3 ms·
I am for non-violence and against the militarization of space, but I'm at a loss as to how to convince others of this. Most non-violent movements are religious
by pmoriarty 7y ago
I am for non-violence and against the militarization of space, but I'm at a loss as to how to convince others of this.
Most non-violent movements are religious at their core, and if people don't already believe in non-violence and don't believe in a religion which tells them not to be violent, they are not likely to be convinced to change their ways and adopt non-violence.
It's possible, though currently unlikley, that leaders of religions who interpret their scriptures as calling for non-violence as a core value become more influential in society. Unfortunately, the world seems to be heading in the opposite direction right now, and as we saw with the assassinations of Gandhi and Martin Luther King, such leaders are vulnerable to being eliminated by people who have no problems with violence.
To ultimately be successful there has to be a grassroots, widespread, decentralized change in consciousness among the masses, and we are very far from that.
The one distant ray of hope that I see is more widespread use of psychedelics, which have the potential to increase empathy and a feeling of connection to and unity with the world and others. This is a pretty long-term hope, however, and it still has the potential to be squashed if there's another backlash from the powers that be.
- meowface 7y agoI'm also for non-violence and am against militarization, but, sadly, violence and military conflict are inevitably not going to go away starting from 2020 onward. [Insert rant about coordination problems / game theory / tragedy of the commons / Moloch] means the US needs to be there to counter other nations that are going to try to militarize it. In an ideal world, such a military force would only act defensively, not offensively or imperially (e.g. colonizing planets, moons, and rocks purely in the name of the United States), but I guess that's not too likely in the long-term. When cyberwarfare started to become a real possibility and not just sci-fi, would you have argued that the US creating cyberwarfare divisions is wrong and shouldn't be done, even as just about every other major country was doing the same? If you were president of the US right now, what would you do if you vetoed a space force and then a few months later, Russia and China simultaneously announced the creation of their own space forces? Given the current state of the world, I believe adding additional military capabilities is just necessary, even though I'm also an idealist who detests violence, war, and death of all kinds, targeted at any being. If we lived in the year 2520 and all militaries have been disbanded for centuries and every country has been living in peace with one another for the same length of time, then, yes, I'd agree that breaking that precedent with the creation of a space force would be wrong. But unfortunately, we're not there yet, and it's possible we may not be even in 1,000 or 10,000 or 100,000 years from now. (Yes, I know there's a chicken-and-egg logic there, but I can only refer back to the implied coordination problem rant.)
- pmoriarty 7y agoThere are actions we can take that lead to escalation or deescalation. The US used to lead, at least in some ways, towards a more peaceful world. Together with the Soviet Union, the US got rid of thousands of nuclear weapons. Now we are headed back in the other direction. The US still leads, but it's leading towards more conflict. Over and over again you see countries following the US as it, for example, starts to justify assassinations, wars, and torture in the name of fighting terrorism. The US unilaterally withdraws from nuclear non-proliferation agreements and nuclear proliferation heats up. As you yourself point out, the US starts militarizing space and other nations follow suit. Just today it was announced that the US is reversing course on a ban against use of land mines. A major nuclear conflict is likely to result in hundreds of millions if not billions of deaths. We have to pull back from the brink rather than always edging closer and closer to it, and this won't be achieved through more militarization.. especially not in a more multi-polar world where the US is daily losing more and more of its technological edge. Achieving a non-violent world isn't going to happen overnight, and it likely won't happen without setbacks, but the US could take the lead and steer towards peace instead of towards war.
- meowface 7y ago>As you yourself point out, the US starts militarizing space and other nations follow suit. Yes, but you can substitute "US" for almost any other country. Russia starts militarizing space: US and Britain follow suit. Someone is inevitably going to be the first one to do it. The land mines, I agree with. The nuclear situation is a little more complicated, since some believe nuclear MAD has actually (so far...) saved far more lives in total than if it weren't there, but I agree cutting back is probably a good idea. I think these things are different from having a military presence in space. I think it's like creating an air or cyber force. It's a vacuum that's inevitably going to be filled with a host of entities, so you might as well be first.
- pmoriarty 7y ago"you can substitute "US" for almost any other country. Russia starts militarizing space: US and Britain follow suit. Someone is inevitably going to be the first one to do it." This argument would be more convincing if Russia was the first to escalate, but they weren't. Yet again the US took the lead. Even if Russia had been the first to escalate, the US could respond in all sorts of non-military ways before resorting to a military solution. This also ties back in to many other aggressive actions the US has taken, arguably since WW2. If it didn't keep squandering its political and moral capital, it would be much more persuasive to the world at large in leading the way to peace. Instead, its self-serving aggression is resulting in ever more polarization, paranoia, and enemy-making. It would be bad enough if the US was simply digging its own grave, but it seems to be intent on digging a grave for everyone. This is truly madness, and I don't see it ending in anything but a global fireball, especially if everyone keeps insisting on throwing more gasoline on the fire.
