5 ms·
The F-117. Great story, was finished in budget and ahead of time. But then it was a black program without any political oversight. Basically a couple of brillia
by hef19898 7y ago
The F-117. Great story, was finished in budget and ahead of time. But then it was a black program without any political oversight. Basically a couple of brilliant engineers closed into a room with the sole task to built a stealth plane.
EDIT: They used components from the F-16 and F-15 programs. Being a black program, this was hidden in spare parts needs for these other planes. I have congress report lying around somewhere which complains about excess spare needs for the F-16 from that period. So, maybe some of the F-117 costs are driving costs of other programs.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoMy dad was convinced this was how they paid for UFOs. I really hope that's true, but I find it nearly impossible to believe our government would be competent enough to maintain secrecy.
- erulabs 7y agoWell at very least these USAF/USN Stealth jet programs are at least competent at secrecy. From an Occam's Razor perspective, it's almost certainly that UFOs are either strange optical aberrations in peoples camera lenses or experimental military aircraft, so in part I think I agree with your dad. Camera weirdness being more common than billion dollar black programs, and those being more common than apparent life in the universe.
- Zancarius 7y agoMy father worked in connection to some of these programs many years ago (long since retired), and his favorite quip was to suggest that a closer inspection of "real" UFOs would reveal a USAF roundel painted on the side. So, naturally, I'm inclined to believe that if any such thing were ever spotted, it would be the result of one of these programs.
- throw0101a 7y ago> Basically a couple of brilliant engineers closed into a room with the sole task to built a stealth plane. I think being able to focus was a big part of it. The F-35 (and F-32) is a 'kitchen sink' of a plane: multi-purpose sounds great in theory, but rarely works out in practice. Especially if you try shoehorning VTOL into the picture. If they had tried focusing on the F-35A and C variants, perhaps things should be less complicated.
- trhway 7y ago>I think being able to focus was a big part of it. The F-35 (and F-32) is a 'kitchen sink' of a plane: multi-purpose sounds great in theory, but rarely works out in practice. Especially if you try shoehorning VTOL into the picture. if you look into the history - F-35 started as VTOL, ie. Yak-141, as Lockheed didn't have any VTOL and needed a response to Boeing/Harrier - onto which the "kitchen sink" of everything else was shoehorned/bolted-on. The Yak-141 was never intended and never imagined to be a good fighter plane or a good attack plane, etc., its primary and the only raison d'etre was VTOL as USSR/Russia just hasn't been capable of having real aircraft carriers.
- cameldrv 7y agoThe F-117 had very limited requirements compared to the F-35. What's killing the F-35 is the extreme complexity of the program. The requirements for the F-117 were basically that it had to be stealthy, and had to be able to carry a minimal payload a reasonable range. There was no radar, no vertical takeoff, no carrier landings, no air-to-air, no sensor fusion, no datalinks, no cooperative engagement, etc etc etc. It's poorly understood how the combination of high performance requirements, complexity, and flexibility mix. Optimizing a system for performance generally requires cutting across domains. Subsystems need to be designed jointly to wring out performance. This means there are many dependencies between the subsystems, so if one thing changes on one subsystem, it may affect a number of other subsystems. If you then add flexibility to the mix -- you want a modular system like the F-35, all of this optimization work has to be done on every combination of parts. Now combine this with a complex set of mission requirements -- every change has to be optimized for multiple missions and multiple aircraft variants. Due to the optimized and complex nature of the aircraft, each change will also affect many subsystems. Because the system is so complex, no person or even a small group of people can have the entire system in their head, so it's hard to know exactly what will be affected with a subsystem change. Subsystems affected by a change will furthermore not even be built by the same company. This all means that each change has to go through very slow formal processes to make sure it keeps working. All of this is to say that layering on all of these categories of requirements has an exponential effect. If the F-35 didn't have to be high performance, or if it didn't have three variants, or if it didn't have to perform multiple missions, the project would have been much easier.
- tempestn 7y agoSo does it follow from that that the entire concept is flawed, and what should have been designed instead are multiple different aircraft?
- GVIrish 7y agoExactly this. The DoD basically took the mistakes of the F-111 program, doubled down on them, and added on some reckless new mistakes. The result is the most expensive weapons program in history.
- Godel_unicode 7y agoI know that it has an "f" in the designation and was called the "stealth fighter", but the f-117 was in no way a fighter.
- JustARandomGuy 7y agoDo you remember the name and date of that congressional report? Would love to read it.
- hef19898 7y agoThat's the one, sold through Amazon. But I guess you should be able to get it as a pdf somewhere as well: F-16 Integrated Logistics Support: Still Time to Consider Economical Alternatives: LCD-80-89