US gear. My argument is only that becoming reliant (whether defined as a critical 1% of the network or the entire 100% of the network) upon the US is not analogous to the same level of reliance upon the CCP - at least from the perspective of the UK.
- w7 7y agoAs far as I'm aware most of the US installed backdoors were via interception of the hardware en-route to its point of installation without the vendor's knowledge. Hardware being a direct product from Huawei doesn't by itself prevent this from happening.
- kalleboo 7y agoCisco doesn’t make mobile network equipment. Motorola also got out of the business. The alternatives to Huawei are Ericsson (Sweden), Nokia (Finland) and Samsung (South Korea)