3 ms·
People mistakenly calculate %2 and %50 simultaneously because they assume that when a case is confirmed the death or cured status is also determined at that mom
by mrtksn 7y ago
People mistakenly calculate %2 and %50 simultaneously because they assume that when a case is confirmed the death or cured status is also determined at that moment.
In reality, though, people who are going to die don't die at the moment of infection confirmation and people who are going to live do lag in the log because it takes time to confirm if someone has recovered and virus-free.
Some will suggest to simply compare the deaths to the confirmed case from a week? ago but this assumes that the patients are admitted at the same stage of their infection and all cases at the time are accounted for(deaths are probably much better tracked than the infection and the publicity has a huge impact on the reporting). It would be a guesstimate at best.
I would say, let's stick to official numbers since the calculation requires each patients timeline. Surely an educated guess can be constructed by modelling the patient prognosis and virus behaviour but that also requires much more data than what the public has.
- mrb 7y ago«assume that when a case is confirmed the death or cured status is also determined at that moment» This is why epidemiologists (ref: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/ebf2/48c9fc0a1a23d1778b94083319aa995e34f4.pdf https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/ebf2/48c9fc0a1a23d1778b9408... or https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22195827 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22195827 for my comment on the paper) prefer instead this formula which only counts patients for which the eventual outcome is already known: deaths / (deaths + recoveries) With this formula, there is no need to guess the "patient timeline". If you do the math right now for the largest case study known to date (published yesterday: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(20)30211-7/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6... covering 99 patients, 11 dead, 31 recovered) you get: 11 / (11 + 31) = 26% case fatality rate If you do the math on ALL data from mainland China (170 deads, 124 recovered as of 2020-01-29 http://www.nhc.gov.cn/xcs/yqtb/202001/e71bd2e7a0824ca69f87bbf1bef2a3c9.shtml http://www.nhc.gov.cn/xcs/yqtb/202001/e71bd2e7a0824ca69f87bb... or in english: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_2019%E2%80%9320_Wuhan_coronavirus_outbreak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_2019%E2%80%932...), you get: 170 / (170 + 124) = 58% case fatality rate This formula gives a pretty good estimate of the eventual observed CFR according to the paper I referenced above. Of course, there are caveats, for one deaths or recoveries may not be properly tracked: there could be many patients with mild cases that are not even detected/confirmed and end up recovering on their own. PS: I am not stating the lower bound CFR is 26%! Another method I applied (described in twitter thread https://twitter.com/zorinaq/status/1222427708723879936 https://twitter.com/zorinaq/status/1222427708723879936) suggest it could be as low as 9%.
- mrtksn 7y agoWhat exactly a margin of %9 to %56 tells us anyway?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- akiselev 7y agoNothing conclusive but if a new disease emerges has a mortality rate even approaching 9% and a basic reproduction number (R0) of 1 or greater, it's a significant cause for concern. Combined with the incubation period, asymptomatic transmission, and the population density in which the outbreaks occurred, in this case it's enough to declare a global public health emergency.
- BoiledCabbage 7y agoThe problem is that the method that you use and the paper referenced (https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/ebf2/48c9fc0a1a23d1778b94083319aa995e34f4.pdf https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/ebf2/48c9fc0a1a23d1778b9408...) only applies the calculation on data 3 weeks, 4 weeks and 5 weeks after the epidemic has peaked. Of course you can get valid data once things have peaked and are slowing down. The issue is trying to get valid data while still in the exponential growth portion. And it seems like this method would have all the same flaws as other methods on rapidly changing data (if not worse due to the lag between recovery and deaths.). I'm not an epidemiologist, but I believe I see flaws in your application of the methods from the paper. [1] At the bottom page 481 it clearly say the virus peaked on March 27th. The first date they use data for the e2 calculation is April 6th. Two full weeks past the peak.
- aqme28 7y agoPatient timelines still matter. It takes longer to recover than it does to die, so it would make sense to compare current recoveries with the number of deaths from several days ago. But without knowing the patient timeline, I couldn't tell you how many.
- 7y ago