3 ms·
This touches on a problem I've been thinking about a lot. AWS, etc, have solved the problem of hardware operation. Containerization is doing the same for OS ope
by wpietri 7y ago
This touches on a problem I've been thinking about a lot. AWS, etc, have solved the problem of hardware operation. Containerization is doing the same for OS operation. I think the next thing is app operation.
For some things, I'm happy to use SaaS providers, where they are responsible for the whole stack. For others, I'm happy to use apps, where they just provide the code, and I provide the platform. But for a number of things, I want something in between: I provide storage and compute, they provide code and operations.
Bitwarden for me is a good example. They're a password manager who provides their backend as a docker container anybody can run. I like that, as I don't really want them to have my data, and if they go out of business, I don't want to be cut off from my passwords. But I won't run the backend myself, because I don't have the time and expertise necessary to make sure it stays secure.
Another good example is photo hosting. I would rather keep all my photos on space I control. But I also need modern, maintained software for syncing, serving, and controlling access to photos and related data. I'm happy to pay somebody to make and maintain that software, but not nearly as happy if that means that at any point they might shut down and take my data with them.
I suspect we're headed toward a future where people like Synology and Digital Ocean sell storage+compute, and then other companies sell and maintain user-selected software that runs on those environments. Basically, some sort of app store for servers. But I'd love to see this happen in an open, nonproprietary way, as the drawbacks of Apple's and Google's app stores have become pretty clear.
- omnimus 7y agoMaybe something like this https://remotestorage.io/ https://remotestorage.io/ becomes popular. I would love to make apps that use user owned universal storage/server.
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoSandstorm was a really nice solution to this, but it required each app to be integrated with it, which I personally think is what killed it. (Which sucked, because for what it supported it was the best option available)
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoPlease don't past-tense Sandstorm! The community is still working on it. Albeit a little slower. ;)
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoI actually didn't realize that. I think I confluated the death of Oasis with Sandstorm in general. I'll have to poke into running it:) Thanks for the correction!
- wpietri 7y agoAh, interesting! Just reading the home page wearing my developer hat makes this stand out: "Each document, chat room, mail box, notebook, blog, or anything else you create is a "grain" in Sandstorm. Sandstorm containerizes each one in its own secure sandbox from which it cannot talk to the world without express permission." The notion that every document is its own independent unit sounds pretty menacing to me. Could be fine for some things, but getting things running there is sounding like a fair bit of work to me, and very limited. And then this part is especially bad: "[maybe someday] You won't have to deal with payments | Eventually, we hope to make Sansdtorm implement in-app purchases and deposit the proceeds directly to your bank account" Right there a lot of incentive to integrate has leaked out. "Please build for our platform in exchange for no money" is not quite the worst offer I've had, but it's definitely not appealing. Looking through the Wayback machine, I see But the part that really concerns me is that they seem to think that server apps can run like mobile apps. To me one of the most powerful things about SaaS products is that the aggregated use information drives both product and operational improvements and allows rapid response to bugs and issues. So as a developer choosing between this and a SaaS approach, this feels like having one foot in a bucket to me. For example, I recently outsourced my mail hosting to Fastmail precisely because I want experts to run things. Would I be happier if the data were stored somewhere I control? Definitely. But not if that means the experts aren't paying attention anymore.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoSandstorm's design is a little bit menacing! And it does require a fair bit of work sometimes to fit web apps not built for Sandstorm into Sandstorm's model. (The holy grail here is apps built for Sandstorm, but the platform needs to be bigger before more developers do that.) Usually packaging for Sandstorm largely entails locking an app into a single-document model, and stripping out authentication (since Sandstorm handles it). But the end goal is pretty well worth it: Any grain is incredibly secure by default, and for the most part, app vulnerabilities are irrelevant. A grain where only you have access doesn't need any sort of authentication or security in the app at all. And since each document is it's own sandbox, sharing a document with someone doesn't give them a way in to exploit access to your other documents as might happen with a vulnerability in a more traditional design. The business model story for selling Sandstorm apps isn't super great right now, you probably could have a licensing model that requested network access through the Powerbox to check the license or something, but in many cases, there's already a wide variety of great open source apps that are free and just frustrating to host and manage without a platform like Sandstorm (or Cloudron). (EDIT: Now that I think about it, Sandstorm used to have a paid license key/feature key system that made no callbacks, I think the licensing info was encrypted asymmetrically.) As for your support of SaaS data collection, I just can't really agree with you: People who want to give data to a developer can choose to do so, but I think it's ethically wrong to collect data without permission. (Sandstorm servers do have the ability to opt in to provide basic app usage data back to Sandstorm's development team.) I love FastMail, and have been an enthusiastic customer since 2016. :)