3 ms·
No it won't. It would displace even more people. The only way to get lower-cost housing is to build more housing. It's that simple.
by fortran77 7y ago
No it won't. It would displace even more people.
The only way to get lower-cost housing is to build more housing. It's that simple.
- btilly 7y agoYes, it will. One of the problems with housing is that local governments get less revenue from housing than business. That gives them every incentive to approve commercial construction and deny residential. Take away the financial perverse incentive., and there is a lot of money to be made by approving badly needed dense residential housing near existing commercial buildings.
- wahern 7y agoProp 13 also applies to commercial real estate. The difference is that commercial properties require fewer public services, so costs are less. But the real difference is that there's usually much less NIMBY opposition to changes in commercial zoning than residential. Talk is cheap. What matters is who shows up to zoning board meetings. People tend to only show up when it effects their neighborhood, not so much when it effects the business district a mile down the road. Likewise for voting preferences. Rescinding Prop 13 is unlikely to change anything because assessed values will be even more if developers can build bigger, multifamily dwellings in the neighborhood. So, yes, taxes would go up, but the local pressure to restrict zoning won't change as the incentives still line up the same way relatively.
- deepakhj 7y agoZoning meetings happen in the middle of the day. The only people that can go are old people!
- wahern 7y agoAlso rich people and neighborhood associations, who send their lawyers. And some poor and ethnic neighborhoods, who send their community activists.
- btilly 7y agoFigures that I saw estimate that local tax revenue from commercial property averages double that from residential. That's a pretty big incentive for a city to attract business and not attract residential. To take the example that you just latched on to, if rezoning the land makes it worth more, and therefore increases local taxes, this becomes an incentive for the city to balance its budget by rezoning. And some of that rezoned land will get dense residential living. Which will reduce traffic congestion. And make everyone's lives better.
- claudeganon 7y agoIt’s not that simple because the housing that gets built in areas with the worse affordability crises is high-end stock that gets bought up as an investment or cash store. “The market” has decided that in an era of extreme inequality and stagnant wages that the only way to recoup investment is targeting this segment, leaving everyone else in dire straits. (Unless you’re talking about the government building massive amounts of social housing to account for the market failure, in which case I agree).
- ummonk 7y agoEven most high end housing ends up getting occupied. This takes high income / wealthy people out of the market for existing housing stock, helping reduce market prices for existing housing.
- mc32 7y agoGrandfather them (current owners) in till it’s sold and all new units are outside prop 13.
- clairity 7y agorather than a wholesale grandfathering, you can just defer the additional tax owed until a sale, when proceeds would be available to pay the tax.