3 ms·
The standard can be changed, it's just that manufacturers have to agree between themselves on the new standard. No involvement from the government is required.
by ClumsyPilot 7y ago
The standard can be changed, it's just that manufacturers have to agree between themselves on the new standard. No involvement from the government is required.
They can make USB 4, 5,6, connector C, D,E,Z, whatever. That's fine. What's not cool, is creating proprietary connector and not letting anyone else use it.
Mind you they only have to agree on charging, not data transfer.
As to whether it's worth it: hard to tell, there comes a time in a technology's maturity where compliance with a common standard is more important than incremental innovation. The power sockets in your house are dtandard, and your power company and electrician are not allowed to innovate, because at some point we decided compatability was more important.
- filoleg 7y ago>The standard can be changed, it's just that manufacturers have to agree between themselves on the new standard. If an agreement of all manufacturers is needed before introducing a new standard in production, it means that it will be delayed by the lowest common denominator of manufacturers until many years later. Which isn't good for the consumer, because they could've gotten a new superior charging standard on their phones many years earlier, as opposed to waiting multiple years until all manufacturers adopt it.
- nwallin 7y agoThe agreement doesn't need to be unanimous. And it's fine for the agreement to be "just use whatever the latest small form factor USB collector is" which has been the de facto Android standard since the beginning. It sounds like you're arguing that the lowest common denominator phone manufacturer will be holding up progress. But the connector is the easiest part, especially if it's a truly ubiquitous standard, because it will be heavily commoditized. The lowest common denominator phone manufacturer will just buy whatever the cheapest connector from China is, and this will almost always be whatever connector is most common.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoMy argument is that charging is at this point a mature technology, we have a charging standard up to 100w. Do you expect future phones to draw more? What possible improvements could future charging standard have, as far as a mobile phone goes? And yes, it is pretty normal to have manufacturers sit round a table and agree standards -most ports on a computer, 4g wireless, etc. You cant even come up with your own phone communication standard - countries allocate frequency specifically for 4g or 5g, none will give you a frequency band for a proprietary communication standard.
- oxfordmale 7y agoApple can still implement proprietary technology in an USB-C charging cable that allows their phones to be charged much faster than others, as long as their device can still be charged by a generic cable and vice versa (without the added benefits).
- scarface74 7y agoWow so now every time that Apple gets ready to introduce a new connector they have to wait for the entire industry to agree to it? But guess what? Only the end connecting to the wall is standard, the end connecting to devices in the house are far from standard. How is this different than iPhones?
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoI am not sure I understand your argument "my toaster does not have a standard connector, so neither should my iphone"? I mean, maybe they should, or maybe none cares to regulate toasters. Or maybe its only relevant to portable electronics, so laptops should have them but toasters shouldn't. Think a bit broader - if apple wants to introduce a new phone communication standard, like 5g but different? It can't - frequencies are allocated for a specific purpose, and none will give you any for a proprietary protocol only you control. This is not such a revolutionary idea if you look at a broader picture
- scarface74 7y agoIf Apple introduced a phone that didn’t comply with the 5G standard it wouldn’t be able to interoperate and would be less useful. But the government didn’t mandate that iMessage had to be compatible with SMS (even though it is somewhat) nor did they mandate that AirDrop had to interoperate with a standard. Should the government also mandate a standard messaging protocol must be used or that it has to work with SMS? Should FaceTime be forced to be interoperable?
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoApple would not even be allowed to sell a phone that had a standard it invented in house, as it would cause interference with other radio equipment. Radio frequencies are some of the most strictly regulated things on the planet, and misusing them will land you in jail in most countries.
- scarface74 7y ago