4 ms·
I don't see any comments regarding the bigger picture. The main reason that this is bad is that the more rural / red states will be able to block ANY federal j
by NineTimes 7y ago
I don't see any comments regarding the bigger picture. The main reason that this is bad is that the more rural / red states will be able to block ANY federal judicial nominee which it doesn't agree with. This means that no matter how liberal the country might become, that political philosophy will NOT be realized in the court system.
The tyranny of the majority is a concern, but the tyranny of a small minority is more of a concern.
One way to mitigate this would be to increase the size of the house to around 700 members. (But that isn't going to happen either.)
Eventually, we will have to have another constitutional convention to correct the imbalance. Heaven help us then.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> One way to mitigate this would be to increase the size of the house to around 700 members. (But that isn't going to happen either.) That won't mitigate it. Who gets to confirm judicial appointments? The Senate, not the House. > Eventually, we will have to have another constitutional convention to correct the imbalance. Heaven help us then. Yeah. I'm not sure that a constitutional convention is what I want to see. One good thing that could come from it is confirming that the 10th Amendment actually means what it says, not what it's been interpreted to mean. Or (perhaps the same thing) that the Commerce Clause is not the blank check that it's been interpreted to be. In my view, those would be good. But a lot that's bad could also come... The other way to do it would be a constitutional amendment. For that to happen, you'd have to get 3/4 of the states to ratify it. For that to happen, they'd have to decide that they'd be, at least, no worse off under the new system. Building a new system where the Senate doesn't confirm judges (or where the Senate is per-population instead of per-state), and still leaving the less populated states no worse off... what are you going to give them in exchange?
- NineTimes 7y agoSurprisingly, the only remaining clause of the constitution which cannot be changed by another amendment is that each state will have equal representation in the Senate. (See article 5 of the constitution.) Removing the advise and consent power and moving it to the house is a good idea which would mitigate the judicial problem.
- anthonypasq 7y ago"tyranny of the majority" is an oxy-moron. It makes zero sense. Of course the majority gets to decide what happens, that how government works. Only in America do we think that the party that won the election shouldnt be able to actually run the government.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThey do get to run it - within limits. Some of the limits are constitutional. Things that are not withing the power of the government are not within its power even when the majority wants to do them.
- thoughtstheseus 7y agoParties do not win elections, people do.
- blotter_paper 7y agoDisagree; parties win elections, people lose them.
- blotter_paper 7y ago> Of course the majority gets to decide what happens, that how government works. That's how some governments work some of the time. Even in modern democracies governments often entrench some values which they purposefully make difficult for a majority to overrule, and this is not something that America came up with. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supermajority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supermajority No presciptive statements have been made in this comment.