3 ms·
There's a difference between a one-off command-line utility, and implementing elderly unfriendly software. Example: My grandmother has a smartphone for keepin
by salawat 7y ago
There's a difference between a one-off command-line utility, and implementing elderly unfriendly software.
Example:
My grandmother has a smartphone for keeping in contact with the rest of the family. I recently got to embark on the adventure of trying to navigate the morass of software installed by other family in order to get the bloody thing to stop stressing her out.
The root cause, of course, was that other family members and friends had various games installed that they played to pass the time which would blast out request to other contacts on their phones or through push notifications.
So poor Gram, who still starts SMS texts with "Dear X" is getting stressed out because she is constantly being pinged by these requests to play this trivia game and nothing else, and Gram is, of course, not the type to want to raise a fuss over it, yet is clearly disturbed by it. Mom, and other folks who have Gram as a contact/friend on Facebook who partake of this game are either blissfully unaware of this aspect of the game, unable to figure out how to disable it (if indeed, one is lucky enough that the game actually supports it), or can't be bothered to after being notified of it.
So. Okay. Deep dive required. So in I go. That deep dive was one of the most infuriating computing experiences I have ever endured in someone's stead.
A)inevitable (App÷) app clones with subtly different interfaces/menu structures, inconsistent names of feature controls.
B) There was a lack of either accessible, accurate, or useful documentation.
C) Integration with other Apps were clunky/painful at best
D) In order to block all spam from this one app and to maintain message reception from the contact in general generally meant tweaking settings on the Contact, the App receiving notifications, and bloody Facebook.
E) not even going to go into the fact that it would most likely change somewhat between handsets/networks.
Now, I generally try not to be too judgemental of the users I shepherd, or what goes on their phone/device. I will generally bend over backwards to accomodate and facilitate a smooth workflow and experience for everyone involved.
After having sat down though and gone through that experience, however, I've opened my eyes to the struggles that these abominations of attention monopolization, and lord knows what else are exacting on us.
You can try to handwave it as failure to adapt to technology by a 90 year old, but do consider, I'd gotten Gram fluent in terms of finding her way through her desktop for most of her typical workflow before. Before the last 5 or so years, most interfaces were similar enough experience was somewhat portable between tools due to generally consistent UI conventions. Coordination of messaging is generally not a hassle for her and she does it for her community simply because she knows how and has a system, and doesn't have much else to do. What is a problem for her though, is having to try to create a new mental model that could accomodate the fact that some ingrate who she had never met implemented a bloody trivia game, that doubled as a DDoS on her through the unwitting accomplicery of her bored contacts/family who didn't know better; and every one of us just accept that as normal.
Hey, those offensive dark patterns (social integration of a game to drive engagement) gets better metrics! Who cares is some old bitty can't get with the program?
Good software empowers, informs, and guides the user in it's use.
Good software should not inflict undue suffering on the User, or other's due to the ignorance; especially not when said harm is only justified through additional convenience afforded the developer
These aren't hard concepts to grasp. Yet more and more particularly in Mobile software, but also in web apps, we throw these concepts right out the window.
It is repugnant, overwhelming, infuriating, and distressing to even me that of all the outcomes ubiquitous adoption of computing would facilitate, the landscape would be so drastically tilted against anyone but an informed developer.
Write your command-line app and distribute it to the user who's joy it is intended to evince. Document, and ensure it's flow can help them become better with it over time. No one cam judge you for that. However, when lines start getting crossed is where the entirety of a technological experience for a significant population of users actively degradez their quality of life through no fault of their own, and where that suffering can be directly traced to industry (mis)behavior that benefits the developer over the end user.
Anyway, apologies if I got ranty. It's a bit late, and your post triggered the memory of that that I really wish I could forget.
It's hard to watch someone you love suffer in silence to something like that, and to also understand all the different factors that added up to it, and yet to be relatively powerless in the grand-scheme of things because you can only be so many places at once. Even though a shell can cross a continent, it's amazing how much you miss when you can't physically share the same experience on a regular basis.
- sandoooo 7y ago>There's a difference between a one-off command-line utility, and implementing elderly unfriendly software. Say I released my console utility publicly. Say I make money off of it, one way or another. Am I obliged to make it work for your 90 year old grandma now? Sure, your grandma probably won't need this particular thing I made, but others might - you never know. But, on the other hand, I'm fairly sure that the significantly larger effort I have to put in would not result in significantly more income for me - this is not a profitable thing to do. In the end, like almost all other arguments about The Right Thing To Do, this is an argument about resource (re)distribution: am I obliged in some way to distribute my limited time and attention towards the hypothetical 90-year-old grandma? Even if it results in my making less money (or, indeed, turn my profitable side-project into a loss-making one)? Under what circumstances should I be obliged to do this, over and above my economic incentive to serve more profitable - less demanding - customers?
- perl4ever 7y ago"In the end, like almost all other arguments about The Right Thing To Do, this is an argument about resource (re)distribution" Like many things there are two separate issues: 1) If everyone did it, there would be a cost to society in that fewer products would be made, given the higher overhead, skills, etc. required. 2) If you (some particular person) did it, it would make you uncompetitive. People suggest regulation because it fixes (2) without requiring any individual to unilaterally decide to sacrifice for the common good. Issue (1) is a finite cost that may or may not be considered worthwhile. It's really weird for people to continually take the position that they can't do anything altruistic and be against society forcing everybody to. Shouldn't it be one or the other?
- sandoooo 7y agoI see a parallel between this and the pushback against Electron, and the counter-argument is the same: more choices in software in general is a good thing, and lowering the cost of entry by dropping requirements in accessibility or performance (Electron) gets society more choices in software. The hypothetical csv-cruncher behaves a lot like a compiler - imagine if we had to make every one of those compatible with screenreaders and 20-year-old hardware running obsolete OSes. Imagine how much shittier everything would be with this additional burden to carry, then multiply it by every component in a typical software stack. This is the cost. It is finite, because everything is finite, but that doesn't stop it from being very large. So to sum up: regulating this is detrimental to society.