3 ms·
There's two part pressure needed for every change: good alternatives and disincentives for the old option.
by jvanderbot 7y ago
There's two part pressure needed for every change: good alternatives and disincentives for the old option.
- BurningFrog 7y agoEmpirically, I don't see that at all. Usually a better alternative will make the old thing obsolete without any disincentives.
- jvanderbot 7y agoIMHO, facts don't sell anything. Defining an option as better isn't sufficient. Disincentives for the status quo are not necessarily taxes or legislation. A powerful disincentive is "missing out" on a "movement" or "being left behind". Adding busses doesn't feel like a "movement", but car-less cities has a nice Green Dream ring to it that might garner support from the right demographics by allowing a moral high ground. There will be increasing disincentive pressure against neighborhoods that allow cars, by a migration of commercial business to car-less areas, perhaps, or a loss of property values in those car-packed areas. But for those disincentives to be effective, they should be given time in the spotlight.
- hrktb 7y agoThis only works if better alternatives don’t impact the existing means. For instance if you want a good cable car system or dedicated bus lanes, bike paths, it will go through reducing or removing private car lanes. In general it’s both effects in one go: transform/reduce the existing infra into the new one, automatically making the new one better when it lands (and inconveniencing everyone until it lands)