7 ms·
In about 20 years, half the population will live in eight states (2018)
- low_common 7y agoCan you link a snapshot behind the paywall?
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoDoes this work? http://web.archive.org/web/20200101022704/https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/politics/wp/2018/07/12/in-about-20-years-half-the-population-will-live-in-eight-states/ http://web.archive.org/web/20200101022704/https://www.washin... Somehow, I'm always able to view Washington Post articles without logging in or anything, but I know others seem to have trouble...
- OrangeMango 7y agoThe source for this article is here: http://statchatva.org/2019/02/11/national-population-projections-2020-2030-2040/ http://statchatva.org/2019/02/11/national-population-project... What is interesting is that despite their prediction of half the population living in 8 states, their prediction is that half of those states will have either lost population or have gained less than 200,000 people within the next 20 years (Pennsylvania, Illinois, Ohio, Michigan)! Edit, I am sorry, but I misinterpreted. The 4 states I mentioned are in their prediction of the 10 states with the highest population. Only Pennsylvania and Illinois are predicted to be among the 8 most populous states.
- thorwasdfasdf 7y agoThis will only exacerbate the housing problem, quite distopian if you ask me. it doesn't make sense to have everyone crowded into areas that didn't want to grow in the first place. I think the fed should give companies incentives to move to unpopulated states that actually want to grow, instead of handing out tax cuts like free candy.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoThese states still have a lot of land area, so I don't find this specific statistic so troubling from a housing perspective. I find it very, very scary however in terms of what it means for our political system. If half of the US population controls only 16 senate seats, and the other half controls 84 seats, how does the senate have any democratic legitimacy at all?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThe Senate isn't supposed to be a democratic institution. Once you understand that, you can quit being scared by the situation.
- jefurii 7y agoWhether or not you're okay about this says a lot about you.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoPerhaps, and not in the direction you think. We don't need the Senate to be the House. We already have the House for that. If you think that the Senate is the problem, that more House-like behavior is what we need, then what it says about you is that you don't understand the point behind the American system of government. The point was to not have too much direct democracy. If you don't understand why that was the point, yes, that says something about you.
- jefurii 7y agoOh I understand perfectly well the reason why the Senate and the Electoral College and superdelegates in e.g. the Democratic Party were created. It was because the founders were afraid of actual democracy and they wanted to ensure their own positions. It has had the effect that a certain constituency (rich white men) are privileged above all others. There is a disconnect between the narrative we have told ourselves about democracy and the actual system we have. I would like to change the system so that it better serves our entire population and not just rich white men.
- wnmurphy 7y agoWhich means half the population will cast votes which have less value than those of their fellow citizens, thanks to the Electoral College.
- shaftway 7y agoThis is already true, and is not an uncommon situation. This is akin to saying "half the population makes less than the mean income". But this is HN, so let's throw some numbers in to see how badly it's skewed already. The state with the lowest population-to-elector is Wyoming, with about 193,000 people per elector. The state with the highest is Florida with over 740,000 people per elector. So Wyomingans votes for president are over 3.8x more valuable than Floridians. The national average is around 580,000 people per elector, and Louisiana is pretty darn close, so I'm going to omit them from calculations. That leaves about 217,000,000 people in states that are higher (Georgia, California, Iowa, New York, Illinois, New Jersey, Washington, Maryland, Missouri, Oregon, Minnesota, Michigan, Wisconsin, Massachusetts, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Virginia, Colorado, North Carolina, and Florida), and 106,000,000 people in states that are lower (the others). I'm too lazy to list out common political affiliations, but they're not as clearly biased as you'd expect.
- tomatotomato37 7y agoAlso want to add that's still better than the EU's parliament balance between its members; Malta has 81,000 citizens per MEP versus the UK's 925,000 per MEP.
- Arnt 7y agoThis is HN, how about presenting an opinion about some preferable alternative? Do you think Malta's number of representatives should be cut to match the UK's, in which case it would have (less than) one member and any minority votes on Malta would be hopelessly lost and ignorable? Do you think the UK (and others) should be boosted to match Malta, in which case the EU parliament would have eleventy thousand representatives? Do you think some other scheme else would be better? We have a similar discrepance in Norway, BTW, where it basically doesn't matter. The least populous region has historically had less that 2% of the population and about 3% of the parliament seats, but the numbers are very small, haven't made a difference, and of course the issue exists precisely because the numbers are so small, so it can never grow to be a big discrepancy.
- dmux 7y agoPrevious discussion 2 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17529987 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17529987
- JohnFen 7y agoI checked if my state was one of the eight and breathed a huge sigh of relief that it wasn't.
- NineTimes 7y agoI don't see any comments regarding the bigger picture. The main reason that this is bad is that the more rural / red states will be able to block ANY federal judicial nominee which it doesn't agree with. This means that no matter how liberal the country might become, that political philosophy will NOT be realized in the court system. The tyranny of the majority is a concern, but the tyranny of a small minority is more of a concern. One way to mitigate this would be to increase the size of the house to around 700 members. (But that isn't going to happen either.) Eventually, we will have to have another constitutional convention to correct the imbalance. Heaven help us then.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> One way to mitigate this would be to increase the size of the house to around 700 members. (But that isn't going to happen either.) That won't mitigate it. Who gets to confirm judicial appointments? The Senate, not the House. > Eventually, we will have to have another constitutional convention to correct the imbalance. Heaven help us then. Yeah. I'm not sure that a constitutional convention is what I want to see. One good thing that could come from it is confirming that the 10th Amendment actually means what it says, not what it's been interpreted to mean. Or (perhaps the same thing) that the Commerce Clause is not the blank check that it's been interpreted to be. In my view, those would be good. But a lot that's bad could also come... The other way to do it would be a constitutional amendment. For that to happen, you'd have to get 3/4 of the states to ratify it. For that to happen, they'd have to decide that they'd be, at least, no worse off under the new system. Building a new system where the Senate doesn't confirm judges (or where the Senate is per-population instead of per-state), and still leaving the less populated states no worse off... what are you going to give them in exchange?
- NineTimes 7y agoSurprisingly, the only remaining clause of the constitution which cannot be changed by another amendment is that each state will have equal representation in the Senate. (See article 5 of the constitution.) Removing the advise and consent power and moving it to the house is a good idea which would mitigate the judicial problem.