3 ms·
Last I tried WhatsApp it refused to let me use it without giving it access to my entire contact list. Even when “giving it access” to a blank list via PrivacyGu
by taneq 7y ago
Last I tried WhatsApp it refused to let me use it without giving it access to my entire contact list. Even when “giving it access” to a blank list via PrivacyGuard, I couldn’t see a way to add a contact manually. That was a deal breaker for me.
- huhtenberg 7y agoThat's hardly surprising. Contact list access is literally THE thing that makes WhatsApp valuable to Facebook. You lock down that and they are now staring at a massive hosting bill with nothing in return.
- phh 7y agoI think that the actual discussion's metadata is more valuable that the contact list itself. Knowing that I discuss everyday with X, is more interesting than to know that I somehow have the phone number of A,B,C,D...X,Y,Z. But yeah I agree that's not surprising. When I personnally hit this issue I was like "ain't that a good old facebook product behind all that fresh paint"
- ElectronShak 7y agoI think this helps prevent spamming, If I could add anyone manually, spamming a set of random phone numbers would be easy.
- taneq 7y agoI was willing to let it have my phone number, which is the thing that would cut down spamming (as a hard-to-generate-in-bulk identifier). I just wasn't willing to give it my contact list.
- icebraining 7y agoOn the contrary; having to type each in Whatsapp is much harder than just bulk importing to Android contacts, which you can do by the thousands at once.
- dTal 7y agoYou used to be able to set up different user profiles on Android - I set one up just for WhatsApp, and only WhatsApp contacts went in it. I am dismayed to find that my new Android phone no longer has this feature, except as part of some bullshit "work profile" nonsense that apparently isn't possible for me to set up by myself, on my own phone. "You'll need a code from your IT admin", I'm told, and "a management tool will be downloaded and used by your IT admin to manage your work profile". Great.
- nikhilgk 7y agoYou can use shelter (https://f-droid.org/en/packages/net.typeblog.shelter/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/net.typeblog.shelter/) or Island (https://island.oasisfeng.com/ https://island.oasisfeng.com/) to get work profiles on regular android phones.
- icebraining 7y agoYeah. My approach has been to ask others to add me instead. If I ever meet another privacy-minded friend, I guess we'll just use Signal instead.
- AdmiralAsshat 7y agoSame. I had a visiting relative from overseas who needed to contact me and WhatsApp was their only means, but despite installing the thing and using my Google Voice Number to register, the thing refused to let me do anything without giving the thing carte blanche access to my contacts. No thanks. I had to ask my spouse to use her existing WhatsApp profile to contact the number. There's zero technical reason why I can't have a silo'd list of contacts WITHIN WhatsApp. Facebook knows it. Fuck them.