3 ms·
> USB connectors do not have the optical isolation of MIDI current loops; USB interconnecting will bring in noisy ground loops that will have musicians and reco
by derefr 7y ago
> USB connectors do not have the optical isolation of MIDI current loops; USB interconnecting will bring in noisy ground loops that will have musicians and recording engineers pulling out their hair.
Isn't MIDI... digital? What do ground loops matter as long as the signal decodes?
Or do you mean that they'll put current into the analogue signal chain?
IMHO, the correct response to that is to do all hybrid analogue+digital signal processing in the digital domain with opto-isolated pre-amp ADCs, no?
- kazinator 7y agoMIDI connects all sorts of gear, a lot of which contains analog signal paths. That's why its design is the way it is. For instance, rack-mounted synthesizer with analog outputs going to a PA.
- drderidder 7y agoIt matters a bunch. All kinds of noise can get picked up over cables and bleed into your audio path on a digital rig. It happens all the time just with power cables which is why every musician carries a handful of "ground lifts" even though they're technically illegal in a lot of places. That said, MIDI over USB is kind of necessary in this day and age. Hopefully instrument manufacturers will be rigorous about isolating any interference it could pick up.
- pjc50 7y agoGround loops can end up with a surprising amount of current. They're also very good at emitting hum into other nearby devices.