14 ms·
This is patently untrue. A lobbyist is just anybody who meets with an elected official on behalf of a group. There are perfectly legitimate lobbyists, and many
by legitster 7y ago
This is patently untrue. A lobbyist is just anybody who meets with an elected official on behalf of a group. There are perfectly legitimate lobbyists, and many depending on the group they may even be volunteers.
It just so happens that the lobbyists that get the most attention are those that represent the most powerful groups. But equating it with bribery is completely misleading.
- cryptica 7y ago>> There are perfectly legitimate lobbyists This is BS. Lobbyists serve the companies they work for and nobody else. There have been many cases of lobbyists getting fired for not sticking to the corporate agenda even on small matters. It's institutionalized corruption. The hypothetical 'legitimate lobbyists' are 'low performers' and they don't stick around very long. Either they will be underpaid and quit or they'll be fired outright.
- blago 7y ago> Lobbyists serve the companies they work for and nobody else. So do lawyers. Defendants pay them to meet with prosecutors and judges. This is not evidence of corruption. It's a process.
- ekianjo 7y ago> Foreign-funded lobbying efforts include those of Israel, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Egypt, Pakistan, and China lobbies. In 2010 alone, foreign governments spent approximately $460 million on lobbying members of Congress and government officials. From Wikipedia. So spending 460M USD on public officials. Was it simply to have 1:1 conversations with politicians?
- akho 7y agoThat figure seems a bit low. So you have 535 members of Congress. Other govt officials (State, trade and aid agencies, ...) foreign powers have a legitimate interest in meeting probably brings that figure to a 1000. Congresspeople have aides, staff, &c — who also need to be dined. To maintain the whole show, you need to have your own staff — well-educated, worldly people — who need to be paid, need offices to work in, .... I don’t think anyone buys yachts from this.
- manquer 7y agoForeign governments have embassies and diplomatic staff for precisely this kind of work . Why do they need more than that ?
- akho 7y agoDiplomatic staff is very limited in number (because they have immunity, so the host country does not want it inflated too much). These kinds of jobs do not require immunity and can be done by non-diplomats.
- manquer 7y agoNot all diplomatic staff carry diplomatic visas. Every other country in the world where lobbying is not legal, all of this is done with government staff, this usecase cannot be a justification for having lobbying when everyone else gets along fine without it when a foreign government employs a third party firm it looks like it wants plausible deniability , or that they are trying purchase access and influence that these firms have as Kushner was selling .
- onetimemanytime 7y agoCongressmen didn't get $460M in brown bags or bank accounts, interest groups spent that much on lobbyists to meet them. No doubt campaign contributions, one way or another, followed but direct gifts are a no-no.