9 ms·
Exactly right. And every time a property is turned over, the base tax rate gets reset, plus prop 13 allows for a 2% increase every year. California has the high
by fortran77 7y ago
Exactly right. And every time a property is turned over, the base tax rate gets reset, plus prop 13 allows for a 2% increase every year. California has the highest sales and income tax (for incomes over $500,000) in the Nation. They don't need the highest property tax, too.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoThe reason California has the highest sales and income taxes is that it has the lowest property tax. People who have held property for a very long time are taxed very little relative to how they would be taxed in other states, and people who are new are taxed a lot.
- fortran77 7y agoCalifornia does NOT have the lowest property tax. It is very distasteful for you to try to win an argument by lying. http://www.tax-rates.org/taxtables/property-tax-by-state http://www.tax-rates.org/taxtables/property-tax-by-state And if you rank the states by percentage revenue from property tax, you'll see they are right in the middle https://www.urban.org/policy-centers/cross-center-initiatives/state-and-local-finance-initiative/projects/state-and-local-backgrounders/property-taxes https://www.urban.org/policy-centers/cross-center-initiative...
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoIt is also very distasteful to accuse others of lying. It's about the least charitable assumption you could make, and therefore against the site guidelines. Not everyone who disagrees with you is lying. Not everyone who disagrees with you and is factually wrong is lying. Some repeat what they've heard. Some just lazily assume without doing the research. Some mis-remember. State that they're mistaken. Cite the evidence. But don't claim that they're lying unless you can prove that they are deliberately stating what is false.
- generalpass 7y ago> California does NOT have the lowest property tax. It is very distasteful for you to try to win an argument by lying. (moderators @dang) > http://www.tax-rates.org/taxtables/property-tax-by-state http://www.tax-rates.org/taxtables/property-tax-by-state > And if you rank the states by percentage revenue from property tax, you'll see they are right in the middle > https://www.urban.org/policy-centers/cross-center-initiative.. https://www.urban.org/policy-centers/cross-center-initiative.... Since the California median home price is more than double the national average for median home prices, your two claims seem clearly to not tell the whole story. What prop 13 does is keep tax rates from increasing beyond a very small percentage of the original purchase price. Thus, property values increase by a lot while taxes collected do not. So the first sentence is sort of true. Anecdotal, but a guy on my street purchased his property with no house on it in the 70s and pays like $100 per year even though it is easily worth over a million, which will heavily skew the stats. The second sentence is completely true: > People who have held property for a very long time are taxed very little relative to how they would be taxed in other states, and people who are new are taxed a lot.
- dang 7y ago> It is very distasteful for you to try to win an argument by lying Whoa. Please edit personal swipes out of your comments here. Your comment would be fine without that bit. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- lern_too_spel 7y agoIt is very misleading of you to post aggregate statistics when people who have owned property a long time pay very different property taxes from people who have not, as I stated in my earlier post.
- neilparikh 7y agoThe property tax in Palo Alto is 0.42%, which is less than 48 states in US. So, not dead last, but I think you can agree that it's pretty close.
- amunicio 7y ago>> They don't need the highest property tax, too. Prop 13 doesn't change the property tax rate, it changes WHO pays the full "nub" rate and who enjoys a "nobility" rebate. It disincentives home owners from moving, even when their new jobs are far away, increasing commuting time. It also creates a resource allocation imbalance. Folks that are retired and don't benefit so much by living in highly concentrated job areas tend to remain there. Even when younger people who would benefit more from living in these areas would be willing to pay more, providing an incentive for retired owners to move to a less concentrated area and making a profit. But with Prop 13, we have instead a system that artificially distorts the housing market(and not in a "just" or "deserving" way).
- fortran77 7y agoSo a retired person should be forced to move from his little 3 bedroom house because some Googler decided the house next door was worth $3.5MM and his property tax goes up to $75,000/year? That's pure evil. I fully supported SB50. Build. More. Housing.
- amunicio 7y ago>> So a retired person should be forced to move from his little 3 bedroom house because some Googler decided the house next door was worth $3.5MM and his property tax goes up to $75,000/year? That's pure evil. Nope. A retired person should have the CHOICE to pocket the $3.5MM the Googler is ready to pay for his house in Palo Alto and buy an even fancier house in Livermore knowing that his property taxes is not going to substantially change much. But with the present system instead, another Googler, let say the food service employee, will never be able to pay the mortgage for a one room apartment PLUS exorbitant "nub" real state taxes. At least the retired guy has a large amount of equity in the house and choices.
- refurb 7y agoYeah, I feel really sorry for the retired person sitting on millions of dollars of equity. Real sob story. Why not just give the option to defer increases in property taxes? It makes zero sense to give tax breaks to people who won the housing lottery.
- Apocryphon 7y agoHow about repealing Prop 13, and replacing it with a land value tax? https://www.econlib.org/land-taxes-the-return-of-henry-george/ https://www.econlib.org/land-taxes-the-return-of-henry-georg...