3 ms·
The perceptability of the 128 steps depends on the parameters it influences. If the midi parameter influences e.g. some form of pitch, 128 values won't get you
by atoav 7y ago
The perceptability of the 128 steps depends on the parameters it influences. If the midi parameter influences e.g. some form of pitch, 128 values won't get you very far without having the steps perceived.
It also has to do with the pressure range of midi controllers: 128 steps are few if you have to distribute them between "barely touching" and "hammering on it with full force". When you play a real instrument, you will notice that the range of things between the most silent and most loud you can manage is usually huge. For midi controllers this is kinda limited, so good developement.
- kazinator 7y agoIf you want high resolution pitch, then you basically disagree with the whole concept of MIDI. The concept of MIDI is that notes are symbols. MIDI tells an instrument to play A4, not to play note witha 440 Hz fundamental. MIDI doesn't care how that instrument i tuned. A4 could come out as 430 Hz. That said, MIDI supports microtonal effects like pitch bending. Pitch bend messages use 14 bits.
- rzzzt 7y agoYou can distribute the values non-linearly, though; the difference between smallest and largest value might be big, but I don't think I could hit a pad or key in 128 different ways. Some controller software does offer a selection of velocity profiles.
- oriolid 7y agoIt depends on the instrument. 128 positions is well enough for piano. From other instruments, drums is the one I know best, and there single parameter is just not enough: the result depends on velocity, the position where the stick hits drum head, for non round tip sticks the stick angle. For cymbals, in addition to hitting different parts of the cymbal, stick tip, shaft and shoulder give different sounds. And so on... There's a good reason why loops sampled from acoustic drums are used even though drum synths exist.
- PaulDavisThe1st 7y agoYou do not need MIDI 2.0 to solve any of those problems.
- oriolid 7y agoNo, and I don't expect MIDI 2.0 to help. It was just response to the idea that single parameter would be enough but 7 bits wouldn't.