- consumer451 7y ago> That's why I think to be ultimately successful there has to be a grassroots, widespread, decentralized change in consciousness among the masses, and we are very far from that. As the world stands it is mostly run by people with the most resources, aka money and/or power. I think this has always been the case throughout history and I don't think we have time to entirely change that right now.[a] Also, in this case maybe this is a good thing. Rich people have the majority of the power and influence, and they are the ones that will be the first to experience the Overview Effect[0] as orbital space tourists. > The overview effect is a cognitive shift in awareness reported by some astronauts during spaceflight, often while viewing the Earth from outer space. > It is the experience of seeing firsthand the reality of the Earth in space, which is immediately understood to be a tiny, fragile ball of life, "hanging in the void", shielded and nourished by a paper-thin atmosphere. From space, national boundaries vanish, the conflicts that divide people become less important, and the need to create a planetary society with the united will to protect this "pale blue dot" becomes both obvious and imperative. This is exactly what we need. At least it is a glimmer of hope and a great self-selected alignment of people who need a cognitive shift, and those who can afford it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overview_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overview_effect edit: [a] To be clear, I do not mean to discount the population and the power of grassroots movements at all, it is also necessary for the non-violent utopia which is required to avoid a "Great Filter"[1] event. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter
- pmoriarty 7y agoDid the overview effect turn any astronauts in to pacifists?
- consumer451 7y ago> Did the overview effect turn any astronauts in to pacifists? Well, I can't speak to that specifically. I am not aware of any astronauts who declared themselves as pacifists. However, it sure seems like a catalyst towards unity and pacifism when reading the quotes. The fact that so many of the experiences are attributed to ex-military astronauts is also significant to me. I would expect independent civilians to be even more open-minded and verbose about their overview experiences. Some interesting quotes on the subject: > Edgar Mitchell, Apollo 14 astronaut: “You develop an instant global consciousness, a people orientation, an intense dissatisfaction with the state of the world, and a compulsion to do something about it. From out there on the moon, international politics look so petty. You want to grab a politician by the scruff of the neck and drag him a quarter of a million miles out and say, ‘Look at that, you son of a bitch.’” [0] > Neil Armstrong, astronaut & moonwalker: “It suddenly struck me that that tiny pea, pretty and blue, was the Earth. I put up my thumb and shut one eye, and my thumb blotted out the planet Earth. I didn’t feel like a giant. I felt very, very small.” [0] > Edward Gibson, astronaut & Skylab 4 pilot: “You see how diminutive your life and concerns are compared to other things In the universe … The result is that you enjoy the life that is before you … It allows you to have inner peace.” [0] > Anousheh Ansari, space tourist: “The actual experience exceeds all expectations and is something that’s hard to put to words … It sort of reduces things to a size that you think everything is manageable … All these things that may seem big and impossible … We can do this. Peace on Earth — No problem. It gives people that type of energy … that type of power, and I have experienced that.” [0] > Shuttle/ISS astronaut Ron Garan: “When we look down at the earth from space, we see this amazing, indescribably beautiful planet. It looks like a living, breathing organism. But it also, at the same time, looks extremely fragile … Anybody else who’s ever gone to space says the same thing because it really is striking and it’s really sobering to see this paper-thin layer and to realize that that little paper-thin layer is all that protects every living thing on Earth from death, basically. From the harshness of space.” [0] > “From space I saw Earth—indescribably beautiful with the scars of national boundaries gone.” ~Muhammad Ahmad Faris, Syrian Astronaut (cited in Hassard & Weisberg, 1999, p. 1) [1] > “If somebody’d said before the flight, 'Are you going to get carried away looking at the earth from the moon?' I would have say [sic], ‘No, no way.’ But yet when I first looked back at the Earth, standing on the moon, I cried.” ~Alan Shepard, NASA Astronaut (cited in Nardo, 2014, p. 46) [1] [0] https://www.phactual.com/14-awe-filled-quotes-about-the-overview-effect-from-outer-space/ https://www.phactual.com/14-awe-filled-quotes-about-the-over... [1] https://www.psychologyinaction.org/psychology-in-action-1/2017/01/01/the-overview-effect https://www.psychologyinaction.org/psychology-in-action-1/20...