4 ms·
I'm one of your dad's generation and we like to call this "inter-generational theft" because it kind-of sums it up: the spending patterns we established, are pr
by ggm 7y ago
I'm one of your dad's generation and we like to call this "inter-generational theft" because it kind-of sums it up: the spending patterns we established, are predicated on leaving our kids (and grandkids, probably) worse off. Not because of a debt burden, there is nothing wrong with long term public sector debt financing.
The problem is the asset bubble in home ownership prices. We should have 10+ year secured residential tenancies and rent controls in place, and put home ownership back into the 3-5% compounding asset class. Sydney and Melbourne is insane. Brisbane (where I live) is better, but only just.
I worry about Hobart: the longterm income levels in Tasmania are not going to keep up, the price of housing there is creating a huge social dislocation issue.
- gowld 7y agoWhat happens to those houses when you die? Are they mortgaged with no equity? If you leave an inheritance, you are giving the wealth back/forward.
- sgc 7y agoAnd what happens when people live longer and longer, so that people have lived a longer percentage of their lives without that influx of assets? It is perfectly common for 60+ year olds to still have their parents living. That will stretch to 70 year olds, and so on. There is a demographic concern that needs to be acknowledged in order to develop societal solutions that provide even basic opportunities such as home ownership at an age when you are raising your own family. One potential contribution to a solution would be to tax investment properties/second homes at a very different rate than primary dwellings (which should be taxed at as close to 0% as is practically possible). This would help reduce compounding the effect of demographics with investment portfolio concerns. If governments are to be at the service of their citizens first and foremost, it makes sense to me that they also have a specific tax rate or other restrictions on property ownership by foreign investors. If those things are not legal, then laws should be changed. They exist in some form in many countries, but not all. I doubt those opinions are popular, but at least they are worth thinking about.
- leetcrew 7y ago> One potential contribution to a solution would be to tax investment properties/second homes at a very different rate than primary dwellings (which should be taxed at as close to 0% as is practically possible). as a renter, that doesn't sound like a good solution to me. my landlord would just pass through the "investment property" tax to me, while homeowners in my income bracket would be getting a fat tax break. people should be assessed a property tax that roughly approximates the local services they consume. after that, we can think about credits for people who are genuinely struggling to make ends meet.
- sgc 7y agoI understand the renter dilemma. The goal would be to propel you towards home ownership. If taxes were higher on investment properties purchase prices would get pushed down, thereby reducing the amount your landlord would need to charge for rent. Rent will go up with inflation regardless, since landlords optimize for profit. But all of a sudden there is less of a difference between what rent costs and a mortgage payment. it is easier to jump out of the renter's cycle. And that means less demand and lower rents for those who remain, creating a virtuous cycle. In the medium term (5 years plus) this would keep rents flat or lower, and reduce housing prices at the same time. At the same time there is a basic philosophy I espouse that all people have a right to a home and a piece of land, and unless absolutely necessary to society, they should not be renting from the government. I agree that there need to be several other programs in place to support lower income individuals, including in respect to primary residences, but that is an expanded conversation in a election year ;).
- leetcrew 7y agoso I have two main objections here. the first is that tax breaks for homeowners tend to benefit the middle class at the expense of those who are just below the threshold to qualify for a mortgage. unless you just give them the money or have the government guarantee their debt, this is going to be a problem. if your idea works really well and housing prices drop a lot, this could be a pretty small group, but it's still worth thinking about imo. my second (and very self-interested) reason, is that I don't want to be propelled towards home ownership. if I really wanted to I could buy a home now (and probably break even; I live in a low price-to-rent area), but I like renting. I'm quite happy in a 700 sq ft apartment, and I don't want the work that comes with a larger dwelling. I'm not exactly hurting for money, but I just don't see a compelling reason why the alternate version of me who bought a house deserves a tax break. I'm not sure I'm convinced by your argument that this policy would also lower my rent, but I'm not an economist so I can't really say. > At the same time there is a basic philosophy I espouse that all people have a right to a home and a piece of land, and unless absolutely necessary to society, they should not be renting from the government. just wanted to say I can certainly respect this, but I have a very different philosophy. land, especially in cities, is one of the only truly scarce things in the world, and its value depends almost entirely on what other people are doing near you. in our era of prosperity, I can agree that people should be entitled to a place to live, but I don't believe they should get to control a specific plot indefinitely.
- thundergolfer 7y ago> you are giving the wealth back/forward. But it's now much more concentrated. Over time my family and dad's best friends family have ~5 houses and apartments each. When they die there'll be ~5 places split between 3 children and 2 children respectively. Easy to see how that's not rebalancing things much.
- thorwasdfasdf 7y ago3-5% is unrealistic. in the long long term, housing prices can't exceed inflation (roughly 2%). and if we were to actually make progress in building houses/shelter, then it would be even less than inflation.
- Rury 7y ago>Not because of a debt burden, there is nothing wrong with long term public sector debt financing. To an extent... >The problem is the asset bubble in home ownership prices. I just want to point out that these two are, are somewhat tied together as of the recent decade. A lot of central banks around the world have been doing QE type things, which consists of printing money in exchange for taking assets off the market in (supposedly) equivalent value until they (central banks) are repaid the printed money to destroy. This arguably causes inflation - not in the traditional sense, but in the form of asset price bubbles. The reason they're doing this stuff is because of the lack of liquidity in the market regarding financing debts. In the US in particular, a large part of the FED's balance sheet is composed of mortgage backed securities (houses) and government debt (bonds) which money was printed for... Anyhow, the point I’m trying to make here, is that the public debt burden we have is a contributing factor to the asset bubbles we see in housing and stocks and other areas...